Banemorth
Footballguy
Gimmie the Doug Martin side by a slim margin. I like Morris but I will never trust Shanny.Big one...10 Team; Start 2 QB Trent Richardson2013 1.1forDoug MartinAlfred Morris2014 1st round pick (probably mid-late)
Gimmie the Doug Martin side by a slim margin. I like Morris but I will never trust Shanny.Big one...10 Team; Start 2 QB Trent Richardson2013 1.1forDoug MartinAlfred Morris2014 1st round pick (probably mid-late)
How do people not understand this? This thread would become uselsss if it turned into a trade advice thread.To stay on topic, another Goodson trade:This thread is valuable because it has trades that were actually made and not cluttered up with all kinds of offers. I agree there's some overlap but the whole AC forum is for discussing potential deals.Yes sirs!
I understand the point of having a separate forum for "advice" but a true discussion doesn't have such strict rules. Can you imagine talking FF at a bar with friends, talking about completed trades and I drop my question. Then my buddy says, "you'll have to pose that question over there at the advice booth".
If you're really bothered by my post, simply not answering would get your point across without the edge of coming off like a ####. Just saying. I posted my question in the appropriate thread now, for all of you rule nazis.
Great trade for the team who got Martin, Morris and future 1st round pick!Big one...10 Team; Start 2 QB Trent Richardson2013 1.1forDoug MartinAlfred Morris2014 1st round pick (probably mid-late)
Put me on the Richardson side. It would take Martin and a late 1st for Richardson and I think the 1.01 is worth more than Morris.Great trade for the team who got Martin, Morris and future 1st round pick!Big one...10 Team; Start 2 QB Trent Richardson2013 1.1forDoug MartinAlfred Morris2014 1st round pick (probably mid-late)
Any thoughts on this?I've just done this in a 16 team .5ppr start 1/2/3/1 and a flexIt leaves me quite thin in depth but my starting lineup is ridiculous.GiveMathewsFitzCookGetHarvinFred Davis14 2ndLineup is nowRodgersMcCoy RichardsonHarvin Green Nicks CobbGraham
I like it for you, but like you said it hurts your depth. I just wouldn't want to be caught holding the bag on Mathews, so if you have Harvin much higher than Fitz then it's a good deal for you. Fred Davis + 2nd is also a win for you.Any thoughts on this?I've just done this in a 16 team .5ppr start 1/2/3/1 and a flexIt leaves me quite thin in depth but my starting lineup is ridiculous.GiveMathewsFitzCookGetHarvinFred Davis14 2ndLineup is nowRodgersMcCoy RichardsonHarvin Green Nicks CobbGraham
Gimmie Decker/Rookie 2.01/Brown.This should be an interesting one for those interested in what Welker's movement has effected in terms of value. Just completed it:12 team PPR.GaveeckerRookie 2.01Andre BrownGot:Hernandez
It will all depend on the QB situation post-NFL draft. If there is a QB worthy of the 1.01, the Richardson side likely wins. It's a gamble now, however.Big one...10 Team; Start 2 QB Trent Richardson2013 1.1forDoug MartinAlfred Morris2014 1st round pick (probably mid-late)
What makes this even more interesting, for context, is that it's not like I was moving WR depth for a starting TE. I have Gronk actually. So Hernandez will be directly replacing Decker in my starting lineup in a flex spot, and coming off a championship it was a move I felt might pay off.Gimmie Decker/Rookie 2.01/Brown.This should be an interesting one for those interested in what Welker's movement has effected in terms of value. Just completed it:12 team PPR.GaveeckerRookie 2.01Andre BrownGot:Hernandez
Same league new day.I Give:Rice, Ray BAL RBBess, Davone MIA WRHolmes, Santonio NYJ WRYear 2013 Draft Pick 4.11Year 2013 Draft Pick 4.12Year 2013 Draft Pick 5.11Year 2013 Draft Pick 6.11I Get:Johnson, Chris TEN RBWright, Kendall TEN WRYear 2013 Draft Pick 1.03Year 2013 Draft Pick 2.12So this is the final outcome. Gave: Percy HarvinRay RiceSantonio HolmesDavone Bess1.112.114.115.116.11Got:Victor CruzChris JohnsonAaron HernandezKendall WrightJulian Edelman1.032.092.12Thanks. It really helped my position. Went from Harvin to Cruz, a wash in my mind, and from Scott Chandler to Aaron Hernandez, night and day huge upgrade.Lost some draft spots but gained depth with Edelman. Pretty happy with the way it worked out.That's a great day of trading for you. Well doneTwo in the same league. PPR. Start 19 Full IDPGiveercy Harvin, 1.11Get:Mike Wallace, Julian Edelman, Aaron Hernandez, 2.09, 4.12ThenGive:Mike Wallace, 2.11Get:Victor Cruz
1.03 all day over a 28 yr old rb with bone on bone knee and major foot issues.16-team .5pprMJD for1.03
Knowing the two rosters. Ill take the 1.03Can't understand why he'd want MJD when the rest of hs roster isn't built to compete16-team .5pprMJD for1.03
Some people can't accept this.Knowing the two rosters. Ill take the 1.03Can't understand why he'd want MJD when the rest of his roster isn't built to compete16-team .5ppr
MJD
for
1.03
accountability is not easySome people can't accept this.Knowing the two rosters. Ill take the 1.03Can't understand why he'd want MJD when the rest of his roster isn't built to compete16-team .5ppr
MJD
for
1.03
I wouldn't have sold Rice for that.No thoughts on that last one I posted?
