Eephus
Footballguy
Seems silly to me. The Hall isn't a zero sum game. Why should admitting Greg Maddux mean bumping somebody down a level. Inducting Rabbit Maranville doesn't diminish Honus Wagner's achievements one iota, it just means one more plaque for shadyridr to obliviously wander past.I heard a proposal recently (maybe it's been discussed here already) that out of the HoF, there are 100 players designated as the "greatest ever". However, you can get kicked out of the "greatest ever" by some new "greatest ever". Not out of the HoF, but out of the "l33t" of the HoF. Then you could let all kinds borderline guys in to the basic Hall, but not into the "greatest ever".
Last edited by a moderator: