Fantasy Football - Footballguys Forums
Yenrub

Infinite New York football Giants thread

Recommended Posts

Quote

Since trading Damon Harrison, the Giants are allowing 152.3 rushing yards per game and 4.9 yards per carry after allowing 113.8 rushing yards per game and 4.3 yards per carry prior.

Holy Schnikes that's not good for the tandem of B.J. Hill and Dalvin Tomlinson.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Quote

Ravens waived OL Hroniss Grasu.

Grasu was a healthy scratch most of the year. He made a Week 8 appearance at left guard for Bradley Bozeman and has been a starter for parts of the last three seasons. We'd expect Grassu to get claimed by an offensive line needy team.

Get on it Giants. I mean they need a tackle more than anything but OL depth is needed.

Edited by The Frankman

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Ok who is excited for today? Could the the game that makes December worth watching. If they can give Eli 3-4 seconds and not have him die the 1st half like the last 2 games, they have a shot. The key is not having him drop back 50 times; sure the secondary is almost all hurt but Saquon is a tremendous weapon and the Eagles Run D isn't as good as the stats say. Keep trotting out 2-3 TEs and get Engram involved.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
22 minutes ago, The Frankman said:

Ok who is excited for today? Could the the game that makes December worth watching. If they can give Eli 3-4 seconds and not have him die the 1st half like the last 2 games, they have a shot. The key is not having him drop back 50 times; sure the secondary is almost all hurt but Saquon is a tremendous weapon and the Eagles Run D isn't as good as the stats say. Keep trotting out 2-3 TEs and get Engram involved.

Cautiously optimistic. The Eagles secondary is banged up but it won't mean a thing if the Giants OL can't handle the very good Eagles DL

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
On 11/19/2018 at 8:49 AM, monk said:

All of these guys were drafted outside of the first round since 2010. Wilson and even Foles have won a SuperBowl ... No QB drafted in the 1st round since 2010 has done that 

  •  Russell Wilson, Wisconsin
  •  Derek Carr, Fresno State
  • Andy Dalton, TCU
  • Colin Kaepernick, Nevada
  • Kirk Cousins, Michigan State
  • Dak Prescott, Mississippi State
  • Nick Foles, Arizona
  • Tyrod Taylor, Virginia Tech
  • Jimmy Garoppolo, Eastern Illinois

 

Only one of those, Wilson has been a consistent winning QB. Compare those QB's to Luck, Wentz, Goff, Mahomes, Watson. I would rather take my chance with a 1st rounder since it is the most important position to get right. 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
20 hours ago, The Frankman said:

Fixed. Also I just saw the tripping penalty monk was clamoring about. JESUS.

They were talking about it on the FAN yesterday ... Boomer couldn't believe that it wasn't called.

 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
On 11/26/2018 at 9:34 AM, dhockster said:

Only one of those, Wilson has been a consistent winning QB. Compare those QB's to Luck, Wentz, Goff, Mahomes,

On 11/26/2018 at 9:34 AM, dhockster said:

Only one of those, Wilson has been a consistent winning QB. Compare those QB's to Luck, Wentz, Goff, Mahomes, Watson. I would rather take my chance with a 1st rounder since it is the most important position to get right. 

. I would rather take my chance with a 1st rounder since it is the most important position to get right. 

  • Dalton has a slightly higher win % than Wentz
  • Dak has a higher win % than Luck 
  • Garrapolo win % is higher than Watson and just below Mahomes (Though none of the 3 have enough of a track record) nor does Goff
  • Foles win % in Philly is higher than Wentz and he has won a SB

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
2 hours ago, monk said:
  • Dalton has a slightly higher win % than Wentz
  • Dak has a higher win % than Luck 
  • Garrapolo win % is higher than Watson and just below Mahomes (Though none of the 3 have enough of a track record) nor does Goff
  • Foles win % in Philly is higher than Wentz and he has won a SB

Yes, because winning % is the true measure of how good a QB is. You can have Dalton, Dak, Garrapolo, and Foles. I will take the others and be very happy.

As a Giants fan, who would you rather play against Foles or Wentz?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
22 hours ago, dhockster said:

Yes, because winning % is the true measure of how good a QB is. You can have Dalton, Dak, Garrapolo, and Foles. I will take the others and be very happy.

As a Giants fan, who would you rather play against Foles or Wentz?

Ummm ...you said those others aren't  "consistent winning QBs" and now winning doesn't matter?

