What's new
Fantasy Football - Footballguys Forums

Welcome to Our Forums. Once you've registered and logged in, you're primed to talk football, among other topics, with the sharpest and most experienced fantasy players on the internet.

What is the worst dynasty trade you have been offered? (2 Viewers)

Auction league, so the "gets" may be way lower salaries than the "gives", but still:

Get: Mayfield, Gallup, Likely, James Mitchell, Logan Thomas
Give: Justin Fields, CeeDee Lamb

I know some people offer these types of trades after being offered an even worse offer.
And others send them hoping for a "Wow, 5 players for 2? What a bargain!" reaction
I hope those type of players have already learned their lesson and improve. Quantity most of the time isn't greater than quality. I said most of the time. Sure, a lot of the posts in this thread are from those that try this philosophy but soon learn experienced owners scoff at it. They either learn and get better, or they bail on the leagues where they are in over their head.
 
Not the worst I've been offered by any means, but I thought y'all might appreciate the pretty outlandish example of an owner making lopsided offers. Same owner made an offer giving me Mixon then one trying to get Chubb from me.

Mar 1:
Child Please offers Mixon, Joe CIN RB; Year 2023 Draft Pick 4.16
Evil Empire for Year 2024 Round 1 Draft Pick from Evil Empire; Year 2024 Round 2 Draft Pick from Evil Empire

Jun 1:
Child Please offers Year 2023 Draft Pick 3.16; Year 2024 Round 1 Draft Pick from Child Please
Evil Empire for Chubb, Nick CLE RB; Okonkwo, Chigoziem TEN TE
Expires: Fri Jun 9 4:00:00 p.m. ET 2023 Fri Jun 2 5:00:36 p.m. ET 2023

So in March with rumors swirling that Mixon (in his twilight) may be cut if he doesn't take a pay cut, this owner sees Mixon + my 4th being worth a 1st and 2nd. Yet somehow Chubb in his prime requires Chig to even be worth the 1st / 3rd. The owner didn't even respond to my counter offer of Chubb for Elijah Moore + his 2024 1st.

Child, please! (name changed to protect the guilty)
 
Just to bump this back to the 1st page,,,

12 team 1QB TE-P FFPC “standard” dynasty league.

team A gave J Jefferson
team B gave J Jacobs

crazy under sell of Jefferson for a team desperate to win now
 
FFPC

Contender gives
2024 R1
Johnston, Quentin
Team Defense, NO

Builder gives
Montgomery, David
Warren, Jaylen
Team Defense DAL
 
Last edited:
Not a specific offer but rather a conversation that i love.

Team A. What would it take for me to acquire Amon?

Me. I say it would have to include one of your 4 best players in a deal

Team A. Could we get something done without any of those 4 players u just mentioned?

Me. Crickets.
 
I was offered QB Kyle Allen, S Jartavius Martin and a 4th rd pick for…….WR Tank Dell.

Technically it is a deep roster keeper league, but it functions like a hybrid keeper/dynasty league.
 
FFPC

Contender gives
2024 R1
Johnston, Quentin
Team Defense, NO

Builder gets
Montgomery, David
Warren, Jaylen
Team Defense DAL
Maybe I’m missing something but this doesn’t seem horrible to me.
I agree, the builder countered with the below.

Warren, Jaylen
For
Chubb, Nick
Moore, DJ
If you agree it isn't horrible, why did you post it here?
Because I wasn't sure if my original offer was so bad that maybe I deserved the absurd counter the other owner sent. I know my post was a little sneaky (my apologies), but I wanted to get an unbiased opinion on my original offer.
 
FFPC

Contender gives
2024 R1
Johnston, Quentin
Team Defense, NO

Builder gets
Montgomery, David
Warren, Jaylen
Team Defense DAL
Maybe I’m missing something but this doesn’t seem horrible to me.
I agree, the builder countered with the below.

Warren, Jaylen
For
Chubb, Nick
Moore, DJ
If you agree it isn't horrible, why did you post it here?
Because I wasn't sure if my original offer was so bad that maybe I deserved the absurd counter the other owner sent. I know my post was a little sneaky (my apologies), but I wanted to get an unbiased opinion on my original offer.
Why would the builder trade his 1st rd pick?
 
Couple interesting ones lately in 14 and 16 team leagues I’m in. All offers were made by me to non-playoff teams:

Team A - K. White LB (was 9th in ppg when offer made), McPherson PK
Team B - A. Gibson RB
Response: LOL, no thanks

Team A - K. White LB, E.J. Epenesa DE, C. okonkwo TE, 2024 1st (hopefully late)
Team B - D. Henry RB, L. Thomas TE
Counter - Henry/Thomas for Diggs/1st

Team A - D. Douglas WR, A. Pierce WR
Team B - D. Schultz TE
Response: not remotely close

Team A - K. Williams RB (this was in week 3)
Team B - 2024 2nd
Counter - Williams for Chase

Starting to question what constitutes a decent offer in some leagues.
 
