better Qb the rest of the way Big Ben or Kitna (1 Viewer)

[eddy13]

better rest of the way Big Ben or Kitna

 

[eddy13]

my bet is big ben.. hes a better runner, has a better line, has a better rb, has a better te and has 2 good wr..

 

[LBH]

I think it depends on how your league is set up. If there is no or minimal penalty for turnovers I think its close. Id rather have Ben even though I dont like the looks of the Steelers schedule for the playoffs

 

[FantasyTrader]

Roethlisberger.

 

[Da Guru]

better rest of the way Big Ben or Kitna

As is WDIS?

 

[SSOG]

Roeth.

 

[Bustin Loose]

If you are serious about winning I would say neither. Ben is arguably the most overrated player on the most overrated team. Kitna is a less then mediocre quarterback in a great system. Either way you don't want to count on these guys in crunch time. You have one thing going for you there is enough delusional Steeler fans to get a good player in return.

 

[chris1969]

If you are serious about winning I would say neither. Ben is arguably the most overrated player on the most overrated team. Kitna is a less then mediocre quarterback in a great system. Either way you don't want to count on these guys in crunch time. You have one thing going for you there is enough delusional Steeler fans to get a good player in return.

Agreed and I got Big Ben in 2 leagues and Kitna in 2.

 

[RBM]

Ben is arguably the most overrated player on the most overrated team.

WTF???

 

[ScoobyDoo]

Ben.

Stick a fork in the Lions. They're done.

 

[tombonneau]

If you are serious about winning I would say neither. Ben is arguably the most overrated player on the most overrated team. Kitna is a less then mediocre quarterback in a great system. Either way you don't want to count on these guys in crunch time. You have one thing going for you there is enough delusional Steeler fans to get a good player in return.

I'm pretty happy with Big Ben aka QB4 in my league. He's been a TD machine, even in blowouts. What's not to like?And I think if any Kitna owner was offered Big Ben straight up they couldn't accept fast enough. I know if I were offered Kitna for Big Ben I would decline in as much time as it took me to stop laughing.

 

[BigTuna]

I'd probably say ben because of his schedule. best to keep both and use qb by committee though.

 

[Frawfog]

I'm not excited about either one. Kitna leads the league in eating the football. He's been sacked 37 times. Roethlisberger is up there in sacks taken as well with 23 and he's had a lot fewer pass attempts than Kitna. Ben took 3 sacks even in the blowout win where he threw 5 TD passes. He threw 16 passes and got sacked 3 times by a team they were dominating. Ugh. My hunch is both of these guys get injured.

 

[Steeler07]

If you are serious about winning I would say neither. Ben is arguably the most overrated player on the most overrated team. Kitna is a less then mediocre quarterback in a great system. Either way you don't want to count on these guys in crunch time. You have one thing going for you there is enough delusional Steeler fans to get a good player in return.

Agreed and I got Big Ben in 2 leagues and Kitna in 2.

The Steelers may be overrated, but Roethlisberger is not.