It not surprising that we’re here. I keep going back to asking what the Sixers exit strategy is. Force Simmons to come back, gel with the team, and have strong play boost his trade value? Or maybe hope he changes his mind about the franchise? These always seemed far-fetched and are getting even less likely by the day. And, obviously, a trade for a player like Beal or Lillard isn’t happening.
Technically speaking, Philly could compel Simmons to get an "independent" league medical evaluation under the Chris Bosh Rule. However there are diminishing returns to doing this. The Spurs could have compelled Kawhi Leonard to do that as well, as he claimed SA was toying with his health with complete disregard ( No one actually believed it) Rich Paul has a negative reputation around the league and in professional sports. He exists simply as a tax on the need for the NBA to bend the knee to LeBron James and Nike.
The owners and Adam Silver don't want a loophole where players can claim mental health to get paid not to play. Even under an evaluation under the Chris Bosh Rule, what can be determined? This isn't a back or a knee. On the flip side, no one wants the negative media optics of it appearing that the ownership group, mostly white males, are leveraging a mentally ill young black man beyond his functional capacity to perform.
Claiming mental health ( real or not) gave Simmons breathing room. The hatchet jobs in the press by Morey and the 76ers had to take a break. That being said, it works both ways. Simmons and Paul can't just unload anymore on the Sixers because they don't want it to appear that they are gaming the system.
The more Rich Paul can take Simmons trade value, the better chance he has to get him traded to a competitive team. The big hold up is Simmons signed a long term deal and doesn't have a No Trade Clause. Look at Melo. He leveraged Denver into trading him to New York. He just simply said I won't sign an extension with anyone else. Once the trade price reduces to a rental price for the rest of the league, the Nuggets were cornered.
A fair argument by the owners is a long term contract is a risk by the franchises but any player who signs a street max or a Super Max or a full Bird Rights max with the intention to immediately demand a trade is a subversion of the system. Lots of owners were angry with Chris Paul. He was the head of the players side of the NBPA and pushed for the Over 38 Rule , which was a change from the Over 36 Rule . Doing so benefited him into getting that massive deal from Houston. To get that concession from the owners, cuts were made to some of the Rookie Scale Exception benefits and some benefits from retired players of previous generations. Paul complained OKC gave him no input into trading him to the Suns. Signing that massive deal was Paul implicitly agreeing that in exchange for long term security and signing a deal without a NTC ( he didn't have the tenure benchmark in OKC) , he would surrender his ability to dictate any trade destination.
Pick one. Long term security and no control if you get traded. Or go short term deal to deal and have your freedom but without long term security. Lots of NBA players want and demand both and that's just unreasonable.
Philly getting Simmons under their medical/mental health supervision opens more pathways to rescind his contract. Or close to loophole where Simmons can get paid to chill out at home and play video games. This would force Simmons to play if he's faking this all, and by virtue of playing, his trade value can't take anymore.
If Simmons does not have a legitimate mental health issue, he and Rich Paul have effectively punished everyone in America who does. The silent argument Rich Paul is making but not saying to Morey is "Trading Simmons for little to nothing is better than trading him for completely nothing which is better than Simmons just sitting for four years killing your cap"
This is a test of Morey's resolve. All he needs is to send in investigators to bird dog and wire up Simmons completely and get him on a video and audio discussing the "mental health strategy" to Rich Paul. This would force the league to ban Rich Paul permanently. Klutch Sports would likely have to dissolve. Simmons would get his full contract rescinded and get the maximum level of fine and a multiple year ban from the league. If a non Sixers team is caught complicit, the tax wouldn't be like the TWolves and Joe Smith, it would be forcing them to hire Becky Hammon and giving her a locked in 10 year contract with minimal penalties after the previous front office and coaching staff are fired.
I don't think most people understand Morey. He'd rather have Simmons' contract fully rescinded and get no trade value back than to trade Simmons for little to nothing with Rich Paul laughing in his face.
This is the Sam Hinkie Curse. This team should have never fired Hinkie. They should have just left him alone. Hinkie would have traded Simmons a lot sooner, like he did with MCW.
Personally, if Simmons is caught faking this in public, I hope Kevin Love hits him with a baseball bat on national TV during half time. There are people out there who truly struggle and suffer with mental health. This is pretty disgusting. I'm sure someone will say there's no evidence Simmons is faking this all, but the entire narrative is cooked. It doesn't pass the immediate sniff test. This was shoddy long con strategy by Rich Paul and it shows.