I'm in a 14-team superflex with 2 PPR for TEs. It's a public league (like FFPC, but not as well-known) so I don't know anyone in the league.

I started 1-6, but sixth place in potential points. The vultures circled.

After week 3:

I give: CMC
I get: mid-round 2024 R1

Week 5:

I give: CMC, Kupp, Geno Smith
I get: Will Levis, Kenny Pickett, Tank Bigsby, Jonathan Mingo, Jayden Reed, Rashee Rice

Week 7:

I give: CMC
I get: Darnell Washington, 2024 R1 (from first-place team)

I give: CMC, Dak Prescott
I get: Tutu Atwell, Darnell Washington, 2024 R1 (from first-place team)

Week 10:

I give: CMC
I get: Tutu Atwell, 2024 R1 (from first-place team)

Week 11:

I give: Prescott
I get: Deshaun Watson (IR)
 
I'm in a 14-team superflex with 2 PPR for TEs. It's a public league (like FFPC, but not as well-known) so I don't know anyone in the league.

I started 1-6, but sixth place in potential points. The vultures circled.

After week 3:

I give: CMC
I get: mid-round 2024 R1

Week 5:

I give: CMC, Kupp, Geno Smith
I get: Will Levis, Kenny Pickett, Tank Bigsby, Jonathan Mingo, Jayden Reed, Rashee Rice

Week 7:

I give: CMC
I get: Darnell Washington, 2024 R1 (from first-place team)

I give: CMC, Dak Prescott
I get: Tutu Atwell, Darnell Washington, 2024 R1 (from first-place team)

Week 10:

I give: CMC
I get: Tutu Atwell, 2024 R1 (from first-place team)

Week 11:

I give: Prescott
I get: Deshaun Watson (IR)
Those offers from the first place team:x
 
I'm in a 14-team superflex with 2 PPR for TEs. It's a public league (like FFPC, but not as well-known) so I don't know anyone in the league.

I started 1-6, but sixth place in potential points. The vultures circled.

After week 3:

I give: CMC
I get: mid-round 2024 R1

Week 5:

I give: CMC, Kupp, Geno Smith
I get: Will Levis, Kenny Pickett, Tank Bigsby, Jonathan Mingo, Jayden Reed, Rashee Rice

Week 7:

I give: CMC
I get: Darnell Washington, 2024 R1 (from first-place team)

I give: CMC, Dak Prescott
I get: Tutu Atwell, Darnell Washington, 2024 R1 (from first-place team)

Week 10:

I give: CMC
I get: Tutu Atwell, 2024 R1 (from first-place team)

Week 11:

I give: Prescott
I get: Deshaun Watson (IR)
Those offers from the first place team:x
I would have Guido pay him a visit with a horse's head or dead fish wrapped in newspaper.
 
This isn’t even a trade. It’s a pox upon dynasty leagues. The vague trader.

Posts to the league GroupMe “I’m bored, let’s make a trade.”

Ok, I’m game. Message him, “is so & so available? If so, what position are you looking to address?”

He asks me who I’m interested in moving.

Wut

I throw out a name.

“Not interested in him”

Ok buddy, work with me here. I can’t do literally all the work. I’m not naming 56 other names until you perk up.

I just said, “ok well maybe take a look at my roster and throw out some offers. Worst I can do is reject.”

He says “ok thx”. That was an hour ago. No offers.

I-

:rant:

Ps - worth noting, I won the league last year, so my team has some solid assets.
 
This isn’t even a trade. It’s a pox upon dynasty leagues. The vague trader.

Posts to the league GroupMe “I’m bored, let’s make a trade.”

Ok, I’m game. Message him, “is so & so available? If so, what position are you looking to address?”

He asks me who I’m interested in moving.

Wut

I throw out a name.

“Not interested in him”

Ok buddy, work with me here. I can’t do literally all the work. I’m not naming 56 other names until you perk up.

I just said, “ok well maybe take a look at my roster and throw out some offers. Worst I can do is reject.”

He says “ok thx”. That was an hour ago. No offers.

I-

:rant:

Ps - worth noting, I won the league last year, so my team has some solid assets.
Ah, the old “make me an offer “ approach.

Offer made:

“I don’t like that offer. Make me another one”.

🤬🤬🤬
 
This isn’t even a trade. It’s a pox upon dynasty leagues. The vague trader.

Posts to the league GroupMe “I’m bored, let’s make a trade.”

Ok, I’m game. Message him, “is so & so available? If so, what position are you looking to address?”

He asks me who I’m interested in moving.

Wut

I throw out a name.

“Not interested in him”

Ok buddy, work with me here. I can’t do literally all the work. I’m not naming 56 other names until you perk up.

I just said, “ok well maybe take a look at my roster and throw out some offers. Worst I can do is reject.”

He says “ok thx”. That was an hour ago. No offers.

I-

:rant:

Ps - worth noting, I won the league last year, so my team has some solid assets.
"Please compile a list of all possible trades (approximately 2^60) that could possibly occur between our two teams. Then circle all trades you would be willing to do. Submit by Tuesday. Thank you."
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Top