At first, I thought the game was much better than I anticipated. And it still is, for the most part. But honestly, it's a bit boring. I want to at least get to the part where Daryl gets the crossbow and see if it gets better from there. But it's a chore to play through. I hear the game is short, so I may be able to finish it in a couple of days. But that depends on whether I have interest in doing so. Without the crossbow, I feel that it's just a bad stealth game right now, and the game definitely punishes you for using guns (which, if you're familiar with The Walking Dead, should make sense). There's a mini-game that the game puts you through when a walker gets right on top of you. It's similar to the aiming game that takes place during the shooting sections of TellTale's The Walking Dead game. But it's poorly handled. For people who complained about aiming in TellTale's game, they won't like that any better. And imagine doing that mini-game several times in a row if you're surrounded, basically until you are dead. Don't get surrounded. You can usually handle two at a time, but any more and you're lucky to make it out alive.
The neat thing with the game is that there are some random events that happen. Between missions, you select the route to take with your car. It gives you the destination and gives you the choice to take a rural road, main road or highway. Highways will take less gas, but you have a higher chance of breakdown. Rural routes allow for more exploration and finding supplies, but eat more gas. Main roads are in the middle. And after selecting your route, the game goes into, what I think reminds me of a Oregon Trail type of randomness. Like I said, sometimes you'll break down and need a part, sometimes you stop for supplies, sometimes the road is blocked and you need to push cars out of the way (or find another route). And the game isn't pre-determined with it. I turned off the game after stopping and needing a new battery only to find that the car didn't break down at all when I started from there the next time.
I'm only a few hours in, but that's what I can say so far. There are some nice surprising moments where the game feels like it could've been something better, but for me, I'm just playing for a pre-TV show story on the Dixon Bros. Unfortunately, so far there hasn't been much of that. It's fetch this, do this, here's a survivor and they need this... etc.
I'll give it a little more time. Maybe it'll get better.