Fantasy Football - Footballguys Forums
This is a sample guest message. Register a free account today to become a member! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!
Trading Halladay (1 Viewer)
- Thread starter Polecat
- Start date
hold
Offer 2 would interest me slightly if I was extremely weak at 2nd and 3rd....however the general rule of thumb is whoever receives the best player in a trade has won the trade. Halladay is way more valuable than any of those players mentioned.
Think of it this way. In a mixed league, I think Halladay is in the top dozen starting pitchers. In return I'd want at least a top 20 or so offensive player, or two players in the top dozen or so at their position. None of the players mentioned qualifies.
Offer 2 would interest me slightly if I was extremely weak at 2nd and 3rd....however the general rule of thumb is whoever receives the best player in a trade has won the trade. Halladay is way more valuable than any of those players mentioned.
Think of it this way. In a mixed league, I think Halladay is in the top dozen starting pitchers. In return I'd want at least a top 20 or so offensive player, or two players in the top dozen or so at their position. None of the players mentioned qualifies.
Yankee23Fan
Fair Tax!
I would hold Roy. True A#1 pitchers are hard to come by and he should be that this year. The guys in the deals simply aren't worth it unless your offense is awful and your pitching is solid without him.
As an aside, Roy was traded in my H2H keeper in the offseason for a 3rd round pick - I think it was pick 24 if I'm not mistaken. The guys being offered to you aren't anywhere near that base value - at least in my league.
As an aside, Roy was traded in my H2H keeper in the offseason for a 3rd round pick - I think it was pick 24 if I'm not mistaken. The guys being offered to you aren't anywhere near that base value - at least in my league.
You're looking at this the wrong way. Who is Chavez replacing? If you are currently not running any 3B out there, well, he is a huge improvement. However, let's say you have a middle of the road 3B man, well, he is only marginally better. 90 RBI's isn't world beating production, and quite frankly Chavez is a wreck in the other categories. Mid-20's homer power doesn't offset .250 batting averages. And he may only score 75 runs for you which is very weak.Cuddyer is an okay outfielder too, but again, who he is replacing is much more important than how he will produce. Cuddyer is not superior in any category, so unless you have a vacant OF spot, or are using some guy in a platoon that is not getting any pt, like Kevin Mench, well, you are only going to realize the above and beyond numbers that Cuddyer may produce.
Dexter Manley
Footballguy
I just traded Halladay for Oswalt str8 up.
I would auto decline both of the trade offers you mentioned.
I would auto decline both of the trade offers you mentioned.
Wrigley
Footballguy
Oranges for oranges.This is a marginal trade at best.
Cat,
As posted earlier, to really know if a trade is going to help or hurt you, we must know your roster.
FairWarning
Footballguy
Plus Crede has a bad back. Not worth the risk.
my man otis
Footballguy
I'll give you a hint - 2 for 1 trades are the best way to win your league...if you're the guy getting the 1 player in return.Both of these offers are a joke to be honest.Halladay is sort of a 1B SP because his K rate isn't as high as some other top guys, but he's right up there. Someone like Damon would be a fair offer.All 4 of the guys you were offered are average players. 2 average does not equal 1 very good player.
Similar threads
