Andre Johnson (1 Viewer)

[SproutDaddy]

Curious as to opinions on his trade value. Who would you say is comparable amongst receivers as equal FF value?

 

[diesel7982]

Redraft vs Dynasty?

Scoring System?

Starting Requirements?

Probably a better question for the ACF

 

[MLBrandow]

I say keep him. His value isn't going to be lower than it is now after coming off of a 700 yard, 2TD campaign (but 119/TD in the Super Bowl).

Buy low, sell high

Buy high, sell low

 

[SproutDaddy]

Redraft vs Dynasty?

Scoring System?

Starting Requirements?

Probably a better question for the ACF

I believe this is the right forum. I'm not looking for advice here. I am just looking for a few opinions on where he ranks amongst other receivers. This is a simple question. Respond with the first thing that comes to mind.

 

[Baracuda]

Everything else being equal, I'd say AJ's value is closest to Roy Williams. I think he's in the 11-15 vicinity. Basically they both have tons of talent, but are risky because of past performance and questions with their offenses/injury histories.

 

[sib]

Everything else being equal, I'd say AJ's value is closest to Roy Williams. I think he's in the 11-15 vicinity. Basically they both have tons of talent, but are risky because of past performance and questions with their offenses/injury histories.

Agree.

 

[Rev]

Agree with the Roy comparisons. Those are 2 guys who could be in the top 5 for dynasty with a solid 2006 campaign. As an owner of both, that would sure be nice, because I'm kind of tired of pulling my hair out because of each.

 

[SproutDaddy]

Everything else being equal, I'd say AJ's value is closest to Roy Williams.  I think he's in the 11-15 vicinity.  Basically they both have tons of talent, but are risky because of past performance and questions with their offenses/injury histories.

Agree.

I was thinking the same. I own him and Moulds in a dynasty. After the trade I am looking to move one. Of course most have interest in AJ, but I was offered the likes of Drew Bennett and a mediocre DL and told it was a decent offer. I not looking to get Chad Johnson or Steve Smith for him(although I'd jump on it in a heartbeat), but I wanted to see if my ranking of him was too high. I see my ranking seems to be in line.