"I wouldn't let
Mark Sanchez throw me a paper bag sandwich."
Hey Steve, can I get a list of QB's who you would allow to throw you your bagged lunch?
That's an interesting question. On the one hand, you'd want to exclude guys like Jay Cutler, Joe Flacco, and Matt Stafford- their laser-rocket arms would likely result in irreparable harm to the contents of the bag. So you'd really want someone with a weaker arm. At the same time, you'd have to place a very high premium on accuracy (to ensure that my bagged lunch does not wind up in the hands of someone else). That's how Sanchez gets ruled out, and it'd also probably spell doom for guys like Vick, Tannehill, and Gabbert. Obviously the rookies are all out of the question, because how I could rate a rookie over a proven vet when I haven't even seen him take a single sandwich snap yet? Schaub and Rivers would have once qualified, but at this point, when delivering a bag that presumably contains baked goods, I would prefer someone a little less stale and a little more fresh. Cam Newton could probably deliver the sandwich just fine, but I wouldn't like his body language while he did it. Ben Roethlisberger could, as well, but given his penchant for improvisation, I'd probably wind up with a pasta salad, instead.
Obviously the future HoFers- Rodgers, Brees, Brady, Manning- would all be up for sandwich delivery duties, but it seems like a gross misuse of resources. I'd rather take a look at the class of QBs who are not so obviously overqualified for the task of throwing a sandwich in a paper bag. Guys like Tony Romo and Andy Dalton would make very underrated sandwich-delivery experts, but I wouldn't want to have to eat over the grumblings of their respective fan-bases. Russell Wilson is another strong candidate, but he's very short, and as this gag proves, I don't do very well with "short". Nick Foles is an intriguing prospect, but with my luck, he'd lose his job to Dennis Dixon and my sandwich would end up as much of a mess as Philly's QB depth chart. Obviously if we were doing an all-time list of paper bag sandwich throwers, Chad Pennington would be a lock to go #1 overall, but I heard he actually tore his rotator cuff twice while I was typing this sentence. David Garrard would be another perfect choice, and his recent promotion to positional coaching intern removes any question of overqualification, but everything about the Jets' quarterback situation stinks like sweaty feet (which is probably why Rex Ryan hasn't jumped ship yet).
No, after considering all of the variables, there's really only one guy who I would want throwing me my paper bag sandwich. Only one guy combines a weak arm with 70+% accuracy. Only one guy maintains the necessary job security without seeming the teensiest, tiniest bit overqualified. Obviously the only guy in the NFL who could be trusted to deliver paper bag sandwiches on the side is...
Alex Smith, QB, KC.