CBS "Expert" Mock Draft results (1 Viewer)

[morbid]

ROUND 1

No. Owner Selection

1 Pete Prisco Larry Johnson, RB, Kansas City

2 Jason Horowitz LaDainian Tomlinson, RB, San Diego

3 Dave Richard Shaun Alexander, RB, Seattle

4 Clark Judge Clinton Portis, RB, Washington

5 Michael Fabiano Edgerrin James, RB, Arizona

6 Brian De Los Santos Tiki Barber, RB, N.Y. Giants

7 Sergio Gonzalez Carnell Williams, RB, Tampa Bay

8 Eric Mack Rudi Johnson, RB, Cincinnati

9 Greg Bromberg LaMont Jordan, RB, Oakland

10 Peter Madden Steven Jackson, RB, St. Louis

11 Daniel E. Dobish Ronnie Brown, RB, Miami

12 Tommy Tighe Willis McGahee, RB, Buffalo

ROUND 2

No. Owner Selection

13 Tommy Tighe Warrick Dunn, RB, Atlanta

14 Daniel E. Dobish Terrell Owens, WR, Dallas

15 Peter Madden Peyton Manning, QB, Indianapolis

16 Greg Bromberg Tom Brady, QB, New England

17 Eric Mack Domanick Davis, RB, Houston

18 Sergio Gonzalez Chad Johnson, WR, Cincinnati

19 Brian De Los Santos Julius Jones, RB, Dallas

20 Michael Fabiano Brian Westbrook, RB, Philadelphia

21 Clark Judge Steve Smith, WR, Carolina

22 Dave Richard Torry Holt, WR, St. Louis

23 Jason Horowitz DeShaun Foster, RB, Carolina

24 Pete Prisco Reggie Bush, RB, New Orleans

ROUND 3

No. Owner Selection

25 Pete Prisco Carson Palmer, QB, Cincinnati

26 Jason Horowitz Larry Fitzgerald, WR, Arizona

27 Dave Richard Jamal Lewis, RB, Baltimore

28 Clark Judge Tatum Bell, RB, Denver

29 Michael Fabiano Randy Moss, WR, Oakland

30 Brian De Los Santos Marvin Harrison, WR, Indianapolis

31 Sergio Gonzalez Corey Dillon, RB, New England

32 Eric Mack Kevin Jones, RB, Detroit

33 Greg Bromberg Anquan Boldin, WR, Arizona

34 Peter Madden Cedric Benson, RB, Chicago

35 Daniel E. Dobish Willie Parker, RB, Pittsburgh

36 Tommy Tighe Antonio Gates, TE, San Diego

ROUND 4

No. Owner Selection

37 Tommy Tighe Matt Hasselbeck, QB, Seattle

38 Daniel E. Dobish Jason Witten, TE, Dallas

39 Peter Madden Tony Gonzalez, TE, Kansas City

40 Greg Bromberg Reuben Droughns, RB, Cleveland

41 Eric Mack Santana Moss, WR, Washington

42 Sergio Gonzalez Reggie Wayne, WR, Indianapolis

43 Brian De Los Santos Daunte Culpepper, QB, Miami

44 Michael Fabiano Hines Ward, WR, Pittsburgh

45 Clark Judge Chester Taylor, RB, Minnesota

46 Dave Richard Chris Chambers, WR, Miami

47 Jason Horowitz Javon Walker, WR, Denver

48 Pete Prisco Roy Williams, WR, Detroit

ROUND 5

No. Owner Selection

49 Pete Prisco Fred Taylor, RB, Jacksonville

50 Jason Horowitz Chris Brown, RB, Tennessee

51 Dave Richard Joseph Addai, RB, Indianapolis

52 Clark Judge Donovan McNabb, QB, Philadelphia

53 Michael Fabiano Darrell Jackson, WR, Seattle

54 Brian De Los Santos Deuce McAllister, RB, New Orleans

55 Sergio Gonzalez Andre Johnson, WR, Houston

56 Eric Mack Plaxico Burress, WR, N.Y. Giants

57 Greg Bromberg Jeremy Shockey, TE, N.Y. Giants

58 Peter Madden Deion Branch, WR, New England

59 Daniel E. Dobish Nate Burleson, WR, Seattle