Foles or Wentz? Coin toss ... the Giants would lose to the Eagles if Nathan Peterman was their QB

Ask the Pats if they would do the SB over with Wentz @ QB  ...i'm sure they'd be all for it

Edited by monk

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Quote

Chargers released RT Joseph Barksdale.

Barksdale battled early-season knee problems and was inactive for Sunday night's win over Pittsburgh for personal reasons. The Chargers will move forward with 2017 sixth-round pick Sam Tevi as their starting right tackle. If 29-year-old Barksdale still wants to play, he shouldn't struggle to find work.

Hey Giants ... get on it.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
15 minutes ago, The Frankman said:

Hey Giants ... get on it.

Agreed. The OLine needs to get a pipeline moving. At times Manning had time to throw yesterday, other times? Eeeesh.  

 

Happy about the win, but boy, they made it hard on themselves so many different ways.

 

And a special "hate you very much" to the NFL. Fox went to the Patsies game at the start of OT. I never got to see to the end of the game due to NFL broadcasting rules. I've been hurt by this both ways this season. First it was the Colts OT that stepped on the Giants broadcast and yesterday it was the Pats. Grrr. Living within the Patriots broadcast shadow is and has been annoying.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
9 minutes ago, IrishTwinkie said:

Agreed. The OLine needs to get a pipeline moving. At times Manning had time to throw yesterday, other times? Eeeesh.  

 

Happy about the win, but boy, they made it hard on themselves so many different ways.

 

And a special "hate you very much" to the NFL. Fox went to the Patsies game at the start of OT. I never got to see to the end of the game due to NFL broadcasting rules. I've been hurt by this both ways this season. First it was the Colts OT that stepped on the Giants broadcast and yesterday it was the Pats. Grrr. Living within the Patriots broadcast shadow is and has been annoying.

Same here bro. I am willing to bet there's a large contingency of fans in this market who would have preferred to see the end of the Giants game if it meant only missing a little bit of the first quarter. I know as an NFL fan, let alone Giants, I'd prefer to see the end of a good game than the first several minutes of my team's 1st quarter.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Quote

Cardinals signed OT Joe Barksdale.

LT D.J. Humphries was sent to injured reserve in a corresponding move. Barksdale had early-season knee issues with the Chargers and then lost his starting job to Sam Tevi before the Bolts released him on Monday. 30 next month, Barksdale has been more than serviceable in recent years.

Oh come ON Giants you could've shored up right tackle!

Edited by The Frankman

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
5 minutes ago, The Frankman said:

Oh come ON Giants you could've shored up right tackle!

I think the Cardinals had a higher waiver wire priority 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Anyone still think the Giants should have drafted Darnold over Saquon ?

Eli's having one of the best years of his career and looks like he has another couple left in him. 

If the Giants draft all O'line and Defense next year and sign a good FA or two they are right there.  They need a RT and Center on offense and an End Rusher S or Corner on defense

Edited by monk

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

After the tough start to the season it’s good to see that Shurmur hasn’t lost the team and that they are still playing hard.

Based on who they beat I don’t think we have learned anything about how good they can be next season but it’s nice to see they are still playing hard.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
3 hours ago, monk said:

Anyone still think the Giants should have drafted Darnold over Saquon ?

Eli's having one of the best years of his career and looks like he has another couple left in him. 

If the Giants draft all O'line and Defense next year and sign a good FA or two they are right there.  They need a RT and Center on offense and an End Rusher S or Corner on defense

Smoke and mirrors. Cratering YPA and no deep arm strength anymore + no athleticism, he might have a year left if the Giants legit put a lot more work into the line next year (draft 2 OL in the first 3-4 rounds, sign a 3rd as a FA). Otherwise go after Teddy B. Also Shurmur has to stick to the gameplan: Eli as game manager and work Saquon first, then allow Eli to spread it around (no locking in on OBJr.)

Edited by The Frankman

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
16 minutes ago, The Frankman said:

Smoke and mirrors. Cratering YPA and no deep arm strength anymore + no athleticism, he might have a year left if the Giants legit put a lot more work into the line next year (draft 2 OL in the first 3-4 rounds, sign a 3rd as a FA). Otherwise go after Teddy B. Also Shurmur has to stick to the gameplan: Eli as game manager and work Saquon first, then allow Eli to spread it around (no locking in on OBJr.)

I agree somewhat but this is the first time in years (maybe ever) that Eli has had the benefit of a high %  low risk passing game. I think he has looked sharp as hell in the short to mid passing game. He threw a bullet TD to Fowler while rolling right yesterday. 

