The Captain
Footballguy
Team A wants to win now.I came home to this blockbusterPhillip Rivers, Vincent Jackson, Thomas Jones, Tony GonzalezforBen Roethlisberger, Steve Smith Sr., Brandon Jacobs, Brent Celek, Mario Manningham
Team A wants to win now.I came home to this blockbusterPhillip Rivers, Vincent Jackson, Thomas Jones, Tony GonzalezforBen Roethlisberger, Steve Smith Sr., Brandon Jacobs, Brent Celek, Mario Manningham
Team B also just recently traded the 1.1 for Braylon Edwards to the same Team A, cumulative result being Team A gave: Braylon Edwards, Cedric Benson, Austin Collie, TJ HoushTeam B gave: Chris Wells, 1.1 and 1.2 (plus the 3.08 to even out the trade some)Team B got owned.12 TEAM PPRTeam A Traded: Cedric Benson/TJ Housh/Austin CollieTeam B Traded: Chris Wells/1.2
team a ... wow, nice deal to start a major overhaul.Team B also just recently traded the 1.1 for Braylon Edwards to the same Team A, cumulative result being Team A gave: Braylon Edwards, Cedric Benson, Austin Collie, TJ HoushTeam B gave: Chris Wells, 1.1 and 1.2 (plus the 3.08 to even out the trade some) :(Team B got owned.12 TEAM PPRTeam A Traded: Cedric Benson/TJ Housh/Austin CollieTeam B Traded: Chris Wells/1.2
I was sitting about 3 feet from my screen and 1st read that as the 1.2, 4.9, and 10.11 picks. I thought, "what kind of league has a 10 round rookie draft?"Time to get some reading glasses I guess..This one just happened in my league- 12 team dynasty, 1/2 pt per catch.Team A- Gave Rookie Picks 1,2,4,9,10,11Team B gave- Steven Jackson, Vincent Jackson and Peyton Manning.Team B was pretty good, but didnt have the horses to win it all and is rebuilding. Team A is obviously trying to win this year.
Team B did well.Team A gave up Johnson, Calvin DET WR; Year 2010 Draft Pick 2.11Team B gave up White, Roddy ATL WR; Year 2010 Draft Pick 1.10;Year 2010 Draft Pick 2.05
I think Team B got killed in this deal. 6 picks in the top-11 is nice and all, but he just traded three studs. I can't imagine he wouldn't have been at least a playoff contender with those 3 guys and a bunch of mediocre players.This one just happened in my league- 12 team dynasty, 1/2 pt per catch.Team A- Gave Rookie Picks 1,2,4,9,10,11Team B gave- Steven Jackson, Vincent Jackson and Peyton Manning.Team B was pretty good, but didnt have the horses to win it all and is rebuilding. Team A is obviously trying to win this year.
If that's the top team in your sig, I think as a win-now team that's not a bad deal at all...If I were a rebuilding team, I'd take the other side of the deal and be glad to start a building process with Garcon/Harvin...Team A (Me): Gets Larry FitzgeraldTeam B: Gets Caddy, Garcon, Harvin, 6th Round Rookie Pick10 Team Dynasty, PPR, 2 QB, 3 RB, 3 WR, 1Flex (RB/WR)Did I give up too much? Especially with Leinart the QB now.
Yeah top team in Sig. Basically I thought a 6th round pick was worthless, Garcon and Caddy were waiver wire pickups and I do like Harvin but you gotta give up something right? Also this team is still really young and I think it can definitely win now. Thanks.The other team was rebuilding after finishing 9th place this past year.If that's the top team in your sig, I think as a win-now team that's not a bad deal at all...If I were a rebuilding team, I'd take the other side of the deal and be glad to start a building process with Garcon/Harvin...Team A (Me): Gets Larry FitzgeraldTeam B: Gets Caddy, Garcon, Harvin, 6th Round Rookie Pick10 Team Dynasty, PPR, 2 QB, 3 RB, 3 WR, 1Flex (RB/WR)Did I give up too much? Especially with Leinart the QB now.
