Why wouldn't you want to face him? In the 13 seasons before this year, he's 8-9 in the playoffs, including 1-4 in AFC championship games.
I would think he's almost exactly who you WOULD want to face in the AFC championship (almost as good as facing Marv Levy or Bud Grant or Dan Reeves in the Super Bowl).
Sure, if your team is QBed by someone like Elway or Brady and Cowher is going to throw Stewart or a worn-out rookie out there. This is the first time in ANY of his AFCC appearances that his team will be led by a QB nearly as talented as Roethlisberger. It's also the first time since 1994, when Cowher was a very young head coach in his first AFCC, that the disparity between starting QBs is anything less than enormous.
So you are blaming Cowher's sub-par Title game record solely on his QB's? That's weak and "homerish".
Not entirely, no. To some degree, definitely. I think there are a lot of talent discrepancies that can be overcome. I think QB is the toughest one to hide and the one that can prove most costly in a big game. A few factors went into them losing each game, and QB was definitely one of them. Especially in 1997 and 2004. In 1994, he lost a game he should've won.
In 1997, the Steelers lost by only 3 to Elway and the Broncos when Kordell threw 3 INTs (2 in the red zone) and fumbled once. You can be the judge as to whether his 4 TO's might have had an impact on the game.
In 2001, the Steelers were beaten almost exclusively because of 2 special teams TDs given up. One was a blocked field goal, and one was a punt that Cowher ordered to be kicked out of bounds... Josh Miller screwed it up, and Troy Brown scored.
In 2004, they just weren't as good as the Pats and Roethlisberger was completely worn out. They were home underdogs.