What's new
Fantasy Football - Footballguys Forums

This is a sample guest message. Register a free account today to become a member! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

Bands/Artists You Like, But Shouldn't (3 Viewers)

Wheatus
Mighty Casey
Dashboard Confessional


Basically overly emotional rock or angry/explicit rap doesn't really fit my public image but I love them both.
 
There is a lot of bad music in my library, but the worst combination of terrible artist and volume of songs is Puddle of Mudd. I should be more ashamed about that than I am.
 
Debbie Gibson
Paul Revere and the Raiders

If you can get past the corny Revolutionary War costumes and the media overexposure, they actually had a few pretty good songs:

"Kicks" was written by The Brill Building duo of Barry Mann and Cynthia Weil (and offered first to The Animals, who turned it down because Eric Burdon didn't like it).

"Indian Reservation" showed a social consciousness one wouldn't have expected from them.

"Steppin' Out" stands among the best garage rock songs that hit the top 50 and has a Count Five "Psychotic Reaction" vibe.

 
If you can get past the corny Revolutionary War costumes and the media overexposure, they actually had a few pretty good songs

What's corny about that?

JK. They were a lot better band than the average rock listener or critic gave them credit for. "The Great Airplane Strike" and other frat rockers like "Just Like Me" were good songs. They were compiled nicely on a double cassette/CD back in the nineties. If you can get a workable copy, there are tons of great songs on it. Lots of frat rock covers and the like.
 
The entire genre of screamo. Taking Back Sunday is patently embarrassing after their first album, but I still dig it.

I listened to some cringey pop-punk back in the day. That stuff was cutting edge? Well, it was for the sludgy nineties. Now it sounds dated, but I still dig it. It ushered in a sociopolitical outlook that paved the way for the naughties. I'll hold that as a truism until somebody proves me wrong. Sex had to start somewhere again. Look how #metoo killed it, which was an extension of another radical nineties Catherine MacKinnon/Andrea Dworkin philosophy.

Believe her.

How'd that work out for Matt Araiza?
 
Ambrosia, REO Speedwagon, & Creed :bag:

Local L.A. band, from San Pedro that no one should ever have to apologize for, for liking.

Their first Top 20 record (reached #17 IRRC) and would have been bigger but they were on 20th Century Fox, a label that was dying at the time and went under a few years later.

Ambrosia - Holding On To Yesterday (1974)

 
Not sure how to interpret this question.

I never feel ashamed for having a diverse and random set of music I like. During college, I had to DJ a station where we couldn't play any top 40 artists so that helped find a lot of weird stuff.

I think my answer is Kanye West. He's undoubtedly a musical genius, but has just become such a social pariah with his statements/mental health issues. Still, I threw on a playlist I have of his stuff for my ride home yesterday.

Apologies if that isn't the spirit of this thread.
 
I think my answer is Kanye West.

Kanye was under serious consideration for the MAD dummies 31 countdown, but I didn’t feel like doing a deep dive into him given what surrounds him these days. His self-aggrandizement, once played for laughs, becomes serious and sad given what we know.
 
I don’t think I buy into any kind of music being something one “shouldn’t like”.
These last few random music threads have been brutal - why are we concentrating on the negatives and bands we "shouldn't like" or ones we "should like but don't". Music should be about sharing things we do like and celebrating the talent instead of ****ting on bands others may love.
 
I don’t think I buy into any kind of music being something one “shouldn’t like”.
These last few random music threads have been brutal - why are we concentrating on the negatives and bands we "shouldn't like" or ones we "should like but don't". Music should be about sharing things we do like and celebrating the talent instead of ****ting on bands others may love.
You're right, but I am also highly confident no one loves Puddle of Mudd. God, they're so terrible. And because they're now fresh on my mind I'll probably listen to them on today's afternoon run.
 
In early days of Pandora, I thought it would be funny to start a Nickelback station, but ban every Nickelback song. Would end up listening to a lot of Dad/Butt Rock and some I still listen to on purpose still today. Halestorm and Stone Sour probably top the list. I've traveled to see both bands.
 
Gwar - I have no shame.
Early early Madonna - I have a little shame.

Actually I have none, loved her early work.

In fact, I bought her first single "Everybody" when it was available only in the 12" format (heard it at a dance club I frequented).

And I remember at the time reading that her record label, Sire, thought she could be a major star if they find the right video for her.
 
There is a lot of bad music in my library, but the worst combination of terrible artist and volume of songs is Puddle of Mudd. I should be more ashamed about that than I am.
:lol: I went and saw them at a venue in tiny Big Bear Lake City, CA a couple of years ago.
 
