Week 4 2025 who should I start thread **OFFICIALLY UNOFFICIAL** (5 Viewers)

[IHEARTFF]

I need someone to absolutely convince me not to start Jeremy mcnichols over Braelon Allen

Go ahead. Both have insanely low floors but JM has a ceiling

You're just saying that because we're playing each other. It's the double bluff

Omg lol I had no idea it was for that league. I’m glad you’re having to make that choice against me.

 

[Proteus]

Full ppr

Tet @ NE

or

BTJr. @ SF(no Bosa)

 

[Chaka]

check my sanity

.25 ppr, pick 2 for flex

Hockenson vs. Pit
Troy Franklin vs. Cin
Ayomanor vs. Hou
Malik Washington vs. NYJ
Dontavin Wicks. vs Dal

Hock and Washington, right?

need 4 WR, 1 ppr

Jamarr Chase vs. Den
Keon Coleman vs. NOS
Troy Fanklin vs. Cin
Wandale Robinson vs. Lac
Rashid Shaheed vs. Buf
Brian Thomas Jr. vs. 49ers

Chase, Shaheed, Fanklin and Thomas?

6 pts per TD

Carson Wentz vs. Pit
Brock Purdy vs. Jac

Wentz?

I'm good with Ho Hock.

Washington is fine but, personally I would be trying to get Ayomanor into my lineup. They have similar Target share but, Ayomanor is seeing almost 20% more snapshare. I think he also has less competition for targets. Also check Stingley's status.

Ayomanor>Washington
≠====================

Totally good with your choices. I might consider Coleman over Franklin but, my heart wouldn't be in it.
====================

Ill like Wentz here. The Niners feel like they're held together by scotch tape and bubble gum.

Wentz>Purdy

 

[steelwind]

Indiana Jones @ LAR
or
Fields @ MIA

4 point passing TD

 

[Proteus]

Indiana Jones @ LAR
or
Fields @ MIA

4 point passing TD

I prefer Fields here.

 

[Chaka]

Need a flex in half PPR. Godwin (vs PHI), Kraft (vs DAL) or TreVeyon (vs CAR).

Thanks!

With Wirfs back and no Evans (I think) I go with Godwin here.

Totally see the argument for Kraft (not so much Henderson) and wouldn't argue if that's the way you go. I just think more of the Bucs passing game gets funneled through Godwin and Egbuka than the Packers through Kraft.

Godwin>Kraft>Henderson

 

[Chaka]

Indiana Jones @ LAR
or
Fields @ MIA

4 point passing TD

Please don't.

I probably lean Fields because of the better matchup and lesser run game. I think Jones will have a fine day, I just wonder if his fantasy prospects in general are capped by Taylor.

Fields>Jones

 

[Chaka]

I need someone to absolutely convince me not to start Jeremy mcnichols over Braelon Allen

I guess it depends a bit on the status of JCM, doesn't it?

But, relative to Braelon I wouldn't try to hard to convince you not to.

 

[Chaka]

Full ppr

Tet @ NE

or

BTJr. @ SF(no Bosa)

Man... I am so upset that this is even a question but, darned if it isn't legit.

I really want to say BTJ and, I might start him in my team over Tet because I still believe in his upside. But McMillan is getting such consistent volume and you're in a full PPR league.

It's a ceiling v floor question. I won't argue against BTJ but the smart move is probably

Tet>BTJ

 

[jm192]

q1`Full Point PPR league

Engram vs Cincy

Or

Fannin at Detroit

Fannin, don't want to trust Engram 1st game back.

 

[jm192]

Indiana Jones @ LAR
or
Fields @ MIA

4 point passing TD

Justin is going to have a Fields day vs Miami. Miami is giving up the 2nd most FPPG to QB.

LAR is legit.

 

[jm192]

Full ppr

Tet @ NE

or

BTJr. @ SF(no Bosa)

I don't know. I'm going to ask the always annoying "Can you bench someone else?"

SF is really strong against WR, ranking 27th in FPPG. Bosa out will make Lawrence's life a little easier.
New England ranks substantially worse, but they're finally getting Gonzalez back. And that may slow Tet down.

I think I'd go Tet just given BTJ's struggles, but if you bench him, he'll have the breakout day today.

 

[Proteus]

Full ppr

Tet @ NE

or

BTJr. @ SF(no Bosa)

I don't know. I'm going to ask the always annoying "Can you bench someone else?"

SF is really strong against WR, ranking 27th in FPPG. Bosa out will make Lawrence's life a little easier.
New England ranks substantially worse, but they're finally getting Gonzalez back. And that may slow Tet down.

I think I'd go Tet just given BTJ's struggles, but if you bench him, he'll have the breakout day today.

I could bench Pickens, Judkins, Hampton, or McCaffrey if I really had a hot nut to get them both in the lineup.

 

[zeke2222]

PPR Flex spot need one:
Ferguson vs GB
Troy Franklin vs CIN?

 

[IHEARTFF]

PPR Flex spot need one:
Ferguson vs GB
Troy Franklin vs CIN?

Volume says Ferguson

 

[jm192]

Full ppr

Tet @ NE

or

BTJr. @ SF(no Bosa)

I don't know. I'm going to ask the always annoying "Can you bench someone else?"

SF is really strong against WR, ranking 27th in FPPG. Bosa out will make Lawrence's life a little easier.
New England ranks substantially worse, but they're finally getting Gonzalez back. And that may slow Tet down.

I think I'd go Tet just given BTJ's struggles, but if you bench him, he'll have the breakout day today.

I could bench Pickens, Judkins, Hampton, or McCaffrey if I really had a hot nut to get them both in the lineup.

