Skinny Luka is scary. He’s way more active and engaged on both sides of the court. When he was heavy, you would see him dominate maybe for one quar
I disagree with the George trade. No one thought that was an horrific trade when it happened, in hindsight it is worse. The Luka trade was laughed at it from start.
If we are using hindsight we can probably find a lot of really bad trades and we won't know where to rank the Luka trade for a decade.
Yeah, using this standard, I don't remember any deal being ridiculed from the start as much as this one.
The Rudy Gobert trade was LARGELY touted as being the worst trade of all time by Minnesota. People thought that Ainge was a genius and that the haul and assets that he got in return were all but a guarantee that Utah would be a juggernaut in the future. While some might try to claim that Gobert isn’t great—the fact of the matter is that his acquisition played a role in rising them from being an unremarkable team to being relevant. Utah basically did the opposite—they went from being a relevant team to being in purgatory.
The Anthony Davis trade was hugely scrutinized at the time. People called Lebron -LeGM and trading away assets like Ingram, Hart, Lonzo and 3 first round picks for Anthony Davis was very criticized. The Lakers ended up winning a ring because of that trade (albeit in the bubble—but I personally do not hold that against them—you have to play the games in front of you). Taking that a step further—Davis ends up getting traded for Luka .
I think you have to use a little hindsight when evaluating trades because the concept is that the teams (GM”s) are supposed to use foresight when they make deals. That is what their job is. How much foresight was used when Ishbia and the Suns made a splash and immediately traded for Kevin Durant and blew their budget on Bradley Beal? I think removing hindsight from trades paints a very incomplete picture.
With Luka for Anthony Davis—at this moment in time—the Lakers seem to be on the right side. However—as another posted said—the Cooper Flagg dynamic seems to be a little too coincidental to be random imo—and that may have played a part. Also, let’s not overlook that “skinny Luka” was not happening in Dallas over the last few years. They also had a healthy Kyrie Irving when the trade was made. One could argue that the Mavs would have a better chance with Kyrie, Anthony Davis, Cooper Flagg, PJ washington, Klay then they would with Luka and Kyrie with no Flagg.