Trade advice: Ingram or Thielen (1 Viewer)

[RG34]

Hi everyone. I’m torn on who to take in a trade. I have Lamar Jackson on my bench because I have Mahomes as my starter. Can’t bring myself to trust Jackson will keep out preforming Mahomes for the starting position. I was offered Mark Ingram or Adam Thielen. I think I’m better off trading him for a good player rather than save him. Please help with ur input. It’s half point ppr 10 teams. This is my lineup. I appreciate the input!

Starters:

Mahomes

kamara

Chubb

Lockett

Boyd

Kelce

Marquise Brown- flex

49ers D

Butker

Bench:

Coleman

Robby Anderson

Freeman

Ravens D

Hockensen

Mclaurin

Lamar Jackson..

 

[Lionsfan011]

If you're determined to sell Jackson for one of those 2 guys I'd rather have Thielen.

Seems like you could get a little more for him. Maybe package Jackson with Brown or McLaurin for a bigger return. 

 

[Gally]

I think you are selling low on Jackson.  I would ask for more.  However, if it must be one of those two guys I would do Thielen based on your roster.  I think Ingram has more value but you need WR help so Thielen gets the nod for me. 

 

[RG34]

I think you are selling low on Jackson.  I would ask for more.  However, if it must be one of those two guys I would do Thielen based on your roster.  I think Ingram has more value but you need WR help so Thielen gets the nod for me. 

Thanks guys appreciate the input. I will hold onto him and hopefully get more of a return than this, not sure if anyone is going to be willing to give me a better receiver than Thielen but if Jackson keeps turning these numbers I would hope that changes for me. 

 

[RG34]

I think you are selling low on Jackson.  I would ask for more.  However, if it must be one of those two guys I would do Thielen based on your roster.  I think Ingram has more value but you need WR help so Thielen gets the nod for me. 

Any suggestions on who to go after pairing either of them with Jackson?

 

[Gally]

Any suggestions on who to go after pairing either of them with Jackson?

I would put Jackson on the trade block and see if there are any takers....heck I might even put both Jackson and Mahomes on the block and see which has the bigger return.  I would also target QB needy teams (there should be a few with the injuries) and see if they have a strength somewhere to withstand losing a RB1 or WR1.  Too many options to just throw out possible names.  Much depends on the other teams and what they need/have. 

 

[fightingillini]

I think you are selling low on Jackson.  I would ask for more.  However, if it must be one of those two guys I would do Thielen based on your roster.  I think Ingram has more value but you need WR help so Thielen gets the nod for me. 

ABSOLUTELY this.........

Thielen isn't close to enough for Jackson.  MIN is more of a run first team now.

Right now IMO Jackson is QB2 behind Mahomes.  Elite QB!  I would want a top 10 WR or a top 12 RB in return.

 

[beerbuff]

Totally agree with the others, you are selling low. 

 

[Nimrod]

I’d look to see if u could sell Jackson to the brees owner or the Big Ben owner 

 

[RG34]

I got Keenan Allen for Jackson and Brown paired. Thanks again for the help, glad I didn’t just on Thielen.