Whys that? I'm 50/50 on him. Just curious what the other side of the 50 is for others...
Here's something I read posted March of this year while still with KC -
"The problem with Wilson isn’t in what he can do, it’s in what he can’t do.
Wilson has always had and continues to have a limited catch radius. While he’ll occasionally make a good catch in which he has to stretch, it is not something you can count on him to do consistently at all. He is also pretty poor at tracking and adjusting to the ball down the field, an utterly crucial skill as a deep threat.
The combination of those two weaknesses negates a lot of what Wilson could be as a field-stretching fast guy. The reality is it’s tough to trust him down the field because he requires a very good throw in order to make the catch. The preference (at least for me) is a guy who can adjust to a ball that is off-target because the farther down the field you get, the less accurate the throws will be. The ability to adjust to and catch an inaccurate ball is what separates fast guys from legitimate deep threats (see Hill, Tyreek).
Additionally, while Wilson does demonstrate some quickness on certain routes, it’s on a limited tree. When he’s asked to perform more than a single cut, his footwork suffers and he doesn’t look nearly as quick in his routes. That’s a real problem, in that it limits what you can ask him to do.
If you watch Wilson next to Hill, it appears by my eyes that Hill is already the superior route-runner, and considering Hill is a second-year player not known for that skill... well, it’s worrisome.
Wilson’s limitations as a route-runner are largely hidden by the role he plays in Reid’s offense, and Reid’s ability to scheme players open."
"That’s where I land with Wilson: he’s a player who isn’t bad by any means and has some strengths (YAC, some speed on go routes, blocking, certain short routes), but he also has some pretty serious limitations (poor catch radius, doesn’t adjust well to the ball, lacks ability in most intermediate routes to change direction quickly) that prevent him from being more than what I’d call a “decent” player. He’s absolutely a guy you like having on your team... but based on what I’m seeing, you don’t want him to be more than your fourth option in the receiving game (which is where Reid had him before Conley got hurt, and arguably fifth behind Kareem Hunt)."