David Yudkin

If you want to get responses to questions

92 posts in this topic

To help encourage people to provide feedback on questions in the ACF, please be sure to include:- Size of League (Number of Teams)- Type of League (Dynasty, Redraft, etc.)- Weekly Starting Requirements- Scoring System- Your Entire Roster (if looking to drop Player A for Player B)This way, those that are reading your post can have a much better idea of what to recommend without guessing.You may also want to indicate what you are leaning toward or might be intending to do.

1 person likes this

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

You may also want to indicate what you are leaning toward or might be intending to do.

Hey David,Great suggestions here. The only thing I don't really agree with is the quoted suggestion. It seems that when a poster states what he/she is leaning towards, many replies will just go along with it as a quick, thoughtless answer.When I post a question, I try to leave my opinion out of it so I don't bias the replies. I have done both methods (giving my thoughts and not) and not giving it seems to get more thoughtful replies.Just my 2 cents.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I'm more inclined to reply to someone who has a plan in mind, but is checking if they have overlooked something. There are too many numpties who as WDIS, then list their entire friggin' roster and expect the good people here do the work for them. Tthreads like that just make me think that the person who started it is too lazy to do their own research and really shouldn't play in FFL.To me, it doesn't matter what someone's opinion is - I'll post mine either way.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

David,Thanks. I'd like to offer another if I could - please list the opponents of the players you are considering, and whether it's a home or road game (vs. Sea, at Bal, etc). This can often be the deciding factor if it's truly a toss-up decision.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I have another suggestion and I have no clue why more people don't do this. If possible put your post in the form of a poll. Tons of people can then just click on who to start instead of replying.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

David,Thanks. I'd like to offer another if I could - please list the opponents of the players you are considering, and whether it's a home or road game (vs. Sea, at Bal, etc). This can often be the deciding factor if it's truly a toss-up decision.

This info is crucial and I often won't answer a thread because I don't feel like looking up opponents, homefield, etc. If someone wants my opinion or insight fine but don't expect me to do research for you.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

David,Another suggestion is to have people on the boards to answer questions at certain times. A few of us tried this on our own a few weeks back but it never seemed to take off. I enjoy helping people out and offering my opinions/experience/knowledge and am on here nightly. I'm sure you could get a few guys to be on at certai times to host a thread and to field questions. You could PM me if you were to set something like this up.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

First of all, there are far too many people on here that are simply looking for awnsers to ther questions and want no part of offering advice on others questions or posts. also, as someone that has strong opinions and likes to express them, I often enjoy posting my thoughts on others questions. The "exchange" of " look at my post and ill awnser yours" seems .... insulting to me. I look forward to the opportunity to help people and offer my advice. Like an offer or bribe in the headline to "reply to mine" should be leverage to get a response in the first place is silly, and additionallly it is very rarely followed through on. And fianlly, why do so many people read the threads but refuse to take the time to post a short opinion? If you are there reading it, why not simply post a short reply with a little back up to their opinion. Seeing that 18 people had viewed your post and you have one response is almost as Frustrating as the one response bieng "Yes, do it. Please see my post" If everyone was more participative and involved and was a littel more certious with the posts and replies this could be a better experience for all of us.

4 people like this

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

First of all, there are far too many people on here that are simply looking for awnsers to ther questions and want no part of offering advice on others questions or posts. also, as someone that has strong opinions and likes to express them, I often enjoy posting my thoughts on others questions. The "exchange" of " look at my post and ill awnser yours" seems .... insulting to me. I look forward to the opportunity to help people and offer my advice. Like an offer or bribe in the headline to "reply to mine" should be leverage to get a response in the first place is silly, and additionallly it is very rarely followed through on. And fianlly, why do so many people read the threads but refuse to take the time to post a short opinion? If you are there reading it, why not simply post a short reply with a little back up to their opinion. Seeing that 18 people had viewed your post and you have one response is almost as Frustrating as the one response bieng "Yes, do it. Please see my post" If everyone was more participative and involved and was a littel more certious with the posts and replies this could be a better experience for all of us.

