timschochet
Footballguy
It’s rare to see a game where a team dominates on the field as much as Clemson did in the 2nd half and not only fails to score but gives up 3 touchdowns. Amazing.
They haven’t beat a top-10 team in forever of course they are storming the field.This storming the field is a bit much by Duke
This storming the field is a bit much by Duke
wouldn't every late hit fall under this definition?When his knee hit the ground the play was dead. The hit came in after his knee was down, therefore not continuance.How can an act that is part of a live play not count as part of the live play?
And this is a point of contention among fans and the frustration with Dabo over the last couple of years. Time after time in other games when a great play is made we hear "transfer from <school> with an outstanding catch", etc. New rules allow a team to be overhauled (Colorado) or upgraded (ND with Harman, certainly FSU in skill positions).Dabo refusing to use the portal because it’s not in the Bible or whatever killed their potential dynasty. Thank God.
Yes. It was a bizarre call. If a runner trying to make the first down marker steps out of bounds and is then hammered into the bench, it's always been "personal foul, defense. 15 yards automatic first down." I've never seen it a turnover on downs and then the offense is penalized. The play is not over just because the guy stepped out of bounds.wouldn't every late hit fall under this definition?When his knee hit the ground the play was dead. The hit came in after his knee was down, therefore not continuance.How can an act that is part of a live play not count as part of the live play?
what percentage of these occur on 4th down?Yes. It was a bizarre call. If a runner trying to make the first down marker steps out of bounds and is then hammered into the bench, it's always been "personal foul, defense. 15 yards automatic first down." I've never seen it a turnover on downs and then the offense is penalized. The play is not over just because the guy stepped out of bounds.wouldn't every late hit fall under this definition?When his knee hit the ground the play was dead. The hit came in after his knee was down, therefore not continuance.How can an act that is part of a live play not count as part of the live play?
A sliding quarterback is down as soon as he STARTS his slide. Thus any foul on a sliding quarterback is always a dead ball foul.what percentage of these occur on 4th down?Yes. It was a bizarre call. If a runner trying to make the first down marker steps out of bounds and is then hammered into the bench, it's always been "personal foul, defense. 15 yards automatic first down." I've never seen it a turnover on downs and then the offense is penalized. The play is not over just because the guy stepped out of bounds.wouldn't every late hit fall under this definition?When his knee hit the ground the play was dead. The hit came in after his knee was down, therefore not continuance.How can an act that is part of a live play not count as part of the live play?
is there a refereeing site, or one of these advanced stats type sites that would track something like that?
was confused by the scenario myself, but i really couldn't remember one of these happening on 4th down when a QB slid and his knee went down before he got smoked.
Carolina pretty much ended it's losing streak against Clemson last year with transfer portal guys. Dabo's NIL with God won't get it done long-term.And this is a point of contention among fans and the frustration with Dabo over the last couple of years. Time after time in other games when a great play is made we hear "transfer from <school> with an outstanding catch", etc. New rules allow a team to be overhauled (Colorado) or upgraded (ND with Harman, certainly FSU in skill positions).Dabo refusing to use the portal because it’s not in the Bible or whatever killed their potential dynasty. Thank God.
Dabo said he's open to the portal but he seems to think he doesn't have holes to fill, which makes it worse as it shows his blindness and/or incompetence. The Oline has been shotty for years and he has no WR that can separate. No playmakers at wideout since Higgins and Ross left. Everyone sees it but him.
It was a nice run but Clemson's inability to read the room and adapt to the changing competitive climate is going to lead them back to annual visits to the Belk bowls of mid-December.
I shutter to think what FSU is going to do to them in a few weeks. That team is hungry and full of dogs. I don't look forward to ND either. It feels like FSU is best in the ACC and will be its rep in the playoff.
that's what i was thinking and what the referee explained(ish) but it definitely feels like one of those gray areas that will be reviewed & changed. maybe even in-season.All dead ball fouls are enforced after the completion of the previous down is counted. Late hits are dead ball by definition.