Brady has been doing that for years with TE's , Slot receivers and RB's and he's considered the GOAT. Brady's not mobile either but he rarely gets touched ... Eli is doing this behind one of the worst lines in the NFL.  

Eli's obviously not Brady but he is definitely in the top 3rd of QBs and we know he is capable of winning the big game and that he will stay healthy. Not many QBs you could say the same.

 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Well, not sure what to think about yesterday. In some respects it was a perfect to capture all the good and all the bad, the hope and miserable reality. Defense unable to hold a lead, OLine unable to block up the pass rush consistently (but improved since the start of the season). Indy defense really didn't need to worry about the long ball and was able to key on stopping the run. Barkley showed signs of genius, Evan Engram looked to becoming a difference maker, Sheppard was doing good things. But work remains in a lot of position groups before this team can truly scare anyone.

Horrifying stat compare: Luck had been sacked 16 times going into the game, Eli 46. That is no way to treat an aging QB.  

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Starting Eli week 17 shows they have no interest in the other QBs on the roster. Looks like they draft someone to sit behind Eli for a year or less, or sign someone like Bridgewater, which, hopefully doesn't happen.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
1 hour ago, The Frankman said:

If the Giants want to reload and sign Bridgewater, they MUST upgrade the OL and Defense (Pass Rush and CB). The Offensive skill positions are set, but the D can't stop a cold.

Which is almost impossible to accomplish in one offseason. If they can get the OL squared away, that would be good enough for me. We'd be as good as the Bucs with top offense/worst defense type of team. It's going to take a lot of money to fix their problems.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
1 hour ago, Jello_Biafra said:

Which is almost impossible to accomplish in one offseason. If they can get the OL squared away, that would be good enough for me. We'd be as good as the Bucs with top offense/worst defense type of team. It's going to take a lot of money to fix their problems.

It depends what they use their 1st round pick on. Is there a stud pass rusher/top OL around? I'm not sure at this point but we'll have to see. They might also cut ties with Olivier Vernon to save a ton of cash.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Quote

Cody Latimer, wide receiver, New York Giants. If I’m Pat Shurmur watching Latimer make two one-handed catches while being blanketed by Dallas corners, I’m thinking, This guy is one of my five wideouts (or six) in 2019. Latimer’s first TD of the year, on standout Dallas corner Byron Jones, was a 21-yard one-hander. Then, with his right arm being pinned in the fourth quarter, Latimer made a lunging 31-yard catch, tipping the ball with his left hand and catching it just before hitting the ground. Then, with a minute to go and down 36-35, Latimer returned a kickoff to the Giants’ 48-yard line, putting them in position for winning field goal. Talk about putting some good tape out there for your team or the other 31 … Latimer won himself a job for 2019 on Sunday.

https://twitter.com/Giants/status/1079457472228675584

https://twitter.com/LeadingNFL/status/1079478328015282176

 

Odell Beckham Jr.

Sterling Sheperd

Corey Coleman

Cody Latimer (Tall WR)

Bennie Fowler

 

Giants don't need to draft a WR next year. Even if Coleman walks you have Latimer, WR core is fine.

Edited by The Frankman

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
6 hours ago, The Fearless said:

Not a Giants fan. But like the franchise. Who's your best current defensive player?

You guys still got Eli Apple?

Apple traded midseason. Best defensive player is Landon Collins, who missed the last 3-4 games due to injury. Janoris Jenkins is still a good corner but he fell off hard from his elite status last season. Oliver Vernon was a stud last year but injuries really sapped him to the point Giants may make him a salary cap cut in Spring 2019. Giants are in an odd situation where they have a lot of young up-and-comers but they're not there yet. BJ Hill, Dalvin Tomlinson, BJ Goodson, Curtis Riley, and don't forget Sam Beal their supplemental corner pick.

