I've participated in several SLs to date, but I feel like I'm finally starting to get comfortable with the format. I've never had a great deal of success in any of the SLs (don't believe I've ever had a top three finish), but as many have already mentioned, the true value in these drafts isn't a win.
First of all, if you have 16 (really 64 considering there are four WSLs) FFers
drafting in freaking January and February you know you're getting the hardest of the core. The competition level is as elite as they come. Then there is the commentary. Not only do we have excellent MBers with dynamite analysis and contributions, but we're also privy to the opinions of proven FBG staffers like Rudnicki, Pasquino, and Bloom. The pace of these drafts---the slow burn of strategy and tinkering; the hands off management (draft and done); the competition level---these SLs are definitely some of my favorite activities of the FF year.
The Draft
Drawing the 1.07 was a gift---I absolutely love attempting to scoop value that falls of the turns. The middle of the draft is the place to do it, where you don't have to struggle through the long valleys without any picks. Its harder to get a heads up on positional runs, but you're also rarely left in the dark.
BPA was my basic strategy in the first few rounds. This slowly turned into a focus on acquiring a deep WR core. Obviously you need a strong team with some bye-week and injury-related breaks to make it far in the WSLs, but I've fully moved to the belief that the WR position is the most make-or-break part of a squad.
1.07 - Steven Jackson, RB6, St. Louis Rams - Of the tier 2 RBs (Gore/Jackson/Turner/Mendenhall/Willams/Stewart), Jackson is my favorite. I'm biased as I've owned the guy in my keeper league for the last four years. His situation holds him back, but his talent, drive and determination are unparalleled. What he did on the pathetic Rams last year was truly a marvel. I'm slightly concerned about his apparent chronic back/disc pain, but if Blooms isn't worried about it (thanks Audible!) I'll try not to worry about it. Love SJax as my foundation.
2.10 - Calvin Johnson, WR10, Detroit Lions – This makes two years in a row I've taken Megatron in the second round of WSL 2. At WR10, this seems like value. I think we saw Calvin's floor last year, and I think the consensus on his upside is top three. At this point in the draft I'm laughing at my own blinders, though---Calvin and SJax are the core of my main keeper league as well.
3.07 - Tony Gonzalez, TE5, Atlanta Falcons – Looking back at 2009's WSL 2 draft, it appears that I'm making a pattern of RB/WR/TE starts. Maybe thats a good thing? Tony doesn't have much upside at this pick, but he's the last of the top tier TE1s that I like and there's no way he would've made it back to me at 4.10. With a top TE secured, I'll be able to slough TE2 unless I see some value drop in my lap.
4.10 - Fred Jackson, RB22, Buffalo Bills – Was hoping Roethlisberger would fall to me here. Once he was gone I knew I wouldn't be going QB. I liked what Fred Jackson did in the poor Buffalo offense (especially considering how drastically he outperformed "more talented" Marshawn Lynch). I could easily see him becoming a bell cow in Chan Gailey's offense. The futher away I get from this pick, the more I like it.
5.07 - Kyle Orton, QB13, Denver Broncos – Yes, this was a homer pick (and I admitted as much), but with QBs continuing to fly off the board, was it so bad? Despite the McNabb rumors, I believe McDaniels will stick with Orton for at least one more year (perhaps out of necessity). Going into his second year in a notoriously hard to grasp offensive system (which he looked more than competent in at times last year), I think Orton will easily finish as QB13 or above. If the Broncos draft Bradford or Clausen
, well then I'm likely due for a November/December exit in this thing. With a weak QB1 I'm going to be looking for one of the top end QB2s relatively soon.
6.10 - Derrick Mason, WR32, Baltimore Ravens – Maybe I'm higher on the guy the most, but I was shocked that Mason made it to me, especially with the news breaking that he likely is going to return as Baltimore's defacto #1 WR. Maybe the Marshall/Boldin trade talk has folks a little scared? At WR32 this seems like a steal to me.
7.07 - Austin Collie, WR38, Indianapolis Colts – The Colts four receivers went 01.09, 05.16, 07.07 and 07.12. I'm thinking at least two of us won't be pleased with the results. I actually like Collie a great deal better than Garcon, especially after Garcon's ill-timed Super Bowl drop and Peyton's subsequent perceived loss of confidence in him (thanks again Bloom/Audible!). Actually,
this Peter King article is what really has me high on Collie. That said, I'm not sure he is a worthy WR3.
