2025 Offseason Rankings and such (1 Viewer)

[lsutigers]

I'm still working to update mine and haven't even started into the UFA signings - https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1gwgzC1aaIaxiXbL_LDSK8b1yVzQo3Fbogm8RuEzMP3w

Teams that appear to have addressed a need early with either high capital or a highly regarded prospect:
Atlanta (Edge) with Walker & Pierce
Baltimore (Edge) with Green
Carolina (Edge) with Scourton & Umanmielen
Cincy (Edge) with Stewart
Dallas (Edge) with Ezeiruaku
SF (Edge) with Williams

Buffalo (IDL) with Sanders)
KC (IDL) with Normal-Lott
Miami (IDL) with Grant
NYG (IDL) with Alexander
Pitt (IDL) with Harmon
SF (IDL) with Collins

Cincy (LB) with Knight & Carter
LAR (LB) with Paul
SF (LB) with Martin

Atlanta (S) with Watts
Baltimore (S) with Starks
Seattle (S) with Emmanwori

Some guys I think that got higher capital than projected and gain some value are Hassanein (Edge) to Detroit, Oladejo (Edge) to Tenn, Lindenberg (LB) to LV, and Trader (Safety) to Miami.

Some teams that look like they failed to address needs and to watch for UFA landings are Edge for Washington, IDL for Atlanta, Jax and NYJ, LB's in Indy and Tenn, and Safeties in Cleveland, Minn, NYJ, TB and Wash.

 

[The Future Champs]

I'm still working to update mine and haven't even started into the UFA signings - https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1gwgzC1aaIaxiXbL_LDSK8b1yVzQo3Fbogm8RuEzMP3w

Teams that appear to have addressed a need early with either high capital or a highly regarded prospect:
Atlanta (Edge) with Walker & Pierce
Baltimore (Edge) with Green
Carolina (Edge) with Scourton & Umanmielen
Cincy (Edge) with Stewart
Dallas (Edge) with Ezeiruaku
SF (Edge) with Williams

Buffalo (IDL) with Sanders)
KC (IDL) with Normal-Lott
Miami (IDL) with Grant
NYG (IDL) with Alexander
Pitt (IDL) with Harmon
SF (IDL) with Collins

Cincy (LB) with Knight & Carter
LAR (LB) with Paul
SF (LB) with Martin

Atlanta (S) with Watts
Baltimore (S) with Starks
Seattle (S) with Emmanwori

Some guys I think that got higher capital than projected and gain some value are Hassanein (Edge) to Detroit, Oladejo (Edge) to Tenn, Lindenberg (LB) to LV, and Trader (Safety) to Miami.

Some teams that look like they failed to address needs and to watch for UFA landings are Edge for Washington, IDL for Atlanta, Jax and NYJ, LB's in Indy and Tenn, and Safeties in Cleveland, Minn, NYJ, TB and Wash.

Schwesinger tops my list if he gets any buzz as a green dot and/or MLB.

 

[Tick]

Jason King at DLF had a good writeup.

2025 NFL Draft: Dynasty IDP Day Three Review - Dynasty League Football

We examine all of the dynasty-relevant day three defensive draft picks.

dynastyleaguefootball.com

 

[MAC_32]

Schwesinger tops my list if he gets any buzz as a green dot and/or MLB.

I'll be surprised if he's not a 90+%er week 1 and have the green dot by the bye.

 

[Tick]

Schwesinger tops my list if he gets any buzz as a green dot and/or MLB.

I'll be surprised if he's not a 90+%er week 1 and have the green dot by the bye.

We're probably all gun shy after the recent rookie seasons from Lloyd, Campbell, and Cooper. It seems to be a stash position now.

 

[Tick]

Sources: 49ers' Mustapha may miss season's start

San Francisco 49ers safety Malik Mustapha is recovering from an injury to the anterior cruciate ligament in his right knee and likely won't be ready for the start of the season.

www.espn.com

Sources: Ex-49ers LB Greenlaw to miss time with serious quad injury

Former San Francisco 49ers linebacker Dre Greenlaw, now a member of the Denver Broncos, recently sustained a serious leg injury, multiple sources told NBC Sports Bay Area.

www.nbcsportsbayarea.com

A couple of notes from Gregg Rosenthal that I hadn't heard about.

 

[MAC_32]

Schwesinger tops my list if he gets any buzz as a green dot and/or MLB.

I'll be surprised if he's not a 90+%er week 1 and have the green dot by the bye.

We're probably all gun shy after the recent rookie seasons from Lloyd, Campbell, and Cooper. It seems to be a stash position now.

Well, if JOK's injury is career threatening, then I wouldn't let recency bias sway me. The risk is if he really is fine and the Browns have been aggressively spending on LB's despite that. It's not even May, but that's a risk I'm willing to take.

 

[Tick]

Schwesinger tops my list if he gets any buzz as a green dot and/or MLB.

I'll be surprised if he's not a 90+%er week 1 and have the green dot by the bye.

We're probably all gun shy after the recent rookie seasons from Lloyd, Campbell, and Cooper. It seems to be a stash position now.

Well, if JOK's injury is career threatening, then I wouldn't let recency bias sway me. The risk is if he really is fine and the Browns have been aggressively spending on LB's despite that. It's not even May, but that's a risk I'm willing to take.

I guess I'm saying that even if he's LB1 for me, that might fall lower in my rookie rankings than it did 5 years ago.