60 Tommy Tighe Donald Driver, WR, Green Bay

ROUND 6

No. Owner Selection

61 Tommy Tighe Derrick Mason, WR, Baltimore

62 Daniel E. Dobish Eric Moulds, WR, Houston

63 Peter Madden Curtis Martin, RB, N.Y. Jets

64 Greg Bromberg Kevan Barlow, RB, San Francisco

65 Eric Mack Eli Manning, QB, N.Y. Giants

66 Sergio Gonzalez Marc Bulger, QB, St. Louis

67 Brian De Los Santos Joe Horn, WR, New Orleans

68 Michael Fabiano Thomas Jones, RB, Chicago

69 Clark Judge Todd Heap, TE, Baltimore

70 Dave Richard Ahman Green, RB, Green Bay

71 Jason Horowitz Drew Brees, QB, New Orleans

72 Pete Prisco Joey Galloway, WR, Tampa Bay

ROUND 7

No. Owner Selection

73 Pete Prisco T.J. Houshmandzadeh, WR, Cincinnati

74 Jason Horowitz Alge Crumpler, TE, Atlanta

75 Dave Richard Chris Cooley, TE, Washington

76 Clark Judge Muhsin Muhammad, WR, Chicago

77 Michael Fabiano Randy McMichael, TE, Miami

78 Brian De Los Santos Heath Miller, TE, Pittsburgh

79 Sergio Gonzalez L.J. Smith, TE, Philadelphia

80 Eric Mack Dominic Rhodes, RB, Indianapolis

81 Greg Bromberg Samkon Gado, RB, Green Bay

82 Peter Madden Jerry Porter, WR, Oakland

83 Daniel E. Dobish Drew Bledsoe, QB, Dallas

84 Tommy Tighe Terry Glenn, WR, Dallas

ROUND 8

No. Owner Selection

85 Tommy Tighe Duce Staley, RB, Pittsburgh

86 Daniel E. Dobish DeAngelo Williams, RB, Carolina

87 Peter Madden Laurence Maroney, RB, New England

88 Greg Bromberg Ben Roethlisberger, QB, Pittsburgh

89 Eric Mack Reggie Brown, WR, Philadelphia

90 Sergio Gonzalez Chicago DST

91 Brian De Los Santos Jake Delhomme, QB, Carolina

92 Michael Fabiano LenDale White, RB, Tennessee

93 Clark Judge Donte Stallworth, WR, New Orleans

94 Dave Richard Frank Gore, RB, San Francisco

95 Jason Horowitz Brett Favre, QB, Green Bay

96 Pete Prisco Vernon Davis, TE, San Francisco

ROUND 9

No. Owner Selection

97 Pete Prisco Mark Clayton, WR, Baltimore

98 Jason Horowitz Marcus Robinson, WR, Minnesota

99 Dave Richard Eddie Kennison, WR, Kansas City

100 Clark Judge Lee Evans, WR, Buffalo

101 Michael Fabiano Trent Green, QB, Kansas City

102 Brian De Los Santos Rod Smith, WR, Denver

103 Sergio Gonzalez Ron Dayne, RB, Denver

104 Eric Mack Priest Holmes, RB, Kansas City

105 Greg Bromberg Indianapolis DST

106 Peter Madden David Givens, WR, Tennessee

107 Daniel E. Dobish Kurt Warner, QB, Arizona

108 Tommy Tighe Keyshawn Johnson, WR, Carolina

ROUND 10

No. Owner Selection

109 Tommy Tighe Jake Plummer, QB, Denver

110 Daniel E. Dobish Laveranues Coles, WR, N.Y. Jets

111 Peter Madden Adam Vinatieri, PK, Indianapolis

112 Greg Bromberg Braylon Edwards, WR, Cleveland

113 Eric Mack Issac Bruce, WR, St. Louis

114 Sergio Gonzalez Michael Vick, QB, Atlanta

115 Brian De Los Santos Kellen Winslow, TE, Cleveland

116 Michael Fabiano Aaron Brooks, QB, Oakland

117 Clark Judge Mike Anderson, RB, Baltimore

118 Dave Richard Carolina DST

119 Jason Horowitz Shayne Graham, PK, Cincinnati

