Fantasy Football - Footballguys Forums
This is a sample guest message. Register a free account today to become a member! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!
Trade value of the 1.01 (1 Viewer)
- Thread starter jeter23
- Start date
Burning Sensation
Footballguy
There are only two players i would definetly trade it for straight up. (AD and SJax)
I would strongly consider Addai and Jones-Drew.
I would possibly consider Gore, Lynch and LT.
Of course there are all sorts of packages i would accept, but it wouldnt take alot to get me to move down to the 1.2. Maybe a WR in the 12-15 range(Holmes, Jennings etc. would certainly work), or a mid-late first round rookie pick.
I would strongly consider Addai and Jones-Drew.
I would possibly consider Gore, Lynch and LT.
Of course there are all sorts of packages i would accept, but it wouldnt take alot to get me to move down to the 1.2. Maybe a WR in the 12-15 range(Holmes, Jennings etc. would certainly work), or a mid-late first round rookie pick.
FUBAR
Footballguy
I have the 1.02 in one league, wouldn't include much to move to 1.01. I see Mac and Stew as close enough in value.
I wouldn't give a RB better than LJ, Portis, Lynch, or Gore for it. No chance of giving LT unless I'm in a total rebuild and drunk.
In a new dynasty draft, I'd probably take either RB after the top 10 picks.
I wouldn't give a RB better than LJ, Portis, Lynch, or Gore for it. No chance of giving LT unless I'm in a total rebuild and drunk.
In a new dynasty draft, I'd probably take either RB after the top 10 picks.
Cookiemonster
Footballguy
I wouldn't give nearly as much as the previous posters seem to be expecting. I'd part w/ Chad Johnson and a throw-in (Pierre Thomas, M.Pittman) after some internal debate.
Initial draft, I'd probably take McFadden early round 3 as well as Stewart and Mendenhall mid round 3 if you were drafting right now - all subject to change post-combine/draft.
Initial draft, I'd probably take McFadden early round 3 as well as Stewart and Mendenhall mid round 3 if you were drafting right now - all subject to change post-combine/draft.
Last edited by a moderator:
fruity pebbles
Footballguy
That's your option to value him as such but nobody would trade the 1.01 for that. As far as early 3rd, I hope you're not talking about a dynasty draft.Have been offered FWP, LJ, McGahee and Tom Brady thus far for the 1.01.
ConstruxBoy
Kate's Daddy
McGahee AND Brady? I think you're making a mistake.
fruity pebbles
Footballguy
No, McGahee or Brady. All 4 players offered seperately
jeter23
Footballguy
I assume he means he has been offered each of those players in a one for one swap.
Colin Dowling
Footballguy
It would be REALLY hard to pass on Brady for the 1.01. In fact, I'd accept that in a heartbeat.
I traded the 1.1 pick about 6 weeks ago. Traded it straight up for Steve Smith (PPR league)
Cookiemonster
Footballguy
I just think this RB class is running on hype thanks in part to ADP's special rookie season and Lynch's strong showing. I'd be surprised if any of these guys are better than Lynch, and I'd take any of those listed (maybe excluding FWP) for this year's 1.01 in a heartbeat. I'd also gladly trade it for somebody's 1st from this year + next year. FWIW, I'm not trying to hard to get any further than the top 5 this year and probably won't offer enough to get in. In comparison, I was willing to give up whatever it took to get the 1.01 last year and think I got off cheap giving up last year's 1.05 and this year's 1st.
comfortably numb
Footballguy
Unless I really needed a RB, I would trade 1.01 for a few WR's as well. (Wayne, Fitzgerald, SSMith, AJohnson)
shamrock84
Footballguy
I was offered the 1.02 and 1.03 picks which I will take but it's contingent on the guy actually attaining the 1.02 pick. We'll see what happens.
ConstruxBoy
Kate's Daddy
OK. I'd still probably do Brady for that. Maybe FWP. I think TDs are somewhat random and I expect Parker to get more TDs most years than he got this year.
ConstruxBoy
Kate's Daddy
I'd probably add Westbrook as a Yes and Gore as a Maybe.
Cookiemonster
Footballguy
Last edited by a moderator:
Cookiemonster
Footballguy
Hell yes!
