Kitrick Taylor said:
I don't think anybody is saying there isn't some randomness to Julio's lack of TDs. I'm confident as a dynasty owner that he'll do fine over the long haul in the TD department.
Imagine yourself as somebody that plays standard scoring in a redraft league. Julio has scored between 5-11 points in 8 out of 10 weeks. The reality is that whatever guy your opponent is likely throwing out there as his WR3 is likely to match that or come close enough to not make much of a difference. As an example, Julio (13th in standard) has 14 more points on the season than Mike Wallace (22nd). Julio outscored Wallace 28-8 in week 3. Outside of that single week, Wallace has outscored Julio by 6 points. Most people spent a 2nd round pick on Julio. Wallace has just slightly over performed his 7th round ADP.
To put it another way, the difference between Julio and the average of the top 5 WRs is 46.5 points on the season. Guys scoring about 46 points less on the season that Julio? WR53 Taylor Gabriel, WR54 Markus Wheaton, WR55 Greg Jennings.
Julio has been a pretty big disappointment on the season in standard scoring leagues. The TDs will likely correct themselves over time. But to the guy that drafted him in RD2 this year that's not really helping.
This is just so bizarre to me. Before the season, all anyone can ever talk about is how consistency is king. Consistency consistency consistency, gotta go get yourself a consistent WR. And now we have a top-12 fantasy WR who is pretty much as consistent as is humanly possible, topping 9.8 fantasy points in every single contest in PPR scoring and exceeding 50 receiving yards in 21 straight games, (the second-longest streak in NFL history), and the talk is all about how "sure, but he's not going to blow up and win you any weeks, so he's barely any better than a WR3". Huh?
It seems that what guys really want is someone who will consistently blow up every week and win you games. That's awesome! But there are only a tiny handful of Antonio Browns or Demaryius Thomases or Jordy Nelsons to go around. As a Julio owner, I would rather he be performing like Antonio Brown, just like the owner of every single WR in fantasy football wishes that WR was performing like Antonio Brown. But at the end of the day, Julio Jones is a top-12 fantasy receiver and has been as consistent as they come, and from the way his owners talk about him, he might as well be a fantasy WR3.
I'd like more out of Julio Jones, and that's especially true in standard scoring leagues (where you're always going to be more at the mercy of weekly touchdown fluctuations). But he's been a top-12 WR in every scoring system. Why aren't we seeing 10-page threads filled with dire concern over Alshon Jeffery and Brandon Marshall, both of whom were drafted in a similar range and have underperformed by a greater amount, even in standard scoring? It just strikes me as weird how the tone in here has gotten so dire and negative over what really amounts to a slight underperformance that many indicators suggest is highly likely to regress over the final six weeks.
The gap in standard scoring between Dez and Julio has been decent (20 points, WR7 vs. WR12), but in other scoring systems they've been pretty neck-and-neck. In PPR, Dez has been WR7 to this point and Julio has been WR9. FBGs' staff leagues use a performance scoring that gives bonuses for 100-yard games, and Dez and Julio check in at WR8 and WR9. I play in a yardage-heavy scoring system that has Dez at 10th and Julio at 12th, about the equivalent of 4 points apart. FBGs' rest-of-year projections have Dez at WR10 and Julio at WR11 in all four scoring formats (standard, PPR, performance, yardage-heavy). Dez has a marginal edge in all scoring systems, but he was expected to- his ADP put him at the end of the first and Julio in the middle of the second. Yet everything in DezLand is all smiles and sunshine and everything in JulioWorld is all gloom and rain. It's just... I don't know. I don't really have a better word for it than "weird".
I guess maybe it's because Julio's big games came earlier in the year, and so we've sort of forgotten about them, or worse, we feel like he's trending downwards? Or maybe because Julio has a teammate who has done pretty well over the last four weeks, so it feels like someone is "stealing" his stats? I don't know. Weird.