If it happens on 4th and the result of the play is not a 1st down, it is a turnover on downs prior to the enforcement of the penalty.
It's the kind of thing we see on rules tests all the time, but only actually see in person once or twice in your entire career.
Totally agree. Based on what transpired this weekend, Carolina pounds Clemson in Columbia this year. I base that mainly on the atmosphere and you know how emotion + momentum leads to the old snowball effect on the scoreboard.Carolina pretty much ended it's losing streak against Clemson last year with transfer portal guys. Dabo's NIL with God won't get it done long-term.And this is a point of contention among fans and the frustration with Dabo over the last couple of years. Time after time in other games when a great play is made we hear "transfer from <school> with an outstanding catch", etc. New rules allow a team to be overhauled (Colorado) or upgraded (ND with Harman, certainly FSU in skill positions).Dabo refusing to use the portal because it’s not in the Bible or whatever killed their potential dynasty. Thank God.
Dabo said he's open to the portal but he seems to think he doesn't have holes to fill, which makes it worse as it shows his blindness and/or incompetence. The Oline has been shotty for years and he has no WR that can separate. No playmakers at wideout since Higgins and Ross left. Everyone sees it but him.
It was a nice run but Clemson's inability to read the room and adapt to the changing competitive climate is going to lead them back to annual visits to the Belk bowls of mid-December.
I shutter to think what FSU is going to do to them in a few weeks. That team is hungry and full of dogs. I don't look forward to ND either. It feels like FSU is best in the ACC and will be its rep in the playoff.
After Saturday night I didn't think we could compete with Clemson this year but now it has the makings of a good game. The battle of the terrible O-Lines.
Agree it seems they need to rethink that one is it certainly looks like it's a continuation of the play. And it basically rewards the offending defense for taking a shot at the QB (or whoever has the ball).that's what i was thinking and what the referee explained(ish) but it definitely feels like one of those gray areas that will be reviewed & changed. maybe even in-season.All dead ball fouls are enforced after the completion of the previous down is counted. Late hits are dead ball by definition.
If it happens on 4th and the result of the play is not a 1st down, it is a turnover on downs prior to the enforcement of the penalty.
It's the kind of thing we see on rules tests all the time, but only actually see in person once or twice in your entire career.
NCAA rules committee really only operates on a 2-year cycle. I can't ever remember a rule CHANGE happening mid-season. They have done updated rule "interpretations" mid-season before where they tweak how or what they want us to call or not call, but an actual rule change (which this would require) won't happen until next season at the earliest.that's what i was thinking and what the referee explained(ish) but it definitely feels like one of those gray areas that will be reviewed & changed. maybe even in-season.All dead ball fouls are enforced after the completion of the previous down is counted. Late hits are dead ball by definition.
If it happens on 4th and the result of the play is not a 1st down, it is a turnover on downs prior to the enforcement of the penalty.
It's the kind of thing we see on rules tests all the time, but only actually see in person once or twice in your entire career.
The rule is the rule but it just doesn't seem right and I'm probably the biggest Clemson hater on these boards.NCAA rules committee really only operates on a 2-year cycle. I can't ever remember a rule CHANGE happening mid-season. They have done updated rule "interpretations" mid-season before where they tweak how or what they want us to call or not call, but an actual rule change (which this would require) won't happen until next season at the earliest.that's what i was thinking and what the referee explained(ish) but it definitely feels like one of those gray areas that will be reviewed & changed. maybe even in-season.All dead ball fouls are enforced after the completion of the previous down is counted. Late hits are dead ball by definition.
If it happens on 4th and the result of the play is not a 1st down, it is a turnover on downs prior to the enforcement of the penalty.
It's the kind of thing we see on rules tests all the time, but only actually see in person once or twice in your entire career.
This rule has been in place for as long as I've been officiating (15 years) and probably for decades prior.
