AnonymousBob
Footballguy
Fair enough it seems. You draft Coles and think you've gotten some value, I draft him and think I've stepped in a steaming pile of cow feces. That's what makes all of this so fun. In ppr leagues I agree he's going to be quite good but in any other format I just wouldn't be able to pull the trigger on him unless we're talking extremely late rounds. Even if Mason and Mushy keep their same lousy qb's I think they'll still be worthwile. Heck, I think Jurevicius is better value and he's on the Browns :X One big question I have-who is going to be throwing the ball to Coles? As we know, qb's can drastically alter a player's value. Is Pennington indeed coming back? Honest question, I really have no clue what's going on with their backfield.Fair enough, but I think the QB situation has been so bad for Coles the last two years, and he has still gotten open and caught a ton or balls. K-Rob simply folded - Coles is a much less risky player. As for Mason, neither the jets nor the skins have seen a QB as good as Steve McNair in decades. But anyway, in ppr leagues, Coles has a great deal of value b/c his floor is relatively high - 70ish catches for 800-900 yards 3-4TDs, while his ceiling is very nice - 90ish catches for 1200ish yards and 8TDs. If Coles' low end makes him agood first backup WR in your league, he's a great player to take a chance on.Why could Coles only get 950 yards and 1 td while with the Redskins while Santana Moss (same qb) grabbed 500 more yards and 9 td's-while catching 6 fewer passes?
At a certain point it gets ridiculous to say player x can be good, so long as everything falls into place. I'd much rather have Mason, K-Rob or a handful of other guys who don't require perfection to perform. Who knows, Coles may burn me this season by my refusal to pick him. I can't imagine how it would happen when they have no qb.
ETA in ppr leagues he's much more valuable.