I plan to target him as the first defensive player taken just because of the advantage he gives my team.

Over R Lewis, J Peppers, E Reed, etc!??!
With my league's scoring, McGee scored 182 points for the season, Lewis had 116 points, Peppers had 121 points, and Reed had 127 points. I know he may not match those numbers but being slated to be the starting CB and return kicks gives him just as many opportunities as last year. I draft in the 11th spot this year and I'm looking to take the McGee and Lewis or Urlacher after the turn. Believe me, I won several games last year just because of McGee's performance...I won't hesitate to take him again. Even with a moderate decrease in his stats, he will still be a top 5 IDP.
I stand corrected...Your league's scoring system is extremely unique. Kick-returning must really supercharge a player's scoring for McGee to net 50% more pts than
all of the top-scoring IDP's. Thanks for the clarification.
OK, back to your question. I would take a look at the following players:
* Azumah (CHI): Smith has stated that Azumah will remain the team's #1 KR, despite Azumah's recent hip surgery. If healthy, Azumah will start opposite Tillman.
* Groce (StL): Butler's replacement opposite Fisher. Groce may be the Rams' PR.
* Terrence Newman (DAL): The chance of him returning punts is getting remote, but he is still getting reps.
* Allen Rossum (ATL): Rossum returns both kicks and punts. He could be only one injury away from starting. Keep in mind that DeAngelo Hall's hip has been bothering him (...and Hall missed last season with a hip injury).
* Justin Miller (NYJ): With Ty Law on board, Miller's chance to start is very slim. However, the chance of Law staying healthy for 16 games may also be slim. Miller could very well return both kicks and punts for the Jets.
* Deltha O'Neal (CIN): O'Neal will probably be ignored in the return game, but injuries could change the Bengals' stance on his involvement. O'Neal was a monster in the return game for the Broncos and is the bona-fide starter opposite Tory James.
* Phillip Buchanan (HOU): If Swinton fails, Buchanan could easily be inserted into the return game. Buchanan's mouth is more than his game, but there's no denying his athletic ability.
* Darrett Williams (DEN): Much like Rossum, Williams is only one injury away from maybe starting. It appears as if Williams has a head-start on both the kick and punt return jobs in DEN. Plus, Lenny Walls has a difficult time staying healthy with multiple shoulder injuries last year.
* Fabian Washington (OAK): It appears as if Washinton will play behind Asomugha for much of the '05 season. However, he may get the nod as the team's PR in the meantime.