Ministry of Pain
Footballguy
It's a good question. With as many as 4-5 good RB coming out and entering the draft, depending on which team drafts who...you might get a really strong RB prospect with the 1.04 pick this year...so to answer your question, due to the fact there is more than just 1-2 RB this year I think the trade value is less than in some years where it was ADP and not much else.
culdeus
Footballguy
McFadden is vastly overrated as a result of what ADP did this year. Watching him in action I've never been impressed with his results versus good teams. This coupled with the number of RBs coming out that will likely outproduce him in 2008 I'd strongly consider trying to deal the 1.01 pick to the highest bidder.
Right now you are looking at perhaps the falcons or raiders? Would you really want to get in the middle of those trainwrecks?
Right now you are looking at perhaps the falcons or raiders? Would you really want to get in the middle of those trainwrecks?
mozzy84
Footballguy
all of them besides LJ imo...I would add westbrook, CJ, wayne, fitz, edwards and smith to that list as well and there are probably others as well.
sparkky
Footballguy
I'd be all over that too!!
I agree completely. I have the #2, 5 and 8 would gladly part with #2 for a proven young RB.
Cookiemonster
Footballguy
I'd give you a proven, 30 year-old WR and a prospect player of your choice. Say J.Norwood or <.
Duke1948
Footballguy
you must have missed the 209 he put on the board against the national champs.
sparkky
Footballguy
The WRs I would consider would be a short list. Wayne, Edwards, maybe A. Johnson. Off the top of my head. RB's are GOLD in this league being a 12 team. Having 2 solid starters is tough and a decent #3 for bye weeks/injuries/matchups is rare. But I have JLewis, Maroney and Benson so I do have a little wiggle room.
fruity pebbles
Footballguy
LJ- no way i'm trading the 1.01 for a 29 year old back on a bad team. good way to always be mediocre. trade value is nil when he turns 30 in one short year.
Addai- probably, although i think McFadden is vastly more talented. Team carries a lot of weight and his is great for RB points.
MJD- No, although it's close. Don't see him as a 300 plus carry back. Will always put up good but not great numbers. Rather shoot for the stars.
Gore- yes
FWP- No way. His ceiling is around 1500 total yards and 6-8 TDs. Not too mention he'll be 28 next year and is on a poor run blocking team. Another way to always be mediocre. Good #2 back but not a #1.
SJax- yes
LT- Yes, older but still capable of huge numbers
ADP- Yes
Lynch- no, think McFadden is more talented. Lynch is on a poor team so what's the point. Might as well go for the guy who i think is better.
Westbrook- ditto LT
Bush- no, think we've seen his best and it aint that good
Moss- Maybe if i was strong at RB but weak at WR. But i'd want to see him sign with the Pats first
Brady- ditto if i were weak at QB, although i'd want to see Moss sign first.
Manning- ditto Brady
Wouldn't consider another WR unless it were 1 ppr.
Addai- probably, although i think McFadden is vastly more talented. Team carries a lot of weight and his is great for RB points.
MJD- No, although it's close. Don't see him as a 300 plus carry back. Will always put up good but not great numbers. Rather shoot for the stars.
Gore- yes
FWP- No way. His ceiling is around 1500 total yards and 6-8 TDs. Not too mention he'll be 28 next year and is on a poor run blocking team. Another way to always be mediocre. Good #2 back but not a #1.
SJax- yes
LT- Yes, older but still capable of huge numbers
ADP- Yes
Lynch- no, think McFadden is more talented. Lynch is on a poor team so what's the point. Might as well go for the guy who i think is better.
Westbrook- ditto LT
Bush- no, think we've seen his best and it aint that good
Moss- Maybe if i was strong at RB but weak at WR. But i'd want to see him sign with the Pats first
Brady- ditto if i were weak at QB, although i'd want to see Moss sign first.
Manning- ditto Brady
Wouldn't consider another WR unless it were 1 ppr.
Last edited by a moderator:
anakin
Footballguy
It is a PPR league and I already have Portis, MJD, L White with Betts, C Brown, K Watson, D McCallister, Hunt but my WRs are the following Cotchery, A Gonzalez, DJ Hackett, , Br Johnson, B Wade, and Br Smith.
Thin Spirit
Footballguy
I traded the 1.1 and the 2.1 for the 1.3, 1.6, and Lee Evans. It is also a PPR league. 
ConstruxBoy
Kate's Daddy
Wow, that is awesome.I traded the 1.1 and the 2.1 for the 1.3, 1.6, and Lee Evans. It is also a PPR league.
