Bills_Fan11 said:
Mario has been about as good as anyone could've reasonably expected. He basically won two games singlehandily last yr - vs Carolina & Miami. Sometimes it's interesting to get opposing perspectives and I had to laugh listening to Dan Lebetard's podcast Friday - asking when his contract is up and saying he should have his mail permanantly routed to the Dolphins backfield. It's also funny to hear them bring up they have the league's highest paid WR core in Miami, which is hard to believe. At least our overpaid unit produces.
If it were me though I'd basically never give a non-QB that kind of dough. Those games we stole last year don't matter because we had no QB. The games the defense has won this year don't matter because we have no QB. The games our all-star defense won in '03 and '04 don't matter because we had no QB. The games JJ Watt is winning now don't matter because they have no QB.
But I mean whatever - I think the reason you struggle to get a response is because it doesn't really move the needle for the list of decisions we wish this franchise didn't make. The Chris Williams and Leodis McKelvin contracts are much worse.
Thanks for the response. I agree with most of your premise about not paying non-QB's top dollar. If there is a player though that can help you become a dominant defense, then it might be worth it. The Ravens won with Dilfer, the Bucs won with Brad Johnson, and the Giants won with a mediocre Eli Manning in 2007. These teams won because of their defense, not because of their QB.
It will be interesting to see if Clowney can stay healthy, how dominate he and Watt can be for the next few years, and how Crennel develops the rest of the defense around them. If they are dominant then maybe the only thing they will need a QB is a game manager.