This is why Footballguys is superior. (1 Viewer)

[MechEng]

WR tiers from Fox

Reading these I thought they were a joke.

 

[loose circuits]

Calvin at 15 is insane

 

[PatsFanCT]

WR tiers from Fox

Reading these I thought they were a joke.

Based on...?It's still a crap shoot. Nobody knows how they will finish, so anybody's guess is just as good as the other. For the most part, they are pretty close to all the other sites out there, including FBG.

 

[footballnerd]

FOX sports has been a joke for quite some time now when it comes to rankings.

 

[dapunisher]

WR tiers from Fox

Reading these I thought they were a joke.

Based on...?It's still a crap shoot. Nobody knows how they will finish, so anybody's guess is just as good as the other. For the most part, they are pretty close to all the other sites out there, including FBG.

I agree with PatsFanCT. I didn't think the rankings were that ludicrous.

 

[Giants4Life]

So because they differed from what everyone else says, that makes them a joke?

If Fox said last year "Forte is going to be the 20th best RB", you'd probably have called them a joke as well

 

[Wrigley]

WR tiers from Fox

Reading these I thought they were a joke.

Based on...?It's still a crap shoot. Nobody knows how they will finish, so anybody's guess is just as good as the other. For the most part, they are pretty close to all the other sites out there, including FBG.

I agree with PatsFanCT. I didn't think the rankings were that ludicrous.

I'm in this boat.

 

[Donsmith753]

Donnie Avery before Crabtree and Nicks does stick out though

 

[BroadwayG]

I don't mind anyone's tiers, but his rounds are way off. Unless this is for a start 2 WR league.

 

[billyjohnson]

WR tiers from Fox

Reading these I thought they were a joke.

Based on...?It's still a crap shoot. Nobody knows how they will finish, so anybody's guess is just as good as the other. For the most part, they are pretty close to all the other sites out there, including FBG.

 

[JB Breakfast Club]

looks fair and balanced to me

 

[dapunisher]

looks fair and balanced to me

 

[gandalas]

Roddy White that low seems a bit off to me as well...

 

[shredhead]

looks fair and balanced to me

It looks so fair and balanced that I think I'll print off numerous copies for my leaguemates.

 

[Cassius]

They look fine. Different, but lol @ calling FBG superior just because the FBG rankings are different from Fox's and you happen to subscribe to one of the two.

 

[bakes]

Roddy White that low seems a bit off to me as well...

Spends too much time on the left side of the field.

 

[brtdud7]

looks fair and balanced to me

Bill O'Reilly agrees

 

[footballnerd]

It gets better with their Top 300 rankings. I hope everyone takes Mathews over Andre Johnson!

 

[SSOG]

Based on...?It's still a crap shoot. Nobody knows how they will finish, so anybody's guess is just as good as the other. For the most part, they are pretty close to all the other sites out there, including FBG.

While I agree that different does not automatically equal wrong (or bad), I strongly disagree with the notion that "anybody's guess is just as good as the other". If I guess that Victor Cruz, Mike Williams, and Mike Williams will finish 1-2-3 in fantasy points this season, that guess is worse than pretty much any other "guess" out there. The process and reasoning behind it is far more flawed, and the likely outcome that it will result in is far worse. While we can't predict the future with perfect accuracy, that doesn't mean we can't handicap it with at least some minor semblance of rationality.

 

[Team ROFLCOPTERS]

Calvin at 15 is insane

Nicks at 28?I don't even read that stuff. Matrix's mean nothing to me without some sort of reasoning behind the choice. It's really irresponsible to do this.