OK, got my order today and I have mixed reactions.
First, I specifically ordered jerseys with no special patches, but my 3 Penguin and 1 Steeler jersey all came with SB and SCF patches. Not a huge deal, but I preferred them without the patches. On top of that, the Pens jerseys came with the "Pittsburgh 250" patches, which were worn in 2007-2008.
My order was:
For myself - Polamalu (white), Fleury (white), Clemente (white)
For my nephew - Crosby (white), Clemente (white), Stargell (black)
For my sister - Crosby (black)
The NHL jerseys are a little disappointing. Particularly the white ones. The numbers and the letters on all of the Penguin jerseys are vinyl, not cloth. And the inside "stitching" on the double numbers and letters are printed, not stitched. The number/letter trim is supposed to be Vegas gold, but is actually kind of gray looking. The gold trim color on numbers and letters on the black jersey look better but they still have the fake "stitching". The rest of it looks pretty good. Still worth the $45 we paid, but definitely can tell that they are knockoffs.
The NFL and MLB jerseys are great. I particularly like the Clemente jersey.
Definitely worth the money paid, but you can't necessarily expect them to all look authentic. They don't.
ETA: After double checking the website, they sent me the wrong jerseys. The ones listed under Stanley Cup 2009 look exactly in the pictures like the ones I got. The ones listed under Pittsburgh Penguins look like they have actual stitched letters and numbers. I sent them an e-mail asking what I needed to do to return the Penguin jerseys and have the correct ones sent out. We'll see what they say.