I'm sorry I don't care so much about bashing AJ that I didn't respond fast enough for some people's liking.
I stand by my list, however, and the production of those players through the first 1/4 of the season relative to AJ supports it. I would rather have guys who are actually putting the points up for my fantasy team than someone who is failing to do so for whatever the excuse of the day is despite having "top 10 talent" when in fact I have never seen him finish in the top 10.
This guy gets it:
Overacting? AJ has failed to live up to his ADP his entire career. He's always drafted as a top 10-12 WR, yet is never a top 10-12 WR.
Yes points per game this, bad QB that, injuries this, bad play calling that. It's his 6th year, he’s supposed to be one of the best 5-6 WRs in the NFL, and it’s time to show it. He disappears more then Casper.
I always rag on AJ. I just don't understand how he's always drafted as a top 10 WR, yet has never been a top 10 WR. After 5 years? I know, I know lots of semi-valid excuses. I just don't believe in drafting guys at a spot, that they've never achieved. It's just bad business. And AJ has more of less proved that 5 years in a row. Maybe I'll miss out on year 6 (he's currently ranked 48), but that also means I missed out on his first 5 underwhelming years. I'll take that.

another overhyped,overrated guy..
AJ is like a pair of Aces in Texas Hold-em...you can't get away from it, its a great hand. its 'the best' you can have..but chances are you'll either win a very small pot or get busted with these Aces, at least that's how the saying goes...( same thing with Big Slick a-k - the bust rate is enormous!)
AJ looks great on paper - size, speed, hands, etc..he's fooled enough people by his high draft pick status, his 103 catch season, his reputation of 'AJ led the NFL before he got hurt 2007 season'..
fact is the guy is an also-ran WR on a team that now has a legit, borderline Pro Bowl TE and a rising star in RB Steve Slaton.
Aj doesn't need to make 10+ catches per game anymore, there are other options on this team.
wait for a big game, and then trade him.