good post

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

If you have a WDIS question list the players AND their opponents. The AC will be posting on Fridays for a few hours. I ask for nothing in return. You're welcome.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

First of all, there are far too many people on here that are simply looking for awnsers to ther questions and want no part of offering advice on others questions or posts. also, as someone that has strong opinions and likes to express them, I often enjoy posting my thoughts on others questions. The "exchange" of " look at my post and ill awnser yours" seems .... insulting to me. I look forward to the opportunity to help people and offer my advice. Like an offer or bribe in the headline to "reply to mine" should be leverage to get a response in the first place is silly, and additionallly it is very rarely followed through on. And fianlly, why do so many people read the threads but refuse to take the time to post a short opinion? If you are there reading it, why not simply post a short reply with a little back up to their opinion. Seeing that 18 people had viewed your post and you have one response is almost as Frustrating as the one response bieng "Yes, do it. Please see my post" If everyone was more participative and involved and was a littel more certious with the posts and replies this could be a better experience for all of us.

I agree but not many people are willing to respond with that type of detail. Most of us have busy lives and only have time to write a couple sentences. That doesn't make the advice any less valid. Obviously the more detail the better, but be realistic. Most people can't or won't spend their lives waiting for a reply on their posts. I love fantasy football, but I love other areas of my life too."I'll respond to yours" shouldn't be insulting. Edited by lebowski

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

A sort of follow-up to responders: try to give actual REASONS for your response (I'm not faultless there either). If someone says "WDIS, A or B"....."B" is a weak answer.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

if you post a poll, answer some other ones. if you have any additional insight that may be helpful reply to it, but at least VOTE. Its not hard and very fast. Sometimes this is all they may need, thus they made it apoll. Post for post, poll for poll.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Personally, I'm about done with this section of the board. I come here on a regular basis and try to answer 15-20 posts. When I post a question I get 2 or 3 responses. You can't expect people to help you if you're not willing to reciprocate.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I hear you. It's a good concept (ie to get various opinions) but it seems to me that most people here are POSs who aren't willing to give back what they get.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

David,Thanks. I'd like to offer another if I could - please list the opponents of the players you are considering, and whether it's a home or road game (vs. Sea, at Bal, etc). This can often be the deciding factor if it's truly a toss-up decision.

don't you basically want to get as many points as you can? It shouldn't matter who your opponent is starting. (or do you think it's a good strategy to start a receiver the opposing QB may be throwing to?)

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I've gotta start 3 of these WR's....who do I go with ? (my league is TD-heavy scoring)R Moss (redzone looks only)N Burleson (will get looks since Moss is limited)R Wayne (is definitely starting)D Bennett (injured ? if he plays should get some looks since there's no one else to throw to other than Mason)I'm leaning towards Wayne, Moss and maybe Bennett but not sure yet. Moss is messing this all up....TD=6pts every 25 yrd rec=1pt

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I feel the best way to get responses to your posts is to answer others. I know that if I get good feedback on a response I immediately look at there name and then look to see if they have any questions posted.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I've gotta start 3 of these WR's....who do I go with ? (my league is TD-heavy scoring)R Moss (redzone looks only)N Burleson (will get looks since Moss is limited)R Wayne (is definitely starting)D Bennett (injured ? if he plays should get some looks since there's no one else to throw to other than Mason)I'm leaning towards Wayne, Moss and maybe Bennett but not sure yet. Moss is messing this all up....TD=6pts every 25 yrd rec=1pt

You hit your head on heavy objects a lot don't ya

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

When I check in here during the season, I answer the questions of anyone whose name I recognize from the FFA or the SP or preseason ACF.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I reply to 1-3 posts/polls per day since I signed up. You guys need to stop crying like little girls, DAMN! For everyone else that is not acting like be*^hes and can offer any help, I GUARANTEE I will reply to your poll/question..Seriously though it's like a bunch of girls in here..

