As long as they're clean, you're good. Shoes are so subjective, and hardly universal. You have to take into account your height, shoe size, what you're wearing them with, and if the shoe fits true to size. But the main thing is that they're clean. Just know that if you're wearing some old, nasty, dusty pieces of crap that it gets noticed. If you wanna come across as an independent man with his life together, spend some time thinking about this. Because if you are an old man with dirty, tired shoes I'm going to assume either your mom or your wife dresses you, and she gave up a long time ago. Keep your shoes fresh bro. That's all that matters.
My guess is that they're pretty new and people are complimenting the cleanliness rather than the actual shoe itself. Congrats on that.