8.10 - Matthew Stafford, QB20, Detroit Lions – Last of the QB2s I wanted, plus I need a high upside guy to balance out Orton. Love this kid's toughness and the possibly synergy with Megatron. Hopefully Detroit and Denver don't have the same bye week.
9.07 - Chaz Schilens, WR53, Oakland Raiders – The most hyped sleeper of 2009 didn't see the field nearly enough to earn his preseason praise, but he's still the de facto #1 WR in Oakland in 2010. Can he stay healthly? Will the Oakland situation improve? The answers are murky, but I love his upside as my WR4.
10.10 - Chester Taylor, RB46, UFA – As the clear-cut top UFA RB this offseason, I love Taylor's chances. As RB46, I drafted him below his floor and he has tremendous upside. My trio of RBs allows me to explore other parts of my roster for the next eight rounds.
11.07 - Todd Heap, TE19, Baltimore Ravens – I'm not counting on him to play a full season, but with Gonzo on board as TE1 I don't need to. One of the better second TEs on any squad.
12.10 - San Francisco 49ers, DST6 – I'm looking for the Niners to improve on their 2009 performance, which included nine top 16 weeks, five of which were top five performances during the last eight weeks of the season. Trajectory---up.
13.07 - Nate Washington, WR77, Tennessee Titans – At this point of the draft I'm looking for occasional bursts of upside---consistency be damned. In 2009, Washington proved to be good for a few WR2 type starts with the rare WR1 upside possible. I imagine his numbers could be eaten into by Britt's growth, although I think he's still likely to have a one or two week scoring burst for team BusMan.
14.10 - Kansas City Chiefs, DST24 – Not all second DSTs are created equal. KC finished first one week and second in another, averaging a 14.1 positional rank over the season---good for 10th highest average (tied with Arizona). They're young, too, so there is room for optimism. That said, they could just as easily stumble. As DST24, worth the risk.
15.07 - Nate Keading, PK4, San Diego Chargers – Kicker time! Kaeding had a rough ending to 2009, but he's too good to pass up as a legit PK1.
16.10 - Jay Feely, PK15, UFA – Wanted a second kicker with a secure job---so much for that! Hopefully Feely finds a home soon (and perhaps it'll be his old one in New York).
17.07 - Kevin Ogletree, WR87, Dallas Cowboys - I'm definitely drinking the Ogletree Kool-Aid. As an UVA alum (and ex-season ticket holder) Ogletree was one of the few offensive bright spots for the Wahoos two years ago. When he left school early I was dissapointed and certain he was making a poor decision. I thought he graded out as a 3rd rounder the middle of his junior year, but he ended up going undrafted. The kid has skills, and only has Roy Williams and Patrick Crayton to pass for a starting spot. The staff/FO in Dallas seems to be in love with him. Ogs just might be the key to a late season burst for team BusMan (if I'm around that long).
18.10 - Jason Avant, WR94, Philadelphia Eagles – I had Avant on my list for quite a few rounds, and he ended up being the last WR on my list still available here. If last year was any indication, he'll far exceed his draft spot (two top tens performances plus an additional three weeks of WR2 production). I don't see the QB situation determining his upside---Philly has been high on Avant for a while.
19.07 - Maurice Morris, RB71, Detroit Lions – Time for some RB flyers. Probably my least decisive pick of the draft. Didn't really love anyone here so I took a guy that might get some quality starts in the early part of the year. Could help cover my RB corps in case Lynch somehow sticks in Buffalo and gets the opening day nod. Or SJax's back flares up. Or Chester re-signs with Minnesota. Likely won't be producing the entire year, though, as Detroit might bring in some outside help (did somebody say Chester Taylor?) or draft a back or two. Guess they could forget they don't like Kevin Smith, too.
20.10 - Montario Hardesty, RB80, Rookie – This rookie comes with the Bloom-wanted-him seal of approval. Dig that. I'll be paying attention to Draft Saturday to see where he lands (or maybe Draft Friday?).
QBs could be my undoing. I thought long and hard about Pennington or Bradford as a QB3, but ultimately decided I should get some RB depth and roll with what I think are two solid 16-game starters this year.
My
RBs are solid---nothing explosive but likely average or above.
Love the upside of the
WR corps.
TEs are definitely above average as a combo.
DEFs and
PKs are suitable.
I'm not as optimistic as Bloom's write up (
thank you, sir) indicates I should be, but for now, I like this team. A lot.
I'll have more later...
polish edited