Whilst I never said I thought it was necessarily the "right thing to do, or did I say it was ethical", it is part of the game on Yahoo settings in many leagues, and I am sure it may be that way on other hosts as well.
@EthnicFury - Hit it straight away, in many Yahoo settings it works only for Thursday night settings, and although it probably shouldn't be allowed, you can not say an owner is "wrong" (Or shouldn't do it??) just for following the rules and taking advantage of certain little nuances.
@Davearm - What you are saying is correct, you could actually do that if you wanted I believe, and without repercussion. Even though i know you were laying out an extreme case to essentially say you didn't agree it should be allowed. (Maybe thats just the way I interpreted it)
There are other responses, and I won't address them all specifically.
I generally write about things that I think are advantageous to the casual FF player, or more often than not its something that interests me from a strategy standpoint. This "free play" is something I just happened to notice years ago in the yahoo leagues I play in. Just not
ALL my leagues are set up this way.
Several years ago, I noticed something (and I'm fairly sure I mentioned it elsewhere on the board here) about the waiver wire in our leagues as well.
It just so happens someone else pointed it out here in the last few days in a new thread. Look here ~~~~~~>
https://forums.footballguys.com/forum/topic/772194-question-about-ww-on-yahoo/
Essentially, about 45 minutes before waivers "run" on yahoo, there is a bit of a dark period. If someone is fast enough or lucky enough to catch it during that period, they can pick up and add players before waivers "run" or so it appears at first glance. During this small window, you can add and drop players, before the players that have been claimed are awarded to their owners that made their successful claims. (Note - you can not pick up someone who has been claimed, he is "locked in" and you can't acquire him, only unclaimed players) You literally have to be fortunate enough to be aware and notice it right as it is happening, as sometimes the waivers run at slightly different times of night on a week to week basis.
When you look at the free agents list, you can acquire players before any players that have been claimed are doled out. I think this is another area which is technically within the rules, but I can see where a few players don't agree with this. But realistically, how is this any different than me being awake at 5:00 a.m. (earlier than most owners ) and making moves, before you wake up for work and are awarded your claimed player? Anyone who is up can notice and act accordingly. Just because some may not agree that it is "right" in their opinion, doesn't mean another owner should or shouldn't do it.
Leagues have different criteria on IR spots, number of waiver wire maneuvers, different ways of vetoing trades, different settings, different rules like "you
MUST play an active player in all positions" (essentially forcing owners to occasionally drop strong players to acquire a defense or kicker on a given week) different ways of "tanking" (Do you think throwing a game in the final week of the regular season to allow a much-worse team into the playoffs, all for
your benefit of playing said team in round 1 of those playoffs should be allowed???). This last one is an issue I don't think people will
EVER uniformly agree on. Just because it is often allowed or within the rules, doesn't necessarily mean its the right thing to do.
That is probably the case in my "free play" example about CJ Anderson. Just because one can do it, should an owner be able to or should he?? I don't know personally, if I'm qualified or even smart enough to judge it on exactly how "right or wrong" this is
...... but I won't condemn someone else if they made this play. Hell, I made it myself in 2 leagues. (technically I haven't dropped Anderson yet, and its not really a "bad play", unless I drop him before the weekend is it?) Oddly enough, I own McCaffrey in one of those leagues, and I probably will not drop Anderson there and keep CMC handcuffed for a playoff run. But in my other league I will consider dropping Anderson if CMC doesn't get injured tonight.
The more points a couple of you guys bring up, the more it gets me to thinking on exactly how "right or wrong" this move may be.
TZM