Opens a can of worms.This rule has been in place for as long as I've been officiating (15 years) and probably for decades prior
I could see them making a change similar to the way they have allowed for fumbles to count after replay as long as there was "immediate clear recovery in the continuing action". The old rule was that after the whistle had blown and the play was over, nothing else could be considered after that and they made that change.Opens a can of worms.This rule has been in place for as long as I've been officiating (15 years) and probably for decades prior
What if a team gets stopped on 4th down. A defensive coach runs on the field and celebrates with the players. Maybe he taunted someone.
That's a dead ball foul. 15 yards after the turnover. You wanna go back and give the offense the ball?
The late hit didn't prevent them from getting the first down. So they get the 15 yards, but after play was over.
Can't be changing rules for fan bloodlust
I went to the game last night and 7-5 would be a good season for what I saw last night. It reminded me of watching these Geoff Collins Georgia Tech teams where it was a struggle to do anything right. Duke dominated them in the trenches. FSU is going to murder ClemsonClemson has Florida State, at Miami, NCSU, Notre Dame, UNC, at South Carolina still this year. Very easily could be staring at a 7-5 season and their rightful return to a December 27th bowl game.
I went to the game last night and 7-5 would be a good season for what I saw last night. It reminded me of watching these Geoff Collins Georgia Tech teams where it was a struggle to do anything right. Duke dominated them in the trenches. FSU is going to murder ClemsonClemson has Florida State, at Miami, NCSU, Notre Dame, UNC, at South Carolina still this year. Very easily could be staring at a 7-5 season and their rightful return to a December 27th bowl game.
Back to Climpsoning it appears.
All dead ball fouls are enforced after the completion of the previous down is counted. Late hits are dead ball by definition.
If it happens on 4th and the result of the play is not a 1st down, it is a turnover on downs prior to the enforcement of the penalty.
It's the kind of thing we see on rules tests all the time, but only actually see in person once or twice in your entire career.
"updated interpretation" would be a rule changeNCAA rules committee really only operates on a 2-year cycle. I can't ever remember a rule CHANGE happening mid-season. They have done updated rule "interpretations" mid-season before where they tweak how or what they want us to call or not call, but an actual rule change (which this would require) won't happen until next season at the earliest.that's what i was thinking and what the referee explained(ish) but it definitely feels like one of those gray areas that will be reviewed & changed. maybe even in-season.All dead ball fouls are enforced after the completion of the previous down is counted. Late hits are dead ball by definition.
If it happens on 4th and the result of the play is not a 1st down, it is a turnover on downs prior to the enforcement of the penalty.
It's the kind of thing we see on rules tests all the time, but only actually see in person once or twice in your entire career.
This rule has been in place for as long as I've been officiating (15 years) and probably for decades prior.
jesus definitely would not do this to DaboClemson has Florida State, at Miami, NCSU, Notre Dame, UNC, at South Carolina still this year. Very easily could be staring at a 7-5 season and their rightful return to a December 27th bowl game.
Next possession:
4 14:25 1 10 LAR 45 27 13 Tom Brady pass complete short middle to Rob Gronkowski for 13 yards (tackle by Nick Scott) 4 13:48 1 10 LAR 32 27 13 Tom Brady pass complete short right to Leonard Fournette for 5 yards (tackle by Leonard Floyd) 4 13:16 2 5 LAR 27 27 13 Tom Brady pass incomplete deep right intended for Rob Gronkowski (defended by Nick Scott) 4 13:11 3 5 LAR 27 27 13 Tom Brady sacked by Leonard Floyd for -9 yards 4 12:28 4 14 LAR 36 27 13 Tom Brady pass incomplete deep left intended for Mike Evans (defended by Jalen Ramsey)
4 | 12:22 | 1 | 10 | LAR 36 | 27 | 13 | Penalty on Eric Weddle: Unnecessary Roughness / Defense, 14 yards (accepted) (no play) | ||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
4 | 12:22 | 1 | 10 | LAR 22 | 27 | 13 | Cam Akers right guard for 3 yards (tackle by Jordan Whitehead) | ||
4 | 11:39 | 2 | 7 | LAR 25 | 27 | 13 | Van Jefferson left end for 15 yards (tackle by Antoine Winfield) |
Top 4 stay put the entire year now.AP Poll update...both Bama and FSU jump Ohio State...UTenn and ND jump into the Top 10...and UNC jumps 4 spots to 17. LSU (5 to 14) and Clemson (9 to 25) obviously biggest drops.