Yes to AD, LT (would add SJax). Probably to Addai and MJD (would add Westy and possibly Gore). If stacked at RB with no QB, yes to Brady/Manning; I'd need to see Moss resign before saying yes (no other WRs in non-PPR). No to the rest.Though I also think that Stewart and Mendenhall are close to McFadden; with a WR/QB upgrade for need (or a fairly high pick), I'd move down from 1.01 to 1.02/1.03. Not every year though.
I was maybe 75% sure at the time it would be 1.01; it was either going to be the 1.01 or 1.02.. nothing lower than that.
mozzy84
Footballguy
jacobs, bradshaw and TO, maybe I am off here but I would be shocked if anyone turned that down.
Colin Dowling
Footballguy
No kidding...
blend
Footballguy
I'd go:LTSJax1.1GrantGoreTurner
FUBAR
Footballguy
LT SJax 1.1 Gore Grant Turner
I don't think it's slam dunk, unless the owner of 1.01 is close to contending, often they're not.
ConstruxBoy
Kate's Daddy
LTSJaxGore1.1GrantTurner
ConstruxBoy
Kate's Daddy
That's a great deal. At 1.07 you can likely get the first QB or WR off the board or one of the lower first day RBs if you like one. And you get Addai and his handcuff? Wow.
mozzy84
Footballguy
nice work! surprised someone would give up addai after the year he just had.
EBF
Footballguy
As I've said before, I think the 1.02 is actually the best value of the picks this year. I think at least one of Stewart or Mendenhall will land in an ideal situation and become a very appealing option in dynasty drafts. When it comes to RB production, situation is HUGE. Nevermind the fact that there are legitimate concerns about McFadden's build and ability to carry a full workload at the next level.
So if I had 1.01 in any of my leagues this season, I would try to sell the "McFadden = once-a-decade stud" logic to a buyer with the 1.02 or 1.03. Get an extra first or second round pick and still pick up an elite RB. That's the way to go.
In a PPR I would probably trade 1.01 for the following players:
Peyton Manning
Tom Brady
LaDainian Tomlinson
Adrian Peterson
Steven Jackson
Brian Westbrook
Frank Gore
Joseph Addai
Reggie Bush
Anquan Boldin
Larry Fitzgerald
Chad Johnson
Reggie Wayne
Andre Johnson
Braylon Edwards
Marques Colston
Antonio Gates
Realistically, who you should take in return for the pick depends on your team composition and your league format.
So if I had 1.01 in any of my leagues this season, I would try to sell the "McFadden = once-a-decade stud" logic to a buyer with the 1.02 or 1.03. Get an extra first or second round pick and still pick up an elite RB. That's the way to go.
In a PPR I would probably trade 1.01 for the following players:
Peyton Manning
Tom Brady
LaDainian Tomlinson
Adrian Peterson
Steven Jackson
Brian Westbrook
Frank Gore
Joseph Addai
Reggie Bush
Anquan Boldin
Larry Fitzgerald
Chad Johnson
Reggie Wayne
Andre Johnson
Braylon Edwards
Marques Colston
Antonio Gates
Realistically, who you should take in return for the pick depends on your team composition and your league format.
jeter23
Footballguy
Thanks, now I have 2, 5, 7, 8, 9, 12. That will help my rebuild move along a little sooner than expected.
silentmark
Footballguy
I doubt the he makes it to the Raiders AND I doubt the Raiders would take him. They have other issues and RB is not one of them imo. Anyhoooooo I offered Parker, Davenport & 2.02 in our dynasty league for 1.01, I already have 1.02, and got rejected. The owner said he would consider Calvin Johnston instead of Parker, which I just can not do, shrug ...
I just got the following trade for 1.1 before the weekend's games:
Give:
Romo
Fargas
Plax
1.9
Get:
MBIII
1.1
Bulger
I'm deep at QB (Still have Peyton and ASmith) and WR (Marshall, Evans, braylon, holmes, stallworth) but was very skinny at RB. I think i probably got a good deal.
kook
Give:
Romo
Fargas
Plax
1.9
Get:
MBIII
1.1
Bulger
I'm deep at QB (Still have Peyton and ASmith) and WR (Marshall, Evans, braylon, holmes, stallworth) but was very skinny at RB. I think i probably got a good deal.
kook
