Tyreek, A Jones or Mack? Pick 1 Keeper. 1st round returns or mid round value? (1 Viewer)

[bri2k]

Is it better to move up a round or two and secure a top player in Hill, or move up 4 to 5 rounds and get value in Jones/Mack? This is a general philosophical question, but also looking for who you'd pick.

I can keep one. I am picking 6th spot in a snake draft. 

Player / Pick cost

Tyreek Hill - 3rd round
Aaron Hill - 7th
Marlon Mack - 7th

12 Team non-PPR redraft. Starting Lineup: QB, RB, RB, WR, WR, TE, D/ST, K

 

[Skoo]

I voted Jones, as I think he's the best value overall. Very close with Tyreek though, dominant players are hard to come by. Wouldn't fault you for going either way.

The way I figured it in a league like yours is that RBs will be in much higher demand than WR since you only start 2 of each. SO much more depth available at WR in drafts.

If you don't mind:

https://forums.footballguys.com/forum/topic/777917-keepers-because-apparently-i-run-my-wifes-team/

 

[Gally]

When you are only keeping one player I generally go with the best player.  You are getting decent value in Hill and he is by far the best player.  I would choose him easily