I wouldn't say 6th rd picks are necessarily worthless, though, but you definitely have to factor in luck when trying to hit on someone that late, and be hopefully that they can at least be roster filler. Someone like Murphy or Hartline last season may have been available and taken that late, especially in a 10-teamer...Yeah top team in Sig. Basically I thought a 6th round pick was worthless, Garcon and Caddy were waiver wire pickups and I do like Harvin but you gotta give up something right? Also this team is still really young and I think it can definitely win now. Thanks.The other team was rebuilding after finishing 9th place this past year.If that's the top team in your sig, I think as a win-now team that's not a bad deal at all...If I were a rebuilding team, I'd take the other side of the deal and be glad to start a building process with Garcon/Harvin...Team A (Me): Gets Larry FitzgeraldTeam B: Gets Caddy, Garcon, Harvin, 6th Round Rookie Pick10 Team Dynasty, PPR, 2 QB, 3 RB, 3 WR, 1Flex (RB/WR)Did I give up too much? Especially with Leinart the QB now.
If you got Fitz you robbed him.Team A (Me): Gets Larry FitzgeraldTeam B: Gets Caddy, Garcon, Harvin, 6th Round Rookie Pick10 Team Dynasty, PPR, 2 QB, 3 RB, 3 WR, 1Flex (RB/WR)Did I give up too much? Especially with Leinart the QB now.
This is where size of league comes into play. It is 12 team- start 6 Rb/Wr, Te, QB, K, D. So you have to have a deep team. He barely made the playoffs and really has no hope of winning it all. Just doesn't have enough pieces to get there. So He rebuilt. This trade went down next- The team that got Jackson, etc. traded- Braylon, Slaton, Reggie Bush and 4 1st's in 2011 for Adrian Peterson, Randy Moss, B. Westbrook. In our league Picks are cheap at the beginning of the year and their value goes up late in the season and right before the draft.I think Team B got killed in this deal. 6 picks in the top-11 is nice and all, but he just traded three studs. I can't imagine he wouldn't have been at least a playoff contender with those 3 guys and a bunch of mediocre players.This one just happened in my league- 12 team dynasty, 1/2 pt per catch.Team A- Gave Rookie Picks 1,2,4,9,10,11Team B gave- Steven Jackson, Vincent Jackson and Peyton Manning.Team B was pretty good, but didnt have the horses to win it all and is rebuilding. Team A is obviously trying to win this year.
so roster fillers for Fitz??Team A (Me): Gets Larry FitzgeraldTeam B: Gets Caddy, Garcon, Harvin, 6th Round Rookie Pick10 Team Dynasty, PPR, 2 QB, 3 RB, 3 WR, 1Flex (RB/WR)Did I give up too much? Especially with Leinart the QB now.
Harvin was a regular starter. Garcon was a bye week filler. Caddy was a bench warmer. All 3 will start though for the other team. win-winso roster fillers for Fitz??Team A (Me): Gets Larry FitzgeraldTeam B: Gets Caddy, Garcon, Harvin, 6th Round Rookie Pick10 Team Dynasty, PPR, 2 QB, 3 RB, 3 WR, 1Flex (RB/WR)Did I give up too much? Especially with Leinart the QB now.