Both coaching staffs have a lot to work on. Clemson was pretty unlucky last night and made a lot of mistakes while Carolina had an awful OL performance that they didn’t make any adjustments to deal with.Totally agree. Based on what transpired this weekend, Carolina pounds Clemson in Columbia this year. I base that mainly on the atmosphere and you know how emotion + momentum leads to the old snowball effect on the scoreboard.Carolina pretty much ended it's losing streak against Clemson last year with transfer portal guys. Dabo's NIL with God won't get it done long-term.And this is a point of contention among fans and the frustration with Dabo over the last couple of years. Time after time in other games when a great play is made we hear "transfer from <school> with an outstanding catch", etc. New rules allow a team to be overhauled (Colorado) or upgraded (ND with Harman, certainly FSU in skill positions).Dabo refusing to use the portal because it’s not in the Bible or whatever killed their potential dynasty. Thank God.
Dabo said he's open to the portal but he seems to think he doesn't have holes to fill, which makes it worse as it shows his blindness and/or incompetence. The Oline has been shotty for years and he has no WR that can separate. No playmakers at wideout since Higgins and Ross left. Everyone sees it but him.
It was a nice run but Clemson's inability to read the room and adapt to the changing competitive climate is going to lead them back to annual visits to the Belk bowls of mid-December.
I shutter to think what FSU is going to do to them in a few weeks. That team is hungry and full of dogs. I don't look forward to ND either. It feels like FSU is best in the ACC and will be its rep in the playoff.
After Saturday night I didn't think we could compete with Clemson this year but now it has the makings of a good game. The battle of the terrible O-Lines.
Top 4 stay put the entire year now.AP Poll update...both Bama and FSU jump Ohio State...UTenn and ND jump into the Top 10...and UNC jumps 4 spots to 17. LSU (5 to 14) and Clemson (9 to 25) obviously biggest drops.
So what was the "no fake QB sliding" thing with Pickett a couple of years back?NCAA rules committee really only operates on a 2-year cycle. I can't ever remember a rule CHANGE happening mid-season. They have done updated rule "interpretations" mid-season before where they tweak how or what they want us to call or not call, but an actual rule change (which this would require) won't happen until next season at the earliest.that's what i was thinking and what the referee explained(ish) but it definitely feels like one of those gray areas that will be reviewed & changed. maybe even in-season.All dead ball fouls are enforced after the completion of the previous down is counted. Late hits are dead ball by definition.
If it happens on 4th and the result of the play is not a 1st down, it is a turnover on downs prior to the enforcement of the penalty.
It's the kind of thing we see on rules tests all the time, but only actually see in person once or twice in your entire career.
This rule has been in place for as long as I've been officiating (15 years) and probably for decades prior.
They issued an interpretation (not a new rule) that a fake slide is the beginning of a slide and thus the play is over/runner is down there. It basically said that the runner doesn't have to actually complete the slide, just start it since the sliding runner rule puts them down at the start of the slide.So what was the "no fake QB sliding" thing with Pickett a couple of years back?NCAA rules committee really only operates on a 2-year cycle. I can't ever remember a rule CHANGE happening mid-season. They have done updated rule "interpretations" mid-season before where they tweak how or what they want us to call or not call, but an actual rule change (which this would require) won't happen until next season at the earliest.that's what i was thinking and what the referee explained(ish) but it definitely feels like one of those gray areas that will be reviewed & changed. maybe even in-season.All dead ball fouls are enforced after the completion of the previous down is counted. Late hits are dead ball by definition.
If it happens on 4th and the result of the play is not a 1st down, it is a turnover on downs prior to the enforcement of the penalty.
