Ghost Rider
Footballguy
Just make it Tarkus by ELP. One of the great sidelong epics of the early prog rock movement.
Last edited by a moderator:
Oh, don't get me wrong - I can't stand "Brand New Key". But, it's not my list.It not me, Melanie was getting beat up by Krista for goodness sakes.
If Krista is going to get into a cat fight with Melanie then we're missing a jello pit.I vote for "Coconut". Just so I can get that stupid, ####### Melanie song out of my head that is driving me crazy. I blame @krista4
You might be onto something here.If Krista is going to get into a cat fight with Melanie then we're missing a jello pit.![]()
i support Getzlaf's need for intelligence in his coconutI vote for "Coconut". Just so I can get that stupid, ####### Melanie song out of my head that is driving me crazy. I blame @krista4
+1 vote here. When do we vote on a replacement for Melanie?I’ll vote for 20th Century Man. The lack of anything from Muswell Hillbillies on either list so far seems an oversight to me.
Replacement for 'Brand New Key' only when you're decried the winner of the jello pit providing at least two 'lean-mean-fighting-machine' moments on video.+1 vote here. When do we vote on a replacement for Melanie?![]()
In the 'believe it or not' category. In a past life I was a native American in a tribe known as the 'sheep eaters' who lived in the Grand Tetons. I had been inextricably drawn to a spot in the back country that was an ancient Indian burial ground. True story.Doesn't look like Indian Reservation is going to make it onto either list.
While I stand by this vote, any T Rex options? I think Tim just had Jeepster and Bang a Gong from Electric Warrior. But Mambo Sun, Cosmic Dancer, Monolith, Hot Love, Planet Queen, etc... give any of ‘em to me.I’ll vote for 20th Century Man. The lack of anything from Muswell Hillbillies on either list so far seems an oversight to me.
I am sure Hot Love was absent from Tim's list because he has never heard it. While it was #1 in the UK it didn't get any airplay in this country to speak of, probably because it was a stand alone single and Reprise didn't have a LP to promote with it. Kind of doubt it will make this list too, but we shall see...While I stand by this vote, any T Rex options? I think Tim just had Jeepster and Bang a Gong from Electric Warrior. But Mambo Sun, Cosmic Dancer, Monolith, Hot Love, Planet Queen, etc... give any of ‘em to me.
I think you missed one.I have few more for consideration - also, did I miss Layla somewhere on both lists? I see Bell Bottom Blues made it.
reaction
Al Green - I Can't Get Next To You (charted the Temptations earlier hit)
Alice Cooper - Eighteen
Alice Cooper - Under My Wheels
Badfinger - No Matter What
Badfinger - Without You
Bee Gees - How Can You Mend A Broken Heart
Bee Gees - Lonely Days
Black Sabbath - Paranoid (released Sept 18, 1970 ...couldn't remember if that met your criteria)
Black Sabbath - War Pigs (Paranoid album)
Black Sabbath - Iron Man (Paranoid album)
Black Sabbath - Sweet Leaf
Bread - Mother Freedom (not the usual sappy bread song)
Brewer & Shipley - One Toke Over The Line
Chicago - Free
Chicago - Lowdown
Climax - Precious And Few
Cornelius Brothers & sister Rose - Treat Her Like A Lady
Creedence Clearwater Revival - Sweet Hitchhiker
Derek & The Dominoes - Layla (reaction)
Electric Light Orchestra - 10538 Overture (majestic and soaring)
Elton John - Friends
Five Man Electrical Band - Signs
George Harrison - Isn't It A Pity
Graham Nash - Military Madness
Graham Nash - Chicago
Grand Funk Railroad - Mean Mistreater
Grass Roots - Temptation Eyes
Guess Who - Hang On To Your Life
Humble Pie - I Don't Need No Doctor
J. Geils Band - Looking For A Love
Jackson 5 - Never Can Say Goodbye
James Taylor - Long Ago And Far Away
Jethro Tull - Hymn 43
Jimi Hendrix - Freedom
Jimi Hendrix - Angel
Joan Baez - The Night They Drove Old Dixie Down  
Neil Young - Only Love Can Break Your Heart
Neil Young - When You Dance I Can Really Love
Nilsson - Me And My Arrow
Nilsson - Without You
Rare Earth - Hey Big Brother
Rare Earth - I Just Want To Celebrate
Rare Earth - Born To Wander
Richie Havens - Here Comes The Sun
Santana - Black Magic Woman
Smokey Robinson & The Miracles - Tears Of A Clown (Sept 24, 1970 release - heavy on '71 charts)
Stephen Stills - Change Partners
Spirit - Nature's Way
Supremes - Stoned Love
T Rex - Hot Love
Temptations - Just My Imagination
Three Dog Night - Liar
Tin Tin - Toast And Marmalade For Tea
Todd Rundgren - We Gotta Get You A Woman
Todd Rundgren - Be Nice To Me
Todd Rundgren - A Long Time, A Long Way To Go
Tom Jones - She's A Lady
Traffic - Medicated Goo
Traffic - Fourty Thousand Headmen
Traffic - Many A Mile To Freedom
Van Morrison - Blue Money
Yes - Yours Is No Disgrace
Yes - Starship Trooper
Yep, America not Bread and I'm going with 20th Century Man as it won by a nose.You show "I Need You" as a song by Bread, it is actually by America. I would vote for 20th Century Man.