  • Like 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

#5 pick. What say you Giants fans? Next QB? Shore up Offensive line? Help the defense? Several options I believe. Opinions?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I think the Giants Oline is closer than people think ... 2 moves could make them a top 10 oline 

  • LT - Solder (Got comfortable and played Solid LT as the season went on) 
  • LG - Hernadez (Great Rookie - Got better as the season went on - should be a pro bowl player)  
  • C - Halapio (won the job and was playing good before the Injury) Strong Free agent Group - Paradis, Kalil and Swanson 
  • RG - Jamon Brown (did A nice job after coming over and the line played much better with him) - Deep FA group here as well
  • RT -  Jonah Williams - Bama (Could immediately start at RT and move to LT in the Future) 

https://www.profootballfocus.com/news/pro-an-early-look-at-top-free-agents-in-2019-offense

After being unable to score 30 points for almost 2 full seasons the Giants scored 38, 30, 40, 35 in the last 7 weeks of the season ...  a couple of OLine additions could make this an elite offense. Giants offensive skills positions are loaded at TE, WR, RB and  even FB (Eli Penny looked great). I would like to see them keep Coleman and Latimer because they are both talented WR's who are also excellent returners on special teams.  Eli looks more than capable of playing another season at a fairly high level with a strong oline. 

The big problem is the defense which is a real mess ... the remaining Draft picks after the 1st round should be used on a QB (if available) and Defense ... no need to draft any offensive players. 

They desperately need Edge Rushers and Safeties ... This draft is supposed to be very deep in Edge Rushers. Hopefully Sam Beal  can recover from his injury and give them some Corner depth where they are also very weak.

As Frankman pointed out the Giants did a great job of developing their young interior players BJ Hill, Dalvin Tomlinson, and BJ Goodson  (I'm not sure why he mentioned Curtis Riley though ... I thought he and all of the Safties were disgracefully bad) 

LBs Ogletree, Goodson and Lorenzo Carter look like they could be a nice core to add too and Landon Collins is of course a great Safety to build around

I don't think the Defensive FAs are a very strong group so the Giants should Draft heavy on D.

The giants have 11 draft picks but no 3rd rounder

  • 1st  - 6
  • 2nd - 38 
  • 3rd - None 
  • 4th - 3 picks (IN THE 106 TO 110 RANGE), (VIA NEW ORLEANS SAINTS), (VIA COMPENSATORY DRAFT PICK FORMULA)
  • 5th - 3 picks (PROJECTED IN THE NO. 138 RANGE), (VIA DETROIT LIONS), (VIA COMPENSATORY DRAFT PICK FORMULA)
  • 6th - (PROJECTED IN THE NO. 175 RANGE)
  • 7th - 2 Picks (VIA MINNESOTA), (VIA LOS ANGELES RAMS)

I wouldn't be surprised if the Giants tried to trade Odell for another 1st round pick which would allow them to grab the OT, Edge Rusher and QB in the 1st 2 rounds ... then package a couple of picks to move up into the 3rd round or maybe Odell and a 4th or 5th for a 1st and 3rd

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
10 hours ago, Rubi said:

#5 pick. What say you Giants fans? Next QB? Shore up Offensive line? Help the defense? Several options I believe. Opinions?

I would like to see the Giants address the RT position via free agency perhaps Daryl Williams (Panthers).

With their 1st round pick I want them do grab a pass rusher – Josh Allen (Kentucky) ,Clelin Ferrell (Clemson) or Jachai Polite (Florida)

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

At this point in time the draft analysis says that BPA for the 1st round pick will be a pass rusher, which happens to be one of the Giants' main needs.  It's also a premium position worth taking early.  When all of that aligns, and if the BPA continues to shake out like that, they have to go with a pass rusher IMO.

If one of the top QBs or OTs fall to the end of the 1st, and seems like a decent value at that point, I would like the Giants to trade up from the 2nd into the late 1st to get that player so they can also have the 5th year option.

  • Like 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I am refreshed by Gettleman. I think some of the media takes are wrong, but I like what he is saying. I feel his candor is refreshing. Sure he mumbles away some of the goofs. Ie Stewart. But I can't argue with him when he says the locker room needed to change either. At least he seems willing to admit and address the teams faults, unlike Reese. I am optimistic here. 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
On 1/1/2019 at 3:00 PM, monk said:

I think the Giants Oline is closer than people think ... 2 moves could make them a top 10 oline 

  • LT - Solder (Got comfortable and played Solid LT as the season went on) 
  • LG - Hernadez (Great Rookie - Got better as the season went on - should be a pro bowl player)  
  • C - Halapio (won the job and was playing good before the Injury) Strong Free agent Group - Paradis, Kalil and Swanson 
  • RG - Jamon Brown (did A nice job after coming over and the line played much better with him) - Deep FA group here as well
  • RT -  Jonah Williams - Bama (Could immediately start at RT and move to LT in the Future) 

https://www.profootballfocus.com/news/pro-an-early-look-at-top-free-agents-in-2019-offense

After being unable to score 30 points for almost 2 full seasons the Giants scored 38, 30, 40, 35 in the last 7 weeks of the season ...  a couple of OLine additions could make this an elite offense. Giants offensive skills positions are loaded at TE, WR, RB and  even FB (Eli Penny looked great). I would like to see them keep Coleman and Latimer because they are both talented WR's who are also excellent returners on special teams.  Eli looks more than capable of playing another season at a fairly high level with a strong oline. 