Me neither, I think you undid some of the good work you've been doing.I wouldn't have sold Rice for that.No thoughts on that last one I posted?
I think you did well.So let's start with Rice Versus CJ2K.Tennessee has beefed up their O-Line and has committed to Johnson. Meanwhile Baltimore's defense has imploded. Maybe they fix it with the guys they have and through the draft... maybe they don't. I think they'll have to throw early and often. I also feel that Pierce presents a real threat to Rice's time. He is exceptionally talented. I'm not remotely worried about Greene. Rice is my RB4. CJ2K is my RB8. Not overly worried with the drop-off. Add in the 1.03 and that MORE than covers for the difference in my mind.Now we have Kendal Wright and the 2.12 for the 4.11, 4.12, 5.11, 6.11, Holmes and Bess.Bess isn't worth anything in my mind. Might not even have a roster spot. Holmes... another guy with little to no value. The Jets are a mess. I'd never, ever, start him. Four late picks. Lottery tickets.Now I got Kendal Wright... my second favorite WR in last year's draft class, and a much earlier pick in the 2.12. Should be some real value there in a deep draft class. The way I saw it.CJ2K 1.03 > RiceWright 2.12 > Trash and late picks
I'm a big fan of this trade for you. Good work.Same league new day.I Give:Rice, Ray BAL RBBess, Davone MIA WRHolmes, Santonio NYJ WRYear 2013 Draft Pick 4.11Year 2013 Draft Pick 4.12Year 2013 Draft Pick 5.11Year 2013 Draft Pick 6.11I Get:Johnson, Chris TEN RBWright, Kendall TEN WRYear 2013 Draft Pick 1.03Year 2013 Draft Pick 2.12So this is the final outcome. Gave: Percy HarvinRay RiceSantonio HolmesDavone Bess1.112.114.115.116.11Got:Victor CruzChris JohnsonAaron HernandezKendall WrightJulian Edelman1.032.092.12Thanks. It really helped my position. Went from Harvin to Cruz, a wash in my mind, and from Scott Chandler to Aaron Hernandez, night and day huge upgrade.Lost some draft spots but gained depth with Edelman. Pretty happy with the way it worked out.That's a great day of trading for you. Well doneTwo in the same league. PPR. Start 19 Full IDPGiveercy Harvin, 1.11Get:Mike Wallace, Julian Edelman, Aaron Hernandez, 2.09, 4.12ThenGive:Mike Wallace, 2.11Get:Victor Cruz
Very hard to evaluate without knowing each team's needs. Very even trade if you ask me. It's hard to determine a winner for me.12 Team PPRTeam A Trades : Hakeem NicksTeam B Trades : Kendall Wright/Andre Brown/1.3
Team A is in full rebuild mode and clearly was not going to compete this year . Currently he holds the following rookie picks ( 1.2/1.3/1.4/1.6/1.11/2.1/2.2/2.3) and a Very Young roster: Roster Highlights.QB: Romo/TannahillRB: Ben Tate/Andre Brown/Bernard Pierce/Robert Turbin/LaMichael James WR: Ashlon Jeffery/Aj Jenkins/Kendall Wright/Mohamed Sanu/Jarius WrightTE: Dwayne Allen/Ladarius Green/Martellus Bennet. I Think it was a good trade for Team A especially with the make up of his current roster.Very hard to evaluate without knowing each team's needs. Very even trade if you ask me. It's hard to determine a winner for me.12 Team PPRTeam A Trades : Hakeem NicksTeam B Trades : Kendall Wright/Andre Brown/1.3
I will take the two players and pick 3.Nicks isn't a guy I would be looking to give up a big package for. I think regardless of situation, whether you are in "win now" or "rebuild", I would prefer Wright, Brown, and pick 312 Team PPRTeam A Trades : Hakeem NicksTeam B Trades : Kendall Wright/Andre Brown/1.3