 

[Tick]

Gary Davenport (@garydavenport.bsky.social)

Just an FYI, but I'll be hitting the full list of rookie IDPs at My Fantasy League over the next couple of days. Two early switches that stood out to me... I'll recommend that Jalon Walker be classified a DE, and that Sai'vion Jones flips to DT. #FFIDP...

bsky.app

Looks like DE for Jalon Walker at MFL.

 

[MAC_32]

I guess I'm saying that even if he's LB1 for me, that might fall lower in my rookie rankings than it did 5 years ago.

That's what I mean by recency bias.

 

[KellysHeroes]

Gary Davenport (@garydavenport.bsky.social)

Just an FYI, but I'll be hitting the full list of rookie IDPs at My Fantasy League over the next couple of days. Two early switches that stood out to me... I'll recommend that Jalon Walker be classified a DE, and that Sai'vion Jones flips to DT. #FFIDP...

bsky.app

Looks like DE for Jalon Walker at MFL.

If he DE this could be like the Mack days when he was getting LB2 numbers from your DE position... the problem was every yr MFL just couldn't make up its mind

 

[KellysHeroes]

Schwesinger tops my list if he gets any buzz as a green dot and/or MLB.

I'll be surprised if he's not a 90+%er week 1 and have the green dot by the bye.

We're probably all gun shy after the recent rookie seasons from Lloyd, Campbell, and Cooper. It seems to be a stash position now.

is it because LB is a harder position to learn now ala like TE? or has the talent just not been there?

 

[MAC_32]

is it because LB is a harder position to learn now ala like TE? or has the talent just not been there?

Broad-brushing, neck-up > skill

 

[The Future Champs]

Schwesinger tops my list if he gets any buzz as a green dot and/or MLB.

I'll be surprised if he's not a 90+%er week 1 and have the green dot by the bye.

We're probably all gun shy after the recent rookie seasons from Lloyd, Campbell, and Cooper. It seems to be a stash position now.

Given the value of green dot LBs in my main league (start 3-4 lbs, 3 pts per solo tackle) I’m prepared to draft high and stash.

 

[Tick]

Bloom’s post draft top 100 is up. Macri has top 50 IDP rookies up at PFF but it’s behind a paywall. IDP+ has a top 101 rookie pick video.

NFL Dynasty Draft 2025: Offense & IDP Top 101 Ranked Rookies! - IDP+

:https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=aOd_TDhc3Ek It's 2025 NFL Fantasy Football Dynasty Draft season, and building a championship roster means dominating both

idpplus.com

The Post-Draft Bloom 100

Sigmund Bloom runs down the top 100 rookies in deep IDP leagues after the NFL Draft

www.footballguys.com

 

[Tick]

PFF combined board video: https://youtu.be/TOtXB1zBFeY?si=nEJl7j9DLMLGFL9m

 

[Tick]

Norton released IDP rookie rankings.

ETA: Maybe don't lean on them too hard right now - missing both Jalon Walker and Malaki Starks in the top 56, seems like they might be a work in progress.

 

[KellysHeroes]

Norton released IDP rookie rankings.

ETA: Maybe don't lean on them too hard right now - missing both Jalon Walker and Malaki Starks in the top 56, seems like they might be a work in progress.

they look good now!
you guys have Knight Jr rank #2 LB, is the expectation he takes over immediately from Pratt?

 

[Tick]

Norton released IDP rookie rankings.

ETA: Maybe don't lean on them too hard right now - missing both Jalon Walker and Malaki Starks in the top 56, seems like they might be a work in progress.

they look good now!
you guys have Knight Jr rank #2 LB, is the expectation he takes over immediately from Pratt?

I think most are assuming that based on how bad the Bengals defense was, Pratt requesting a trade, and Knight’s draft slot.

 

[KellysHeroes]

Lloyd not getting his 5th yr option is crazy

 

[Crippler]

Having a real tough time looking at rankings

When I look ar my league, DL needs are minimal with having 100 plus available and teams starting 48. Whereas team need at LB is bleak. Despite only 64 worthwhile ones at most and 50 wanted to be started each week. DB has 120 starters and 67 started.
Add in high unit last year DL 600( started 4-3-4) LB 1083(started 3-4-4) DB 1028(started 3-2-6)

So I have rankings as
1. Carson Schwesinger
2. Jihaad Campbell
3. Demetrius Knight
4. Abdul Carter
5. Nick Martin
6. Nick Emmanwori
7. Jalon Walker
8. Teddy Buchanon
9. James Pearce
10. Danny Stutsman
11. Chris Paul
12. Malachi Starks
13. Mykeal Williams
14. Shemar Stewart
15. Mike Green
16. Donovan Ezeiruaku
17. Nick Scourton
18. Mason Graham
19. JT Tuimoleau
20. Cody Simons
21. Kevin Winston
22. Andrew Mukuba
23. Jeffrey Bassa
24. Femi Oladejo
25. Prince Ummanmeilen
26. Xavier Watts
27. Jahdae Barron
28. Barrett Carter
29. Walter Nolan
30. Landon Jackson

10 LB-14 DL-6 DB but I like all DL

Feels weak overall in the end

And when you add O
Expect 3 LBs go 2nd. No clue on Abdul. I thought mid 3rd but looking at drafts/rankings probably mid 2nd but not sure how much better than others way later but name and rankings.

 

[KellysHeroes]

A Carter over Walker? won't Walker get more tackle opps?

 

[Crippler]

A Carter over Walker? won't Walker get more tackle opps?

Does Walker not have huge bust potential at that size. Seen it many times where these smaller pass rushers get beaten up in NFL. But why grabbing Carter not a necessity as DL is strength of this draft far and away. LB is weakest.