'griff321 said:
'mdlane said:
'trader jake said:
It's easy to be being enthralled by Dez's athletic ability and upside but it's also difficult to ignore the off-the-field issues and problems staying healthy. I'm torn on him.
Last night he and Romo did make one of the biggest plays in the game when Romo found him on a broken play scramble and heave for a 1st down late in the 4th.
I think you're describing a WR13ish (high WR2 with top-5 upside and low bust-risk unless injured). A lot of the disappointment has to do with expectations rather than performance - because his performance last night was startable. Calvin faced that a ton the last couple years, too.
Calvin still performs like a beast when injured. Dez doesn't. Until Dez proves otherwise he'll always be the Bryant McKinnie of wide receivers. I'm an owner in a few leagues and I hate it. If I could move him for less I would in a heartbeat.
If you go back to the first four games last year, there were multiple threads about how disappointing Calvin is, how disappointing Calvin's injury-riddled 2009 was, and how Calvin is all hype. That all the Calvin supporters just liked to make excuses to explain why Calvin couldn't consistently produce at an elite level. And then, he started to.
I see Dez and this thread the same way. You can't compare Dez to Crabtree - I've watched both and Dez is just flat out more talented than Crabtree.
I refuse to believe that, barring injury, Dez won't be a top-7 WR with the potential in fantasy football to dominate your opponent any given week. I guess I'm the opposite of you - I don't own him in most leagues because he was always too expensive, but if I could pay some middling RB for him now, I would do it in every league I play in. Because 8 pts in a week isn't a bust and the potential is there for 30.
That's nice. If I refuse to believe the Packers lost the 97 Superbowl to the Broncos, do you think they'll give the victory to the Packers?
Dez's issues have nothing to do with his talent level. It has a lot to do with what's between his ears. Maybe he'll put it all together someday. There's starting to be a lot of red flags as early indicators however.
I think it was Mike McCarthy that said "I used to think injuries were a matter of luck. Now I know it is a skill."
So far Dez has shown that he doesn't posses that skill. He's also shown he's not really handling his newfound money or success very well.
That doesn't sound like a recipe for long term success to me.
As for Crabtree, I think he's got plenty of talent. I think you could make a compelling argument that Dez has more, but that's really immaterial to the point. Both Dez and Crabtree are similar because they've had trouble staying healthy early in their careers. For the record, I'm also concerned about Hakeem Nicks' ability to stay healthy.