145 - Broadchurch
Chaos34 11
Top score. Thought it would rank quite a bit higher by appearing on more lists, but figured I'd have it highest. If you haven't seen it, it's a surprisingly intense ride for the beautiful setting. One of my considerations for ranking anything this high was would I or have I watched it more than once. My two top rated shows are the two I've rewatched the most.
I haven't rewatched Broadchurch. No need. An intricate deeply emotional and involved plot unfolds with David Tennant and Olivia Coleman giving what afaik is their best performances. That's saying something. It's the resolution of that plot that keeps you thinking and watching but once it resolves, as well done as it is, rewatching just can't provide its best feature: The emotional investment in the outcome. That may describe quite a few shows you've seen. It's just stronger here.
As some of you ranked shows because it worked for both you and your spouse. this was one of the first that worked for me and my daughter. Single dad, sole custody - we still talk about it some and laugh about how one of us getting ahead of the other was a very big problem. Good times. Good life lessons for the kid. Soundtrack as intense as the story. It led me down a continuing rabbit hole of British television shows, many on my list.