Who would you pick #1 overall? (1 Viewer)

[chris1969]

I have a friend that loves to say perceived reality is reality, to which I usually reply that percieved reality is lazy BS.

Here's the way I look at it....

Best Arm by far Marino

Best Guy after the snap Unitas

Best Guy before the snap Manning

But Manning is very close in the other catagories and has few weaknesses. He is so good at creating mis-matches before the snap that as a coach I think I would stop calling plays.

I think that these 3 guys are closer to geing QB Icons than the other 3 though.

 

[chris1969]

I'm 37 BTW born 1969 the year Neil Armstrong landed on the moon.

For the guy that thought Bert Jones was a TE, Stretch Armstrong did not land on the moon.

 

[cr8f]

If injuries weren't a factor I always liked Bert Jones.

 

[Bob Henry]

If all three were "rookies" and I were evaluating them equally, I'd say Bert Jones then Aikman then Namath.

 

[gump]

If injuries weren't a factor I always liked Bert Jones.

If injuries weren't a factor, Joe Namath was Steve Young 25 years earlier.