So I was playing around last night and ended up in Oasis. As those of you who have played know you are given 3 choices for Bob and Harold. Harold asks you to kill him. Then you have the priest who gives you some sap to limit Harold and Bob to Oasis so no one else will know. Your last choice is from the priests wife she gives you a potion that will make Harold replenish the wasteland as he has Oasis. Now apparently there is no wrong answer here, so you can do what you want as far as the game is concerned. But maybe there is a bad choice here. I was thinking about doing a poll and seeing if the FFA would weigh in on the philosophical underpinnings of that decision. We'll see. I still haven't decided but I am leaning toward killing the poor guy. Although the needs of the many outweigh the needs of the few or the one. Decisions, decisions.
That was one of the better ones. The "bad" karma is to kill him obviously. Limiting him to the garden is neutral or slightly bad. Cant remember. Healing the wastelands is the good karma. That's what I went with.
My understanding was the only bad karma decision was to burn Harold/Bob down with the flame thrower. All other choices were neutral to good karma.
Poor guy is afraid of fire. If your speech is high enough, I think it changes up the dialog options and you can convince Bob to go along with your choice or get some extra perk somehow. Wiki should say. There was also some good loot in the caverns below him.
Instead of shooting Dave at the Republic in the face you can do some fun things with calling for an "election" of a new ruler.
I'd like to go back and replay Vegas someday, at a certain point you have to make a choice that closes off later mission branches. I went totally goodie goodie and missed out on a lot of the Caesar related content. Plus I wanna blow up that Monorail! The Ghoul's at the rocket factory have pretty fun ending options too! That one I definitely saved and replayed to see what happens.