I'm the owner of team B. My main RB's are Lynch and MJD. I made the playoffs last year but didn't get far. I'm hoping that Forte can help get my team further this season. My roster after the dealalton, Andy CIN QBManning, Eli NYG QBOsweiler, Brock DEN QBPalmer, Carson OAK QB Benson, Cedric GBP RBCarter, Delone IND RBForte, Matt CHI RBJackson, Fred BUF RBJennings, Rashad JAC RBJones-Drew, Maurice JAC RBLynch, Marshawn SEA RBPeerman, Cedric CIN RBThomas, Pierre NOS RBBoldin, Anquan SFO WRColston, Marques NOS WRFloyd, Malcom SDC WRJackson, Vincent TBB WRJohnson, Stevie BUF WRQuick, Brian STL WRWashington, Nate TEN WR Gonzalez, Tony ATL TEGreen, Ladarius SDC TEMiller, Heath PIT TEWitten, Jason DAL TE Gostkowski, Stephen NEP PKBears, Chicago CHI DefTeam A gave upalton, Andy CIN QBForte, Matt CHI RBYear 2014 Round 3 Draft Pick Team B gave up:Tannehill, Ryan MIA QBYear 2014 Round 1 Draft Pick Year 2014 Round 2 Draft Pick
Seems like giving away Forte real cheapTeam A gave upalton, Andy CIN QBForte, Matt CHI RBYear 2014 Round 3 Draft Pick Team B gave up:Tannehill, Ryan MIA QBYear 2014 Round 1 Draft Pick Year 2014 Round 2 Draft Pick
Nicks is worth way more than the 1.03 IMO. Not sure if giving up Wright is too much (admittedly not a fan) but it's not a bad trade.I will take the two players and pick 3.12 Team PPR
Team A Trades : Hakeem Nicks
Team B Trades : Kendall Wright/Andre Brown/1.3
Nicks isn't a guy I would be looking to give up a big package for. I think regardless of situation, whether you are in "win now" or "rebuild", I would prefer Wright, Brown, and pick 3
Not really sure what you are saying here. Of course Nicks is worth more than pick 3. That wasn't the trade though.I also never said it was a "bad" trade, I jsut can't think of a scenario where I prefer Nicks to that package.'cstu said:Nicks is worth way more than the 1.03 IMO. Not sure if giving up Wright is too much (admittedly not a fan) but it's not a bad trade.'ghostguy123 said:I will take the two players and pick 3.'Bandite said:12 Team PPR
Team A Trades : Hakeem Nicks
Team B Trades : Kendall Wright/Andre Brown/1.3
Nicks isn't a guy I would be looking to give up a big package for. I think regardless of situation, whether you are in "win now" or "rebuild", I would prefer Wright, Brown, and pick 3
What I meant is that it comes down to how you view Wright - I view him as a WR3 type.Not really sure what you are saying here. Of course Nicks is worth more than pick 3. That wasn't the trade though.I also never said it was a "bad" trade, I jsut can't think of a scenario where I prefer Nicks to that package.'cstu said:Nicks is worth way more than the 1.03 IMO. Not sure if giving up Wright is too much (admittedly not a fan) but it's not a bad trade.'ghostguy123 said:I will take the two players and pick 3.'Bandite said:12 Team PPR
Team A Trades : Hakeem Nicks
Team B Trades : Kendall Wright/Andre Brown/1.3
Nicks isn't a guy I would be looking to give up a big package for. I think regardless of situation, whether you are in "win now" or "rebuild", I would prefer Wright, Brown, and pick 3
Starters look really good but I would prefer the other side'Donsmith753 said:Any thoughts on this?'Donsmith753 said:I've just done this in a 16 team .5ppr start 1/2/3/1 and a flexIt leaves me quite thin in depth but my starting lineup is ridiculous.GiveMathewsFitzCookGetHarvinFred Davis14 2ndLineup is nowRodgersMcCoy RichardsonHarvin Green Nicks CobbGraham
hoooooooooooooooolllllllllllyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyy crap. I thought that was ANTONIO Brown......................What I meant is that it comes down to how you view Wright - I view him as a WR3 type.Not really sure what you are saying here. Of course Nicks is worth more than pick 3. That wasn't the trade though.I also never said it was a "bad" trade, I jsut can't think of a scenario where I prefer Nicks to that package.'cstu said:Nicks is worth way more than the 1.03 IMO. Not sure if giving up Wright is too much (admittedly not a fan) but it's not a bad trade.'ghostguy123 said:I will take the two players and pick 3.'Bandite said:12 Team PPR