The big problem is the defense which is a real mess ... the remaining Draft picks after the 1st round should be used on a QB (if available) and Defense ... no need to draft any offensive players. 

They desperately need Edge Rushers and Safeties ... This draft is supposed to be very deep in Edge Rushers. Hopefully Sam Beal  can recover from his injury and give them some Corner depth where they are also very weak.

As Frankman pointed out the Giants did a great job of developing their young interior players BJ Hill, Dalvin Tomlinson, and BJ Goodson  (I'm not sure why he mentioned Curtis Riley though ... I thought he and all of the Safties were disgracefully bad) 

LBs Ogletree, Goodson and Lorenzo Carter look like they could be a nice core to add too and Landon Collins is of course a great Safety to build around

I don't think the Defensive FAs are a very strong group so the Giants should Draft heavy on D.

The giants have 11 draft picks but no 3rd rounder

  • 1st  - 6
  • 2nd - 38 
  • 3rd - None 
  • 4th - 3 picks (IN THE 106 TO 110 RANGE), (VIA NEW ORLEANS SAINTS), (VIA COMPENSATORY DRAFT PICK FORMULA)
  • 5th - 3 picks (PROJECTED IN THE NO. 138 RANGE), (VIA DETROIT LIONS), (VIA COMPENSATORY DRAFT PICK FORMULA)
  • 6th - (PROJECTED IN THE NO. 175 RANGE)
  • 7th - 2 Picks (VIA MINNESOTA), (VIA LOS ANGELES RAMS)

I wouldn't be surprised if the Giants tried to trade Odell for another 1st round pick which would allow them to grab the OT, Edge Rusher and QB in the 1st 2 rounds ... then package a couple of picks to move up into the 3rd round or maybe Odell and a 4th or 5th for a 1st and 3rd

It's surprising how bad the line was earlier in the year... and now they are so close to a starting 5. They obviously need depth but they haven't been on eposition away from a solid line in years. I mentioned RIley because as bad as he was at times he showed flashes that can be corrected. Young safeties have it rough in today's NFL. Giants have no plans to trade OBJr., so they'll need to make do with what they have. The big question for the Giants is when their draft spot comes up at #6 and Dwyane Haskins and Jonah Williams are on the board... who do they draft?

 

Giants obviously have to focus on Dwyane Haskins if you can get him. Would be a great QB to learn behind Eli for a year; good size and a strong arm.

1 hour ago, IrishTwinkie said:

I am refreshed by Gettleman. I think some of the media takes are wrong, but I like what he is saying. I feel his candor is refreshing. Sure he mumbles away some of the goofs. Ie Stewart. But I can't argue with him when he says the locker room needed to change either. At least he seems willing to admit and address the teams faults, unlike Reese. I am optimistic here. 

https://www.sny.tv/giants/news/key-takeaways-from-giants-gm-dave-gettlemans-end-of-season-press-conference/302320218

 

Honestly, I would not be too unhappy if every pick after the 1st 3rd rounder was on D. Get the pass rushers and corners you need; also it becomes imperative you keep Janoris Jenkins around as a vet mentor.

 

Also.... I think it's time this offseason we make a 2019 Giants thread.

Edited by The Frankman

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I was talking with a friend about the Eli thing. I agree with the linked article that end of season Eli is probably a good indication of where he is at. Early season Eli was more about the crap-tastic oline play. So with that, is a Nick Foles or Bridgewater better? I don't think so. But there is only one way to find out. Pick you guy to replace Eli and have a competition in camp. Let the best player win. My money will be on Eli. But lets see it. To be the man, beat the man. Honestly there wasn't a QB alive who could have done anything resembling useful behind that early season line. My feeling is that end of season Eli could have won a bunch more games with any kind of a real defense. 

 

Going into the offseason, I'd like to see a RT and focus on defense. And more Oline depth.

 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
1 hour ago, monk said:

I don't think the Giants should waste a high pick on a QB this year ... none of them are franchise QBs 

The 2020 QBs are stacked with  ... Tua,  Herbert, Fromm and others. Save it for next year 

https://www.12up.com/posts/6256687-2020-qb-draft-class-is-suddenly-insanely-stacked

 

 

Can decision makers survive another bad season?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
2 hours ago, MAC_32 said:

Can decision makers survive another bad season?