The flip side "Skin And Bone" ridiculing fad diets is better:Yep, America not Bread and I'm going with 20th Century Man as it won by a nose.
How many rock songs mention, William Shakespeare, Rembrandt van Rijn, Titian, Leonardo da Vinci and Thomas Gainsborough?
The album Muswell Hillbillies featured purposely dated recording techniques, to give it an antiquated feel.
Although the song failed to breach Billboard top-100 (106) it seems fit for this time in history.
Released 24 Nov 1971
I call illegal procedure on this one. Lola came out in June 1970.I discovered was that Ray Davies attempted suicide after his first marriage ended within a year of these sessions and that even though later he would have a child with Chrissie Hynde he was rumored to be AC/DC. Regardless of Ray's bisexuality this song is 'supposedly' about an encounter that their manager had in a nightclub.
Most have heard the story that Ray would have to re-dub the 'Coca-Cola' line to 'Cherry-Cola to avoid legal issues.
Interesting musical note. Ray bought a used Droba and that is how the start of the song sounds so tinny and unique.
"I remember going into a music store on Shaftesbury Avenue in London when we were about to make 'Lola'. I said, 'I want to get a really good guitar sound on this record. I want a Martin.' And in the corner they had this old 1938 dobro [resonator guitar, in this case a National Steel] that I bought for £150. I put them together on 'Lola' which is what makes that clangy sound: the combination of the Martin and the dobro with heavy compression."
Released 27 November 1970
Wiki page which I checked and double checked numerous times to make certain. Lola Versus Powerman and the Moneygoround, Part One From Wikipedia, the free encyclopediaI call illegal procedure on this one. Lola came out in June 1970.
It still came out more than 6 months before 1971. Between the two current 1971 lists, both of you guys are playing fast and loose in terms of what is getting considered and what's not. IMO, you might as well count anything from June 1970 on if you Lola counts as a 1971 song. If the first time it appeared on an album was 1978, would it then be a 1978 song?Wiki page which I checked and double checked numerous times to make certain. Lola Versus Powerman and the Moneygoround, Part One From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Lola Versus Powerman and the Moneygoround, Part One
Studio album by
the Kinks
Released 27 November 1970
-----------------
The album was released in November of 70, the single was released before the album. It was the first track completed on the album so they released it early since they felt it would do well as a single.
Tim made a list of the top 100 songs for 1971. I saw a lot of songs that were leftover but decided to place songs that came out from September to not only make it to 100 songs but to include songs that were still getting air-play and charting in 71. Lola was on an album released in November of 70 so it qualified for my list if that doesn't fit your ethical standards of fair play then I can live with your outrage.It still came out more than 6 months before 1971. Between the two current 1971 lists, both of you guys are playing fast and loose in terms of what is getting considered and what's not. IMO, you might as well count anything from June 1970 on if you Lola counts as a 1971 song. If the first time it appeared on an album was 1978, would it then be a 1978 song?
