Top 10 fantasy players since 2000 (1 Viewer)

[wiscstlatlmia]

Quarterback:

http://fantasy-footballu.com/zblog/2012/7/13/top-10-fantasy-players-since-2000-quarterbacks.html

Running back:

http://fantasy-footballu.com/zblog/2012/7/13/top-10-fantasy-players-since-2000-running-backs.html

Wide Receiver:

http://fantasy-footballu.com/zblog/2012/7/14/top-10-fantasy-players-since-2000-wide-receivers.html

 

[ZWK]

Where is Tiki Barber?

Daunte Culpepper should make the top 10. He had 4 seasons as a top 2 fantasy QB; Eli Manning's best finish is 5th.

 

[wiscstlatlmia]

Where is Tiki Barber?Daunte Culpepper should make the top 10. He had 4 seasons as a top 2 fantasy QB; Eli Manning's best finish is 5th.

Tiki Barber...should be #10 or #9... I'll give that to you, Maybe I'll go back later and switch out Fred Taylor.If Daunte Culpepper had even a good 3rd season to add on to the other two I would agree with you, but I just dont see it

 

[Sabertooth]

Love seeing both Rodgers and Favre on the list. As a Packers fan, we've been truly blessed by excellent QB play for the greater part of 20 years. I am 38 now, I was 18 I think when Favre entered the game for Majik. To think that my entire adult life has seen the Packers with not just good, but great QB play is truly amazing.

 

[ZWK]

Where is Tiki Barber?

Daunte Culpepper should make the top 10. He had 4 seasons as a top 2 fantasy QB; Eli Manning's best finish is 5th.

Tiki Barber...should be #10 or #9... I'll give that to you, Maybe I'll go back later and switch out Fred Taylor.If Daunte Culpepper had even a good 3rd season to add on to the other two I would agree with you, but I just dont see it

Culpepper was a top 2 fantasy QB in 2004, 2003, 2002, and 2000. He made the Pro Bowl in 3 of those years, and in the other one he ran for 600/10. In all 4 seasons he scored more fantasy points than Eli did in any season before 2011. And if you go by ppg, you can also put Culpepper's 2001 in there - he was 5th in ppg that year but missed 5 games.

 

[David Yudkin]

Since 2000, here were the Top 10 fantasy scorers at each position (based solely on total fantasy points) . . .

1 Peyton Manning 3729.2

2 Tom Brady 3217.9

3 Drew Brees 3133.1

4 Donovan McNabb 3098.5

5 Brett Favre 3007.2

6 Matt Hasselbeck 2449.9

7 Daunte Culpepper 2167.1

8 Ben Roethlisberger 2067.5

9 Eli Manning 2049.3

10 Jeff Garcia 2013.2

1 LaDainian Tomlinson 2852.8

2 Edgerrin James 1791.3

3 Shaun Alexander 1769.3

4 Tiki Barber 1692.0

5 Clinton Portis 1688.5

6 Thomas Jones 1687.2

7 Jamal Lewis 1620.6

8 Ahman Green 1618.7

9 Ricky Williams 1586.9

10 Steven Jackson 1573.8

1 Terrell Owens 2032.5

2 Randy Moss 1981.4

3 Torry Holt 1670.6

4 Hines Ward 1635.6

5 Marvin Harrison 1615.5

6 Reggie Wayne 1607.8

7 Derrick Mason 1535.8

8 Chad Ochocinco 1525.4

9 Steve Smith 1429.8

10 Larry Fitzgerald 1405.0

1 Tony Gonzalez 1633.4

2 Antonio Gates 1234.3

3 Jason Witten 1039.0

4 Jeremy Shockey 837.0

5 Todd Heap 835.6

6 Dallas Clark 768.7

7 Alge Crumpler 708.3

8 Chris Cooley 668.6

9 Kellen Winslow 622.3

10 Randy McMichael 593.6

Based on 75 games played, fantasy ppg . . .

1 Peyton Manning 21.19

2 Daunte Culpepper 20.84

3 Drew Brees 20.34

4 Donovan McNabb 19.99

4 Tom Brady 19.99

6 Kurt Warner 18.39

7 Jay Cutler 18.21

8 Philip Rivers 18.18

9 Ben Roethlisberger 17.98

10 Jeff Garcia 17.97

1 Priest Holmes 17.72

2 LaDainian Tomlinson 16.78

3 Marshall Faulk 15.64

4 Tiki Barber 15.38

5 Clinton Portis 14.94

6 Maurice Jones-Drew 14.66

7 Shaun Alexander 14.38

8 Ahman Green 13.72

9 Steven Jackson 13.69

10 Edgerrin James 13.57

1 Terrell Owens 12.95

2 Marvin Harrison 12.43

3 Calvin Johnson 11.89

4 Randy Moss 11.66

5 Larry Fitzgerald 11.33

6 Torry Holt 10.64

7 Marques Colston 10.61

8 Andre Johnson 10.52

9 Greg Jennings 10.36

10 Anquan Boldin 10.19

1 Antonio Gates 9.35

2 Tony Gonzalez 8.55

3 Jason Witten 7.27

4 Kellen Winslow 6.76

5 Vernon Davis 6.72

6 Dallas Clark 6.68

7 Chris Cooley 6.19

8 Jeremy Shockey 6.11

9 Owen Daniels 6.06

10 Todd Heap 5.88

 

[wiscstlatlmia]