Were they bad because of their QB play, Oline, or Defense? Giants led the NFC east in Scoring and Eli was sacked 47 times ... Defense allowed the most points in the AFC east 

Would they have had a better season with Darnold or Josh Rosen. I'll answer that for you ...No ! Will they be better with Haskins  next year ... that's another no.

 

Edited by monk

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
13 minutes ago, monk said:

Were they bad because of their QB play, Oline, or Defense? Giants led the NFC east in Scoring and Eli was sacked 47 times ... Defense allowed the most points in the AFC east 

Would they have had a better season with Darnold or Josh Rosen. I'll answer that for you ...No ! Will they be better with Haskins  next year ... that's another no.

 

Eli was sacked 47 but some of that is Eli’s fault.  He’s a statue back there and has almost no feel for pressure when it comes.  

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Eli didn't start out of the gate when they had Warner. If they draft someone, Eli will still start the season. They have to decide if what is available in the draft this year is worth using a 1st or if 2020 is the better year to draft one. The 2020 class is being highly touted already. I'd like to see them sign Foles and wait a year to draft a QB. Use all picks this year on defense. 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
48 minutes ago, Boone22 said:

Eli was sacked 47 but some of that is Eli’s fault.  He’s a statue back there and has almost no feel for pressure when it comes.  

And after every sack, Eli gets up. He takes a beating, that not many QBs could you say would be able to withstand. He's not a mobile QB, that is a fact. Put a mobile QB in there and you think he'd do better? Maybe, but my money is on the mobile QB would be running for his life instead of being tackled quickly. Would the results be much different, though?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
1 hour ago, monk said:

Were they bad because of their QB play, Oline, or Defense? Giants led the NFC east in Scoring and Eli was sacked 47 times ... Defense allowed the most points in the AFC east 

Would they have had a better season with Darnold or Josh Rosen. I'll answer that for you ...No ! Will they be better with Haskins  next year ... that's another no.

 

So you think decision makers can survive another double digit loss season?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
16 hours ago, Boone22 said:

Eli was sacked 47 but some of that is Eli’s fault.  He’s a statue back there and has almost no feel for pressure when it comes.  

Deshaun Watson was sacked like 58 times with a better oline 

Brady is a statue and Peyton was a statue but these guys never got sacked.

Eli has always been a statue but this is the most he's ever been sacked by far. 

Edited by monk

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
15 hours ago, Jello_Biafra said:

Eli didn't start out of the gate when they had Warner. If they draft someone, Eli will still start the season. They have to decide if what is available in the draft this year is worth using a 1st or if 2020 is the better year to draft one. The 2020 class is being highly touted already. I'd like to see them sign Foles and wait a year to draft a QB. Use all picks this year on defense. 

You're going to pay Foles a lot more than Eli and for multiple years.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
15 hours ago, Jello_Biafra said:

And after every sack, Eli gets up. He takes a beating, that not many QBs could you say would be able to withstand. He's not a mobile QB, that is a fact. Put a mobile QB in there and you think he'd do better? Maybe, but my money is on the mobile QB would be running for his life instead of being tackled quickly. Would the results be much different, though?

Mobil QB is also much more likely to be injured so you'd better have a real capable backup (mo money ) 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
15 hours ago, MAC_32 said:

So you think decision makers can survive another double digit loss season?

Giants were .500 over the last 8 games of the season. 3 of those loses were to playoff teams and they lost by 1, 1, and 3 points in those games

They also lost a game on a last second 63 yard field goal ... which was a record for a game winner

Their defense sucks but they are not that bad overall

 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
59 minutes ago, monk said:

Giants were .500 over the last 8 games of the season. 3 of those loses were to playoff teams and they lost by 1, 1, and 3 points in those games

They also lost a game on a last second 63 yard field goal ... which was a record for a game winner

Their defense sucks but they are not that bad overall

 

Mind going into more depth about why the offense isn't also a problem?  I'm only watching from afar, but my impression of it has been between inconsistent and awful.  Wins over Nick Mullens, Josh Johnson, and one of those QB carousel games for Tampa wouldn't have me feeling that next season will be better either.  But perhaps there's something I'm missing about the offense from afar. I could barely stay engaged in those horrendous performances against Philly and Atlanta, so I shut down watching this team at that point.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    No registered users viewing this page.