Team A Trades : Hakeem Nicks
Team B Trades : Kendall Wright/Andre Brown/1.3
Nicks isn't a guy I would be looking to give up a big package for. I think regardless of situation, whether you are in "win now" or "rebuild", I would prefer Wright, Brown, and pick 3
Good for both if the team getting Jackson is making a run and the other team can't14 team 0.5 ppr qb, rb, rb, wr, wr, flex, flex, te, d, k2014 1st (mid?)J. Baldwinfor2014 4thSteven Jackson
Uh, Jackson is going to whoop ### this season. Terrible trade.Any format I play to get players who are going to produce NOW.14 team 0.5 ppr qb, rb, rb, wr, wr, flex, flex, te, d, k2014 1st (mid?)J. Baldwinfor2014 4thSteven Jackson
Start 2/2 format in a 14 team league...Jackson.14 team 0.5 ppr qb, rb, rb, wr, wr, flex, flex, te, d, k2014 1st (mid?)J. Baldwinfor2014 4thSteven Jackson
Think you need to be more specific on the Jackson.12 TM; QRRWWWTF; 1.0 PPR; 1st YearGave:GreenJacksonGot:GronkBoweUnless SSOG chimes in, I'll be surprised if many prefer my side. I view Bowe as an upgrade over Jackson, whom I wanted to deal while his value is high. And while I picked Green over Gronk initially because he is safer and has more trade value, I think Gronk is a unique advantage and makes my team better. Turning Jackson into Bowe was enough for me to justify the move. BradyD.MurrayE.Lacy (Knock no wood, currently 1.01)CruzNelsonBoweAustinGronk (formerly O.Daniels/B.Myers)
Steven.Think you need to be more specific on the Jackson.12 TM; QRRWWWTF; 1.0 PPR; 1st YearGave:GreenJacksonGot:GronkBoweUnless SSOG chimes in, I'll be surprised if many prefer my side. I view Bowe as an upgrade over Jackson, whom I wanted to deal while his value is high. And while I picked Green over Gronk initially because he is safer and has more trade value, I think Gronk is a unique advantage and makes my team better. Turning Jackson into Bowe was enough for me to justify the move. BradyD.MurrayE.Lacy (Knock no wood, currently 1.01)CruzNelsonBoweAustinGronk (formerly O.Daniels/B.Myers)
I think you made your lineup worse for the next couple years. Is Green - Bowe + Jackson - Lacy < Gronk - Daniels? Based on last years stats Green - Bowe ~= Gronk - Daniels, right?Steven.
My only IDP league is heavy, so taking the defenders out of the picture, I think this is pretty good value for Jackson. Especially considering the 2014 pick seems to be coming from a non-playoff team.Green Bay Packers gave up:Jackson, Steven STL RBSan Francisco 49ers gave up:Johnson, Charles CAR DELandry, LaRon NYJ SYear 2013 Round 2 Draft Pick from San Francisco 49ersYear 2014 Round 1 Draft Pick from San Francisco 49ersZealots league...the second round pick is 2.02.
If we use 2012 averages for the WRs and TEs, yes, the gap is about equal. But looking at the last 3 seasons, 2011 was an outlier for Bowe. I feel just fine leaning on him for WR2 numbers, and expect them, even. In which case, Gronk - Daniels > Green - Bowe.As for Jackson and Lacy, I want to see what happens with Lacy before I concede him being a downgrade over the next 2 seasons. I don't think equal short-term production will be difficult to acquire, if need be, too.My worst starter is now Bowe. It was Daniels. If Gronk scores close to Green (he has), that is a big difference.I think you made your lineup worse for the next couple years. Is Green - Bowe + Jackson - Lacy < Gronk - Daniels? Based on last years stats Green - Bowe ~= Gronk - Daniels, right?
I'm not high on investing too much on a QB in the current market. But like Ryan here. Cutler is just a throw in at this point, and even if I had another quality starter, I'd need quite a bit more than Jackson for Ryan.12 team IDP+PPR dynasty league:Team A TradesJay CutlerSteven JacksonTeam B TradesMatt Ryan