I'd rather play Tet and BTJ over Pickens.

 

[Schmeabs]

PPR pick 2

Adams vs Colts
Samuel at Falcons
Sutton vs Bengals

Have Adams sitting as of now with him questionable

 

[jm192]

Kirk, Boute or Downs in full PPR. Projected for a slight win.

 

[jm192]

PPR pick 2

Adams vs Colts
Samuel at Falcons
Sutton vs Bengals

Have Adams sitting as of now with him questionable

Adams and Sutton as long as Adamas plays

 

[Mike719]

APPRECIATE THIUGHTS: PPR. Starting Ferguson in TE so need 1 of these for flex. Kincaid, Doubs, Ridley. Thanks

 

[Mike719]

PPR pick 2

Adams vs Colts
Samuel at Falcons
Sutton vs Bengals

Have Adams sitting as of now with him questionable

Adams and Sutton as long as Adamas plays

Adams Sutton

 

[Mike719]

PPR league. 12 teams. Desperate to upgrade at RB even if slightly. Need upside.

Rate this trade offer:

* I GIVE: I. Pacheco & H. Fannin

* I GET: T. Henderson

Note: I have T. McBride at TE and the other manager is desperate for TE help.

Local beat NE writers saying Henderson is getting first reps today at practice.

No brainer to offer?

Thanks

I would take Henderson. I wish I was offered. I need RB help too

 

[jm192]

APPRECIATE THIUGHTS: PPR. Starting Ferguson in TE so need 1 of these for flex. Kincaid, Doubs, Ridley. Thanks

I think Doubs. Kincaid is still seeing about half the snaps, he's "ok" as your TE because the poistiion sucks after the top 6 or 7. But as a flex, I think I'd rather go almost anyone. Doubs gets a bad Dallas defensee.

Ridley feels super unreliable. Don't trust him. Don't trust Ward.

 

[Schmeabs]

PPR
Jeudy at Detroit
Godwin vs Philly

 

[Chaka]

PPR Flex spot need one:
Ferguson vs GB
Troy Franklin vs CIN?

Ferguson and not close. Too much volume lately.

Ferguson>Franklin

 

[Chaka]

PPR pick 2

Adams vs Colts
Samuel at Falcons
Sutton vs Bengals

Have Adams sitting as of now with him questionable

No problem with that. It's a coin toss regardless.

 

[Chaka]

Kirk, Boute or Downs in full PPR. Projected for a slight win.

In full PPR I liked what I saw from Kirk's usage last week. Boutte can't be trusted. Downs is a fine choice but, he has a pretty low floor

 

[jm192]

Waddle vs NYJ
Pittman vs LAR
ETN vs SF

Need 2 for 0.5 PPR. Thanks

 

[Chaka]

APPRECIATE THIUGHTS: PPR. Starting Ferguson in TE so need 1 of these for flex. Kincaid, Doubs, Ridley. Thanks

Hard to say. I guess Doubs for the upside matchup and I think his targets are more secure.

Can see the same for Kincaid but, I do worry about his downside.

Don't love Ridley yet, even with no Singletary

Doubs>Kincaid>Ridley

 

[Chaka]

PPR
Jeudy at Detroit
Godwin vs Philly

Godwin IMO. Jeudy has been so mid and, I believe no Evans.

Godwin>Jeudy

 

[Chaka]

Waddle vs NYJ
Pittman vs LAR
ETN vs SF

Need 2 for 0.5 PPR. Thanks

Feels like a coin toss. Personally I don't like relying on Tua but, ETN may be a mirage.

Pittman>ETN>Waddle

 

[My_Bench_Scores_More]

With the Cee Dee Lamb injury, that could lead to him missing up to 3 weeks, I need to fill the ranks.

Both Keenan Allen and Quentin Johnston are available in my league. I'm leaning towards Allen. Any thoughts? Chargers play the Giants this week.

Thanks!

Keenan. He gets redzone looks. He and Herbert have a great connection.

Wishing I had opted for Johnston right now

 

[NickRocks]

Need a flex

Breece vs MIA
Pearsall vs JAX

 

[Chaka]

Need a flex

Breece vs MIA
Pearsall vs JAX

PPR??

That Miami defense isn't very good...

And Pearsall should see a bunch of targets...

PPR
Pearsall>Breece

Non PPR
Breece>Pearsall

 

[NickRocks]

Need a flex

Breece vs MIA
Pearsall vs JAX

PPR??

That Miami defense isn't very good...

And Pearsall should see a bunch of targets...

PPR
Pearsall>Breece

Non PPR
Breece>Pearsall

Half PPR so you can see the struggle. Haha

Thanks!

 

[Chaka]

Need a flex

Breece vs MIA
Pearsall vs JAX

PPR??

That Miami defense isn't very good...

And Pearsall should see a bunch of targets...

PPR
Pearsall>Breece

Non PPR
Breece>Pearsall

Half PPR so you can see the struggle. Haha

Thanks!

I think I lean Pearsall but, it's close.

 

[My_Bench_Scores_More]

True to my Username, I started Jones and benched Stafford today. That move represents a loss of 15 points from my score. Figures Jones decides to throw his first two interceptions of the season in one game.

 

[tkrull2.0]

I need to score 17 points on Monday. PPR. Pick 2:

J.Chase @ Den
C.Brown @ Den
C.Sutton v Cin

 

[Chaka]

I need to score 17 points on Monday. PPR. Pick 2:

J.Chase @ Den
C.Brown @ Den
C.Sutton v Cin

It's a crap shoot of course but, I probably bench Brown. He's just been so bad.

Chase>Sutton>Brown