LeBron rarely forces the ball and almost always makes the correct basketball play, why should he change his game to force the ball to Love? He averaged a freaking triple double. He could have had more assists and arguably extended thee series if his teammates knocked down open looks.
K - Capella should be happy cuz this will be my last attempt to clarify the point i have been trying, apparently unsuccessfully, to make since the King's place in basketball left discussion and became coronation. Have at me, cuz i wont defend. I follow arguments i can't win only so far cuz i dont do it to argue, but to make a point.
Game 1 of the Finals made clear what most of us had guessed - that the addition of KD made the Dubs an unprecedented team, with the skill of 4 stars - two super, two legitimate All-stars - working together to create unparalleled offensive & defensive spacing that was virtually unbeatable. For the first time in his career, LeBron James was really up against it. What did he have to counter? His big man was lost, his other big was compensating by going inside rather than his usual stretch-4 (at which he's in the argument for best-in-show) and his spotshooting wing is probably hungover. It's him and his Mr Outside, Kyrie.
My assertion is that the other 4 members of my all-time top 5 would have looked to use the attention on them to get these others going. No matter how talented a fighter you are, if you and your buddies run into 4 bigger guys spoiling for action, you dont counter by telling 2 of your guys to sit over there while you & Kyrie get this on, no matter how talented you are. Jordan, Magic, Bird would have all looked to get TT & JR a cupcake early and rewarded his other star for his gruntwork by allowing him to matter. Russ woulda barked, beat & iso'd his teammates til they got the point. LeBron just took it on, took it on as brilliantly as he ever has, he & Kyrie, as brilliantly as he did when he brought them back from 1-3 last year. But by doing so, he'd already conceded the loss, in the name of his greater glory.
My other, finer point is that a great gamesman precipitates reaction and further refines his own action in response. The best examples of this are Bill Walsh & Belichick in football, but the others of b-ball's Top 5 all had it.
Earlier on in this thread, i compared the King's peculiar anhedonia with that of poker legend Phil Hellmuth who, even with his titles, millions, HOF status, still must harangue players leagues below him in order to make his greatness tactile for himself. I happen to know this well because i was a professional poker player when he & his type came into the game. All of a sudden we had this wave of college kids, with their algorithms, incredible memories and pattern recognition skills. I played a smartass version of cowboy poker (in what very few mid-stakes N/L, P/L cash games were left in the 80s) where you found tendencies, set traps & cooked your rabbit.
Fortunately, no greater % of whiz kids were Hellmuth-quality than cowboys were Brunson-quality, but we had a whole new matrix to understand and defeat if we were to keep our crumbs. Most of us didn't survive - my middling talent held on to plus play until northern Nevada's only regular P/L game (featuring Freddy Deeb, Tuna Lund, Ray Zee and the occasional McEvoy) went down - but those who did prevailed by sending up differently-disguised red herrings and statistical blind alleys and reckoned their reaction patterns. We had to - only way to beat the game. I so respected the the value of newskool v olskool poker that my first post-pro act was to form investors to apply for a gaming license in San Luis Obispo (Cali was legalizing flop poker on a county-tolerance basis in those days) cuz i thought there was gold in pitting the students of Cal Poly vs the ranchers of the San Joaquin.
Back to my point. I'd love to play poker with LBJ because, while i may be amazed at how quickly he gets it, i know he'll insist on hammering me over the head with his new knowledge and that's sucker money. For that matter, i'd like to play MJ cuz i understand that losing bets is the way he feels human, so i'm counting that stack already. Probably can handle Bird til he puts a bad beat on me and gets the upside to stompin on my liver, then i'm dead. Magic will be tough cuz we got the same act - he'll make every bet, fold and smakyak seem like the best idea he ever had and he'll probably be better at it than me. Russ will be the quiet guy who giggles to himself every once in a while and nobody can figure out how all the chips ended up on his side of the table. Fun game, will feel lucky to cash and won't go back.
LeBron James stands with Jim Brown and Usain Bolt among the most powerful athletes of all time. He is a nonpareil baller with his combination of power, presence & perspicacity. But his lack of savvy, gamesmanship and joy which makes him a bad coach, terrible GM and middling teammate so far keeps him from my top spot in the Pantheon. nufced -