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I tend to check in here more in the offseason. The Fall & early Winter is always busy for me with my endless pursuit of migratory fish, hunting, managing several fantasy leagues and chasing fat chicks.When I check in, I try to answer the posts that pertain to roster building/trading. I find them more interesting to read and analyze compared to the WDIS questions that you can find answers for from about 10-15 websites each week.In the last year.....Tick would be the AC MVP. Everytime I check the AC out, he usually has replied to a few posts. For those of you that appreciate my opinion. Feel free to PM me about a question you may have, since I don't regularly get on the AC. I'm always willing to try to help someone else out. As long as they are not in any of my leagues :).-salmonstud

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

First of all, there are far too many people on here that are simply looking for awnsers to ther questions and want no part of offering advice on others questions or posts.

also, as someone that has strong opinions and likes to express them, I often enjoy posting my thoughts on others questions. The "exchange" of " look at my post and ill awnser yours" seems .... insulting to me.

I look forward to the opportunity to help people and offer my advice. Like an offer or bribe in the headline to "reply to mine" should be leverage to get a response in the first place is silly, and additionallly it is very rarely followed through on.

And fianlly, why do so many people read the threads but refuse to take the time to post a short opinion?

If you are there reading it, why not simply post a short reply with a little back up to their opinion. Seeing that 18 people had viewed your post and you have one response is almost as Frustrating as the one response bieng

"Yes, do it. Please see my post"

If everyone was more participative and involved and was a littel more certious with the posts and replies this could be a better experience for all of us.

To your question about why some read the posts and don't reply..........couldn't it be that all don't know the answer or don't feel experienced enough to give a valid response. I know if I post a question, I want only those who know what they're talking about.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I tend to check in here more in the offseason. The Fall & early Winter is always busy for me with my endless pursuit of migratory fish, hunting, managing several fantasy leagues and chasing fat chicks.

Da U.P. eh?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Hey, salmon, how was this season for fat chicks? I almost got a 32-inch-waister once, but I let her get away when I sobered up.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I am in a 16 team league that is quite different than most leagues as rushing TDs are 6 pts and all passing and receiving tds are only 3. Obviously the league is heavily weighted towards RBs, even to the point a couple of years ago that the firs t20 picks were all RBS.The league is not a re-draft or dynasty league. We start 1 QB, 2 RB, 3 WR, 1 TE, 1 D/ST and 1 K.Just like 2 years ago, I have the #1 pick. And just like 2 years ago, I will likely take LT... but thats the easy part. What to do at 32/33 and again at 64/65 is whats the toughest thing. 2 years ago, I took 2 marginal starting RBs (hoping 1 would be a solid starter each week), but both Zeroeue and A Train flopped. Then, in a calculated risk, I took Vick (who was hurt) and Hesselbeck with my next 2 picks. I am not sure that this strategy is the right one. Last year, the team that drafted 1st took Holt and Chad Johnson with his next 2, eventually trading one to get a 2nd RB. Do you think this is a good strategy?Inanalyzing my leagues last 3 drafts and using your VBD, it seems that the best VALUE at 32/33 is a WR then an RB, and at 64/65 is another WR and RB. I am totally confused on whats the best approach.Any thoughts????

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I know I'm new to these forums, but not to FF.One other suggestion I would make to those folks asking for advice regarding what picks to make early...give more insight about the OWNERS of you league. For example...rookie owners have a strong tendency to overvalue QB's, while the guys who've done more/better research and have experiance won't.Way too many posts/replies in these threads seem to assume that the vast majority of the owners in these leagues know what they are doing.Someone asked whether they should take Manning with the fourth pick...and that's the perfect example of what I mean. My answer to that question is different in a league of mostly rookie owners versus one of mostly experianced and knowledgeable owners!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I'd like to add that it is much easier to provide feedback in the AC forum if the question is set up as a poll.Quick, easy to understand - I can review a lot more that way. Not the best qualitative feedback, but if you can, put your question in a poll to get more responses IMHO.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