New Order

I was always a "classic rock" guy at heart (still am), and I typically do not care for electronic dance/club style music. However their song Bizarre Love Triangle hit big in my early college years and I enjoyed it. I had a couple friends through college that would listen to New Order regularly, and I became familiar with a couple other songs. I actually purchased their compilation album, Substance, somewhere along the way and discovered several more catchy songs. I suppose it isn't coincidence that this was also during my peak mind altering years. Although I don't seek out their material routinely these days, I still enjoy listening to the Substance material from time to time when the mood hits me.

ETA...I suppose I could mention Big Audio Dynamite in much the same way. Although BAD could also be considered "dance" music, it was really a rather unique fusion of several genres that I found to be interesting. I like BAD even more than New Order.
 
Last edited:
New Order

I was always a "classic rock" guy at heart (still am), and I typically do not care for electronic dance/club style music. However their song Bizarre Love Triangle hit big in my early college years and I enjoyed it. I had a couple friends through college that would listen to New Order regularly, and I became familiar with a couple other songs. I actually purchased their compilation album, Substance, somewhere along the way and discovered several more catchy songs. I suppose it isn't coincidence that this was also during my peak mind altering years. Although I don't seek out their material routinely these days, I still enjoy listening to the Substance material from time to time when the mood hits me.

ETA...I suppose I could mention Big Audio Dynamite in much the same way. Although BAD could also be considered "dance" music, it was really a rather unique fusion of several genres that I found to be unique and interesting. I like BAD even more than New Order.
When The Clash broke up, the two main contributors produced some great music. Mick Jones with BAD and Joe Strummer with bands like The Mescaleros.
 
I don’t think I buy into any kind of music being something one “shouldn’t like”.
These last few random music threads have been brutal - why are we concentrating on the negatives and bands we "shouldn't like" or ones we "should like but don't". Music should be about sharing things we do like and celebrating the talent instead of ****ting on bands others may love.
I don't know. The thread titles laid it out for you, so if it's not your thing you don't have to read the posts.
I agree the negativity isn't a great thing. But some other music threads have innocuous titles and then I've posted something the usual music thread participants don't agree with and been ridiculed for it.
 
I don’t think I buy into any kind of music being something one “shouldn’t like”.
These last few random music threads have been brutal - why are we concentrating on the negatives and bands we "shouldn't like" or ones we "should like but don't". Music should be about sharing things we do like and celebrating the talent instead of ****ting on bands others may love.
I don't know. The thread titles laid it out for you, so if it's not your thing you don't have to read the posts.
I agree the negativity isn't a great thing. But some other music threads have innocuous titles and then I've posted something the usual music thread participants don't agree with and been ridiculed for it.
You’re right. I apologize. It bothered me but you’re right I don’t have to participate.
 
Ambrosia, REO Speedwagon, & Creed :bag:

Local L.A. band, from San Pedro that no one should ever have to apologize for, for liking.

Their first Top 20 record (reached #17 IRRC) and would have been bigger but they were on 20th Century Fox, a label that was dying at the time and went under a few years later.

Ambrosia - Holding On To Yesterday (1974)

Song has a CSN vibe to it.
 
Not sure how to interpret this question.

I never feel ashamed for having a diverse and random set of music I like. During college, I had to DJ a station where we couldn't play any top 40 artists so that helped find a lot of weird stuff.

I think my answer is Kanye West. He's undoubtedly a musical genius, but has just become such a social pariah with his statements/mental health issues. Still, I threw on a playlist I have of his stuff for my ride home yesterday.

Apologies if that isn't the spirit of this thread.
just curious as a kanye fan, do you like fishsticks??? :bag:
 
I don’t think I buy into any kind of music being something one “shouldn’t like”.
These last few random music threads have been brutal - why are we concentrating on the negatives and bands we "shouldn't like" or ones we "should like but don't". Music should be about sharing things we do like and celebrating the talent instead of ****ting on bands others may love.
You're right, but I am also highly confident no one loves Puddle of Mudd. God, they're so terrible. And because they're now fresh on my mind I'll probably listen to them on today's afternoon run.
I know nothing about the band but Blurry is outstanding.
 
Coldplay, Lil Pump and Limp Bizkit (their early stuff still hits)
Limp Bizkit is probably a good answer for me. Chocolate Starfish and the Hotdog Flavored Water? What a bunch of douchebags. But "Rollin'" and "Nookie" get some play when I'm driving.

I actually hate those as well lol. For me it doesn't get much better than their Family Values tour era. Cambodia is still in rotation when I need a little motivation in the gym.
 
I think my answer is Kanye West.

Kanye was under serious consideration for the MAD dummies 31 countdown, but I didn’t feel like doing a deep dive into him given what surrounds him these days. His self-aggrandizement, once played for laughs, becomes serious and sad given what we know.

To be ashamed of liking Kanye seems shortsighted. Most folks who hate just hate the person and not the music. Most also aren't that knowledgeable in hip hop. The guy is a musical wunderkind and responsible for so many classic songs and albums. He pretty much ran hip hop in the 2000s. I'll always love that Kanye.
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Back
Top