I'll take Bowe and the 1.0114 team PPRBowe2010 1.012011 3rd round pickJenningsA.BradshawM.Bush2010 2.062011 4th round pick
guys are depth starters..Harvin without Favre?? Garcon is a bye-week filler...and if you are starting Caddy you're in trouble...plain and simple.Harvin was a regular starter. Garcon was a bye week filler. Caddy was a bench warmer. All 3 will start though for the other team. win-winso roster fillers for Fitz??Team A (Me): Gets Larry FitzgeraldTeam B: Gets Caddy, Garcon, Harvin, 6th Round Rookie Pick10 Team Dynasty, PPR, 2 QB, 3 RB, 3 WR, 1Flex (RB/WR)Did I give up too much? Especially with Leinart the QB now.
this is a joke trade.Harvin was a regular starter. Garcon was a bye week filler. Caddy was a bench warmer. All 3 will start though for the other team. win-winso roster fillers for Fitz??Team A (Me): Gets Larry FitzgeraldTeam B: Gets Caddy, Garcon, Harvin, 6th Round Rookie Pick10 Team Dynasty, PPR, 2 QB, 3 RB, 3 WR, 1Flex (RB/WR)Did I give up too much? Especially with Leinart the QB now.
I have Bowe & the 1.1 in a 12 team league (on the block) and I agree. Maybe @ 1.6 or later, but not the 1.1SpineDoc said:I'll take Bowe and the 1.01D said:14 team PPRBowe2010 1.012011 3rd round pickJenningsA.BradshawM.Bush2010 2.062011 4th round pick
I think I like the deal for the team getting Harrison in a PPR. Interesting trade though. I'm glad Miles woke you up so you had a chance to post it.16 team start 3 WR st 1 rb st 1 rb/te PPRJerome Harrison and Julian EdelmanforCedric Benson (Benson owner was also a Welker owner)
Love the side getting Finley12 team PPR - WCOFF scoringTeam A - J. Finely, 1.05 and a 2nd rounder in 2011Team B - A.Gates, and Mike Sims Walker
Who do you have left at QB? just curious Either Way I like itI wonder if Welker was healthy you would still make this deal?Gave: BradyGot: Holmes, 2.5
There isnt a more overvalued player in all of FF than him. Sell High I sayLove the side getting Finley12 team PPR - WCOFF scoringTeam A - J. Finely, 1.05 and a 2nd rounder in 2011Team B - A.Gates, and Mike Sims Walker
Don't get me wrong, I really like Finley too, but I have to agree there is no upside to him with the price you would have to pay to get him right now. Everything I'm seeing trade wise with him is as if he's already Antonio Gates all over again. I'm not saying he won't be, but that's far from certain. To get him, it seems like everyone is having to pay for that potential as if it's a sure thing or already proven. You may not get burned but it seems to me there is no upside once you pay that price and plenty of downside.All of that said, I don't mind this deal. Gates is getting older and 1.05 should net one of the rookie RB.There isnt a more overvalued player in all of FF than him. Sell High I sayLove the side getting Finley12 team PPR - WCOFF scoringTeam A - J. Finely, 1.05 and a 2nd rounder in 2011Team B - A.Gates, and Mike Sims Walker
Really, I thought the complete opposite. I guess thats the beauty of it.Love the side getting Finley12 team PPR - WCOFF scoring
Team A - J. Finely, 1.05 and a 2nd rounder in 2011
Team B - A.Gates, and Mike Sims Walker
* River-Rats gave up Tomlinson, LaDainian SDC RB;Johnson, Calvin DET WR;Shockey, Jeremy NOS TE * Broncofan gave up Bess, Davone MIA WR;Bowe, Dwayne KCC WR;Finley, Jermichael GBP TE; Year 2010 Draft Pick 3.01
* Broncofan gave up Manning, Peyton IND QB;Bryant, Antonio TBB WR * Gamblers gave up * Williams (VA Tech), Ryan FA RB;Sims-Walker, Mike JAC WR
end result gave: Peyton, R.Bush, A.Bryantgot: Roth, R.Williams (VT), Michael Floyd (ND)* Broncofan gave up Bush, Reggie NOS RB;Sims-Walker, Mike JAC WR * Bottled Lightning gave up Roethlisberger, Ben PIT QB;* Floyd (Notre Dame), Michael FA WR
Pretty bad.end result gave: Peyton, R.Bush, A.Bryantgot: Roth, R.Williams (VT), Michael Floyd (ND)