DAVID....please look at mine and advise/critique...do I need to shorten post in the future? got mult looks w /no answer/help....danka.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

14 Teams.Redraft. Start 1 QB, 2 RB, 2 WR, 1 TE, 1 K, 1 DEF.1 pt. per reception.6 points per touchdown (1 pt. bonus over 50 yards, 2 pt. bonus over 60 yards)1 pont per 10 yards rushing/receiving.1 point per 30 yards passing.No interception penalty.Usual field goal points. 16 points for shutout, 10 points 1-6 points allowed. QBs-Favre, LeftwichRBs-Barber, Westbrook, Anderson, S. DavisWRs-Coles, McCardell, Travis Taylor, Crayton, Frisman (had Walker)TE-Shockey, FranksK-KaedingD-Bears Should I trade Stephen Davis for Kennison? Serious WR trouble here.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

14 Teams.

Redraft.

Start 1 QB, 2 RB, 2 WR, 1 TE, 1 K, 1 DEF.

1 pt. per reception.

6 points per touchdown (1 pt. bonus over 50 yards, 2 pt. bonus over 60 yards)

1 pont per 10 yards rushing/receiving.

1 point per 30 yards passing.

No interception penalty.

Usual field goal points.

16 points for shutout, 10 points 1-6 points allowed.

QBs-Favre, Leftwich

RBs-Barber, Westbrook, Anderson, S. Davis

WRs-Coles, McCardell, Travis Taylor, Crayton, Frisman (had Walker)

TE-Shockey, Franks

K-Kaeding

D-Bears

Should I trade Stephen Davis for Kennison? Serious WR trouble here.

terrible trade

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Just wanted to add...there are now FOUR places you can go to guarantee an answer to your question.

Tick is fantastic with dynasty questions.

The Coach's Corner...good, quality people.

Lombo is good during the week, *excellent* last minute, when most of us are gone.

And, of course, my thread...with the only restriction that you don't post a new topic on your question as well (to keep the flow of other topics off the front page down.)

And if you do post, either in these threads, or on your own, *please* answer at least 2 questions, and put a little analysis into your reply. If everyone did just that, this place would be absolutely fantastic.

Edited by Keys Myaths

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Playing first place team and looking for an upset.Scoring: 1pt/25 yds rush and rec.1 pt/5 receptions6 pt/TDMust start 4 of the following including at least 1 RB:Mike Anderon vs. B-moreCadillac Williams @ CarolinaTory Holt @ MinnHines Ward vs. ChiDrew Bennett @ HouTJ Housh vs. ClevelandKeenan McCardell vs. MiamiPlease help ruin the braggard's season.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

HELP!!!!!!!I have Alexander, Jordan and Dominic Davis. I know Jordan is out. Any word on Davis? If Davis doesn't play any one you suggest to pick up. FisherMarion BarberBarlowGore Greg JonesWells

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

What's wrong with people that makes them put questions in this thread?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Need some help.

10 team league, 3 keepers, draft format

standard scoring

start 1 QB, 2 RB, 2 WR, TE, K, Def, 1 flex

I have Peyton, Julie Jones, Willie Parker, Plaxico, and Darrell Jackson starting

I have one flex spot left to fill:

Question:

Start Kevin Jones or Antonio Bryant?

Edited by ttrhawk5

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Need some help.10 team league, 3 keepers, draft formatstandard scoringstart 1 QB, 2 RB, 2 WR, TE, K, Def, 1 flexI have Peyton, Julie Jones, Willie Parker, Plaxico, and Darrell Jackson startingI have one flex spot left to fill:Question:Start Kevin Jones or Antonio Bryant?

What's wrong with people that makes them put questions in this thread?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!


Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.


Sign In Now

  • Recently Browsing   1 member