Since 2000, here were the Top 10 fantasy scorers at each position (based solely on total fantasy points) . . .1 Peyton Manning 3729.2 2 Tom Brady 3217.9 3 Drew Brees 3133.1 4 Donovan McNabb 3098.5 5 Brett Favre 3007.2 6 Matt Hasselbeck 2449.9 7 Daunte Culpepper 2167.1 8 Ben Roethlisberger 2067.5 9 Eli Manning 2049.3 10 Jeff Garcia 2013.2 1 LaDainian Tomlinson 2852.8 2 Edgerrin James 1791.3 3 Shaun Alexander 1769.3 4 Tiki Barber 1692.0 5 Clinton Portis 1688.5 6 Thomas Jones 1687.2 7 Jamal Lewis 1620.6 8 Ahman Green 1618.7 9 Ricky Williams 1586.9 10 Steven Jackson 1573.8 1 Terrell Owens 2032.5 2 Randy Moss 1981.4 3 Torry Holt 1670.6 4 Hines Ward 1635.6 5 Marvin Harrison 1615.5 6 Reggie Wayne 1607.8 7 Derrick Mason 1535.8 8 Chad Ochocinco 1525.4 9 Steve Smith 1429.8 10 Larry Fitzgerald 1405.0 1 Tony Gonzalez 1633.4 2 Antonio Gates 1234.3 3 Jason Witten 1039.0 4 Jeremy Shockey 837.0 5 Todd Heap 835.6 6 Dallas Clark 768.7 7 Alge Crumpler 708.3 8 Chris Cooley 668.6 9 Kellen Winslow 622.3 10 Randy McMichael 593.6 Based on 75 games played, fantasy ppg . . .1 Peyton Manning 21.19 2 Daunte Culpepper 20.84 3 Drew Brees 20.34 4 Donovan McNabb 19.99 4 Tom Brady 19.99 6 Kurt Warner 18.39 7 Jay Cutler 18.21 8 Philip Rivers 18.18 9 Ben Roethlisberger 17.98 10 Jeff Garcia 17.97 1 Priest Holmes 17.72 2 LaDainian Tomlinson 16.78 3 Marshall Faulk 15.64 4 Tiki Barber 15.38 5 Clinton Portis 14.94 6 Maurice Jones-Drew 14.66 7 Shaun Alexander 14.38 8 Ahman Green 13.72 9 Steven Jackson 13.69 10 Edgerrin James 13.57 1 Terrell Owens 12.95 2 Marvin Harrison 12.43 3 Calvin Johnson 11.89 4 Randy Moss 11.66 5 Larry Fitzgerald 11.33 6 Torry Holt 10.64 7 Marques Colston 10.61 8 Andre Johnson 10.52 9 Greg Jennings 10.36 10 Anquan Boldin 10.19 1 Antonio Gates 9.35 2 Tony Gonzalez 8.55 3 Jason Witten 7.27 4 Kellen Winslow 6.76 5 Vernon Davis 6.72 6 Dallas Clark 6.68 7 Chris Cooley 6.19 8 Jeremy Shockey 6.11 9 Owen Daniels 6.06 10 Todd Heap 5.88

wow, good stuff David

 

[packseasontix]

Manning - 4th, 7th, 4th, 2nd, 2nd, 3rd, 1st, 3rd, 7th, 6th, 4th,

Brady - NR, 20th, 9th, 10th, 11th, 2nd, 7th, 1st, INJ (8th), 9th, 3rd, 3rd,

Brees - NR, NR, 19th, 27th, 9th, 8th, 3rd, 5th, 1st, 2nd, 6th, 2nd,

Rodgers - NR, NR, NR, NR, NR, NR, NR, NR, 2nd, 1st, 2nd, 1st,

Favre - 10th, 4th, 11th, 12th, 7th, 15th, 10th, 6th, 14th, 3rd, 29th, NR,

Culpepper - 1st, 13th, 2nd, 1st, 1st, 35th, 42nd, 34th, 38th, 37th, NR, NR,

Issues:

Culpepper had 4 top 2 finnishes

Length of Success

Brady over Brees (top 10- 8 each, Brady 1 extra QB1 numbers, Brees avg 4.5 when QB1, Brady 6.1 when QB1, you could factor in Cassel with 2008 injury and another year of top 10/QB1 numbers)

or

Rodgers over Brady/Brees due to 4 straights years of 1st or 2nd

The only edit I may have is to look at this from a QB team perspective

Manning - Painter

Favre - Rodgers (Packers)

Brady - Cassel

The reason I put out the QB team perspective is because if you had the roster size you may have already had the back-up ready to start. Obviously the 2nd two worked out great while the first one really sucked.

Personally I would rank:

Manning

Brady/Brees - Tie

Rodgers - to Young

Favre

Culpepper

McNabb

Rivers - due to Vick being out of the league

Vick - Jail Time

Warner, Palmer, Garcia, Eli, Bulger, Romo - Tied for 10th (they all had small spurts of being top options)

 

[Chazzhawk]

Is this someone's personal list or is this based on points? I am sure it is a typo, but how is Calvin Johnson at the bottom half of wide receivers when he has had 3 seasons of 77+ touchdowns?

 

[chook]

Is this someone's personal list or is this based on points? I am sure it is a typo, but how is Calvin Johnson at the bottom half of wide receivers when he has had 3 seasons of 77+ touchdowns?

Madden doesn't count.

 

[wiscstlatlmia]

Is this someone's personal list or is this based on points? I am sure it is a typo, but how is Calvin Johnson at the bottom half of wide receivers when he has had 3 seasons of 77+ touchdowns?

woops

 

[rizzler]

Is this someone's personal list or is this based on points? I am sure it is a typo, but how is Calvin Johnson at the bottom half of wide receivers when he has had 3 seasons of 77+ touchdowns?

woops

Wis, I am sickened that Arian Foster is not #1 every offensive category.Explain thyself. I saw Foster throw for 62tds last year alone.