BobbyLayne
Footballguy
Distilling a 53-man Detroit Lions roster for the first quarter of the 21st century
Allen Park — Believe it or not, we've experienced 25 seasons of Detroit Lions football since the turn of the century.
Admittedly, most of it hasn't been good. Anchored by one of the few winless seasons in NFL history in 2008, the team has won less than 40% of its games during that stretch, with only five postseason appearances.
The good news? Things have been trending up as of late. The team broke a three-decade skid without a division title, winning the NFC North the past two seasons. That earned the Lions their first home playoff game in Ford Field’s history and their first playoff victory since 1991. The team followed that up with a franchise-best 15-win campaign last season, although they couldn't replicate the previous year's postseason magic.
There's obviously plenty to reflect on at the quarter-century mark. However, we decided to put a different spin on the topic, producing a 53-man roster based on the performances of players who have worn the Honolulu blue since 2000.
Enjoy.
Quarterback (2)
In: Matthew Stafford, Jared GoffFirst man out: Jon Kitna
Thoughts: There’s no need to shoehorn Kitna, Daunte Culpepper or Joey Harrington onto this roster. Stafford and Goff are more than enough.
Between them, they hold almost every meaningful single-season and career passing record in franchise history. Stafford tops the list when it comes to the majority of the counting stats, buoyed by his 5,000-yard, 41-touchdown season in 2011, while Goff reset the bar for efficiency by completing 72.4% of his passes and posting a 111.8 passer rating in 2024.
Who would be the starter between the two? I’ll leave it for you to debate. Stafford had more arm talent and racked up the fourth-quarter comebacks. Goff, meanwhile, is more efficient and has been the more consistent winner, including division titles and postseason victories that eluded his predecessor.
Running back (4)
Jahmyr Gibbs, David Montgomery, James Stewart, Theo RiddickFirst man out: Kevin Jones
Thoughts: In just two seasons each, Gibbs and Montgomery’s spots are secure. They’re No. 1 and No. 2 in rushing touchdowns for the Lions over the past 25 years. Additionally, Gibbs has averaged 5.5 yards per carry and racked up nearly 3,200 yards from scrimmage. Montgomery’s 4.4 yards per carry and 2,248 yards from scrimmage are also beyond respectable, given the timeshare.
Stewart gets the nod after admirably stepping into the void created by Barry Sanders’ abrupt retirement ahead of the 1999 season. Stewart battled some injuries during the final three seasons of his career. Still, he produced a pair of 1,000-yard campaigns, chipped in 101 receptions and found the end zone 19 times for Detroit.
There were several contenders for the fourth spot. D’Andre Swift had the most talent, but durability limited his production. He peaked at 617 rushing yards and 1,069 yards from scrimmage.
Jones’ 761 rushing attempts remain the most for a Detroit running back since the turn of the century. Regardless, he didn’t come close to topping 1,000 yards after his rookie season.
Finally, Joique Bell’s rise to prominence as a Michigan native and former Wayne State standout was a wonderful story to cover. He spent parts of five seasons with the Lions, grinding out 2,235 yards and 22 touchdowns on the ground.
Nevertheless, we went with Riddick because of his expertise as a pass catcher, his effectiveness as a blocker, and his stellar contributions on special teams. Never particularly useful between the tackles, Riddick’s angle route was an unstoppable weapon for the Lions. His 80 catches in 2015 are the most in a season for a running back in franchise history, and his 285 receptions rank sixth among all Lions players since 2000.
Wide receiver (6)
Calvin Johnson, Amon-Ra St. Brown, Golden Tate, Marvin Jones, Roy Williams, Kalif RaymondFirst man out: Kenny Golladay
Thoughts: The first five names on this list are no-brainers.
Johnson is one of the greatest receivers ever to play the game. St. Brown is well on his way to setting the franchise record for receptions. And Tate, Jones and Williams are third, fourth and fifth in receptions over the past 25 years, with a sizeable lead over Nate Burleson, who is next on the list.
Burleson, the consummate locker room guy and future media star, had a decent case for the sixth spot. Mike Furrey had one great season, Golladay two, and if we check back in two years, Jameson Williams could be the easy answer. Yet we’re going with Raymond.
Raymond’s 147 receptions and seven touchdowns across four seasons aren’t particularly impressive relative to the other options. However, his contributions as a return man make him the right choice. He’s averaged better than 30 yards on kickoffs and 12.4 yards fielding punts during his time with the Lions, earning second-team All-Pro honors twice for those contributions.
Tight end (3)
Sam LaPorta, T.J. Hockenson, Brandon PettigrewFirst man out: Eric Ebron
Thoughts: There shouldn’t be too much to debate here. LaPorta rewrote the franchise’s record books as a rookie, and he’s just getting started.
Meanwhile, Hockenson and Pettigrew did an admirable job living up to the lofty standards attached to being selected in the first round. Pettigrew’s 301 receptions rank behind only Johnson, St. Brown and Tate since 2000. And Hockenson’s career was off to a strong start, with 128 combined catches in his second and third seasons, before he was shipped to Minnesota at the trade deadline in the middle of his fourth year.
Hockenson edged out Ebron, another former top-10 pick. The two had nearly identical stat lines during their time with the Lions, but Ebron’s issues with drops were the difference.
We also considered highlighting David Sloan, a block-first tight end. The disqualifier was that his best seasons came before 2000, including a 1999 Pro Bowl selection.
Offensive line (10)
Taylor Decker, Penei Sewell, Jeff Backus, Riley Reiff, Frank Ragnow, Dominic Raiola, Rob Sims, Larry Warford, Jonah Jackson, Graham GlasgowFirst man out: Gosder Cherilus
Thoughts: Detroit has had some excellent offensive linemen over the years, even if some weren’t fully appreciated during their careers.
With multiple All-Pro selections apiece, Sewell and Ragnow were some of the easiest names to put on this roster. The rest of the group is set-it-and-forget-it starters.
Backus started 191 of 192 games during his 12-year career. Reiff took over the blindside duties after Backus’ retirement but also offered the flexibility to play on the right side, starting his career there and shifting back when the Lions drafted Decker in 2016. All three were durable and performed above average as pass protectors and run blockers.
On the inside, Sims stabilized the left guard spot for years after coming over in a trade from Seattle. Warford and Jackson, both third-round picks, were stellar in pass protection. Warford, who went on to earn three consecutive Pro Bowl selections for New Orleans, was also a damn fine run blocker.
Glasgow’s versatility has been so valuable during his two stints with the Lions. He’s had above-average stretches at three different spots in the lineup. And while he arguably makes a third center unnecessary, Raiola’s had an underrated 14-year career that included some of his best work in his later years.