It's the kind of thing we see on rules tests all the time, but only actually see in person once or twice in your entire career.
This rule has been in place for as long as I've been officiating (15 years) and probably for decades prior.
It has been this way for at least 23 years (my start of officiating)NCAA rules committee really only operates on a 2-year cycle. I can't ever remember a rule CHANGE happening mid-season. They have done updated rule "interpretations" mid-season before where they tweak how or what they want us to call or not call, but an actual rule change (which this would require) won't happen until next season at the earliest.that's what i was thinking and what the referee explained(ish) but it definitely feels like one of those gray areas that will be reviewed & changed. maybe even in-season.All dead ball fouls are enforced after the completion of the previous down is counted. Late hits are dead ball by definition.
If it happens on 4th and the result of the play is not a 1st down, it is a turnover on downs prior to the enforcement of the penalty.
It's the kind of thing we see on rules tests all the time, but only actually see in person once or twice in your entire career.
This rule has been in place for as long as I've been officiating (15 years) and probably for decades prior.
Probably one of the most asked rules questions, especially for newer officials.All dead ball fouls are enforced after the completion of the previous down is counted. Late hits are dead ball by definition.
If it happens on 4th and the result of the play is not a 1st down, it is a turnover on downs prior to the enforcement of the penalty.
It's the kind of thing we see on rules tests all the time, but only actually see in person once or twice in your entire career.
that's what i was thinking and what the referee explained(ish) but it definitely feels like one of those gray areas that will be reviewed & changed. maybe even in-season.All dead ball fouls are enforced after the completion of the previous down is counted. Late hits are dead ball by definition.
If it happens on 4th and the result of the play is not a 1st down, it is a turnover on downs prior to the enforcement of the penalty.
It's the kind of thing we see on rules tests all the time, but only actually see in person once or twice in your entire career.
Latest NCAAF, News, Rumors, and Articles by OutKick
Fearless, authentic, and wokeless reporting from Clay Travis and OutKick Contributors. Sign up to the Daily OutKick to never miss a beat.www.outkick.com
Loser programLatest NCAAF, News, Rumors, and Articles by OutKick
Fearless, authentic, and wokeless reporting from Clay Travis and OutKick Contributors. Sign up to the Daily OutKick to never miss a beat.www.outkick.com
Luther Campbell ain’t walking through that door.Latest NCAAF, News, Rumors, and Articles by OutKick
Fearless, authentic, and wokeless reporting from Clay Travis and OutKick Contributors. Sign up to the Daily OutKick to never miss a beat.www.outkick.com
Do they normally sell games out? I don't think of Miami as having a large local fanbase
It would help some if they built a stadium 30 min south near the old OB by the Marlins…Luther Campbell ain’t walking through that door.Latest NCAAF, News, Rumors, and Articles by OutKick
Fearless, authentic, and wokeless reporting from Clay Travis and OutKick Contributors. Sign up to the Daily OutKick to never miss a beat.www.outkick.com
Do they normally sell games out? I don't think of Miami as having a large local fanbase
Texas - Bama??People I work with in Iowa are all about this weekend. I'm not sure I could care less about this weekend's lineup though.
People I work with in Iowa are all about this weekend. I'm not sure I could care less about this weekend's lineup though.
Texas - Bama??People I work with in Iowa are all about this weekend. I'm not sure I could care less about this weekend's lineup though.
Deion - Nebraska could be fun. Dumbo going against Miami has a lot of stakes.
Anybody else a bit surprised that Colorado is only favored by 2.5 over Nebraska? The Huskers just lost to a Gopher team that literally can not run the ball. I figured they would be double-digit dogs in this one, but I guess not?
Lot of good games.Texas - Bama??People I work with in Iowa are all about this weekend. I'm not sure I could care less about this weekend's lineup though.
Deion - Nebraska could be fun. Dumbo going against Miami has a lot of stakes.
I mean......Oregon at Texas Tech isn't terrible. It's passable, okay?