I forgot it was Tim that ruled out Joy To The World because it came out in 1970 (even though it was actually released as a single in 1971 and was the #1 song of the year). Your stated purpose was to include songs released late in the year that peaked in 1971 (which makes sense). But Lola peaked in October 1970. It's your list, feel free to do whatever you want with it. But IMHO, the song had already faded by the time 1971 came around. Feel free to continue.Tim made a list of the top 100 songs for 1971. I saw a lot of songs that were leftover but decided to place songs that came out from September to not only make it to 100 songs but to include songs that were still getting air-play and charting in 71. Lola was on an album released in November of 70 so it qualified for my list if that doesn't fit your ethical standards of fair play then I can live with your outrage.
Didn't say peaked. Said were getting air-play and still charting because I remember 71 and what was being played on the radio is what I recall of that time and that is what I was attempting to capture and stated so earlier in the thread.I forgot it was Tim that ruled out Joy To The World because it came out in 1970 (even though it was actually released as a single in 1971 and was the #1 song of the year). Your stated purpose was to include songs released late in the year that peaked in 1971 (which makes sense). But Lola peaked in October 1970. It's your list, feel free to do whatever you want with it. But IMHO, the song had already faded by the time 1971 came around. Feel free to continue.
Oh come onFrom the album Abraxas which was voted number 202 in Colin Larkin's All Time Top 1000 Albums. The album was also included in the book 1001 Albums You Must Hear Before You Die.
The 1:49 instrumental at the end is called "Gypsy Queen," and was written by the Hungarian jazz guitarist Gabor Szabo. It is included as radio stations usually play "Black Magic Woman" and "Gypsy Queen" as one song.
Released September 23, 1970
First page, first post, first paragraph.Oh come on
I thought the rule was gonna be November 1970 on?
With all due respect, but seeing Sweet Jane on a greatest guitar tracks all of time list reminds me of seeing Kurt Cobain in the top 20 guitarists list, or Ringo Starr in the 10 drummers. I wonder what these people are hearing sometimes.This was Reed's attempt at writing a hit for the Velvet Underground, who were highly influential, but commercially doomed. Loaded was the band's last album, and the title was a reference to the record company mandate that the album be "Loaded with hits."
There was a great deal of acrimony during recording of the album, and Reed left before it was finished. In his absence, "Sweet Jane" was edited down, with a wistful coda removed from the song. This angered Reed, who told Rolling Stone magazine that if he knew they were going to press on with the album, "I would have stayed with them and showed them what to do."
Lou would later release a live version that many are aware of but I love this version.
Q Magazine rated "Sweet Jane" at #18 on its list of 100 Greatest Guitar Tracks, and Guitar World rated it at #81 on its list of the 100 Greatest Guitar Solos, while Rolling Stone ranked it #335 on their list of the 500 Greatest Songs of All Time.
Studio album by The Velvet Underground Released November 15, 1970
But anyone who ever had a heart, (oh!)
They wouldn't turn around and break it!
Maybe they were thinking of Lou Reed's live version on Rock N Roll Animal with guitarists **** Wagner and Steve Hunter.With all due respect, but seeing Sweet Jane on a greatest guitar tracks all of time list reminds me of seeing Kurt Cobain in the top 20 guitarists list, or Ringo Starr in the 10 drummers. I wonder what these people are hearing sometimes.![]()
![]()
Don't get me wrong, it's a nice little tune, but one of the greatest guitar songs of all time? No f'ing way.
Number one with a bullet/hammer.It’s one of the most famous three minutes and 48 seconds in rock n’ roll. And its story is marked by theft, madness, domestic violence — and murder...
... A searing guitar riff and Clapton’s tortured vocals would have made “Layla” memorable no matter what. But sealing the deal was a nearly four-minute piano coda of such sheer loveliness that “Layla” was recognized almost immediately as a new classic....
... The coda was credited to drummer Jim Gordon, who played the main piano part
I have not been paying close attention, but would the song you are referring to be One Tin Soldier, by Coven?2 100s & STILL no #1 popular song of 1971?!?!
Billboard Year-End Hot 100 singles of 19712 100s & STILL no #1 popular song of 1971?!?!