120 Pete Prisco Byron Leftwich, QB, Jacksonville

ROUND 11

No. Owner Selection

121 Pete Prisco Ben Troupe, TE, Tennessee

122 Jason Horowitz Pittsburgh DST

123 Dave Richard Steve McNair, QB, Baltimore

124 Clark Judge Neil Rackers, PK, Arizona

125 Michael Fabiano Keenan McCardell, WR, San Diego

126 Brian De Los Santos T.J. Duckett, RB, Atlanta

127 Sergio Gonzalez Koren Robinson, WR, Minnesota

128 Eric Mack Matt Jones, WR, Jacksonville

129 Greg Bromberg Jerramy Stevens, TE, Seattle

130 Peter Madden Philip Rivers, QB, San Diego

131 Daniel E. Dobish Dallas Clark, TE, Indianapolis

132 Tommy Tighe Brandon Jacobs, RB, N.Y. Giants

ROUND 12

No. Owner Selection

133 Tommy Tighe Ben Watson, TE, New England

134 Daniel E. Dobish Brandon Lloyd, WR, Washington

135 Peter Madden Dolphins DST

136 Greg Bromberg Ryan Longwell, PK, Minnesota

137 Eric Mack Chris Perry, RB, Cincinnati

138 Sergio Gonzalez Jay Feely, PK, N.Y. Giants

139 Brian De Los Santos Jason Elam, PK, Denver

140 Michael Fabiano Drew Bennett, WR, Tennessee

141 Clark Judge Cincinnati DST

142 Dave Richard Mark Brunell, QB, Washington

143 Jason Horowitz Tampa Bay DST

144 Pete Prisco Michael Clayton, WR, Tampa Bay

ROUND 13

No. Owner Selection

145 Pete Prisco Travis Henry, RB, Tennessee

146 Jason Horowitz Brandon Stokley, WR, Indianapolis

147 Dave Richard Ernest Wilford, WR, Jacksonville

148 Clark Judge Jon Kitna, QB, Detroit

149 Michael Fabiano Mike Vanderjagt, PK, Dallas

150 Brian De Los Santos Antwaan Randle El, WR, Washington

151 Sergio Gonzalez Kevin Curtis, WR, St. Louis

152 Eric Mack Alex Smith, TE, Tampa Bay

153 Greg Bromberg Troy Williamson, WR, Minnesota

154 Peter Madden Joe Jurevicius, WR, Cleveland

155 Daniel E. Dobish Jeff Wilkins, PK, St. Louis

156 Tommy Tighe Seattle DST

ROUND 14

No. Owner Selection

157 Tommy Tighe David Akers, PK, Philadelphia

158 Daniel E. Dobish Baltimore DST

159 Peter Madden Derrick Blaylock, RB, N.Y. Jets

160 Greg Bromberg Amani Toomer, WR, N.Y. Giants

161 Eric Mack Jacksonville DST

162 Sergio Gonzalez Atlanta DST

163 Brian De Los Santos Greg Jones, RB, Jacksonville

164 Michael Fabiano Ryan Moats, RB, Philadelphia

165 Clark Judge Marshall Faulk, RB, St. Louis

166 Dave Richard Marion Barber, RB, Dallas

167 Jason Horowitz Marcedes Lewis, TE, Jacksonville

168 Pete Prisco Lawrence Tynes, PK, Kansas City

ROUND 15

No. Owner Selection

169 Pete Prisco Denver DST

170 Jason Horowitz Robert Ferguson, WR, Green Bay

171 Dave Richard Roddy White, WR, Atlanta

172 Clark Judge Antonio Bryant, WR, San Francisco

173 Michael Fabiano N.Y. Giants DST

174 Brian De Los Santos Santonio Holmes, WR, Pittsburgh

175 Sergio Gonzalez David Carr, QB, Houston

176 Eric Mack Nate Kaeding, PK, San Diego

177 Greg Bromberg Sebastian Janikowski, PK, Oakland

178 Peter Madden Maurice Drew, RB, Jacksonville

179 Daniel E. Dobish Michael Pittman, RB, Tampa Bay

180 Tommy Tighe Chad Jackson, WR, New England

ROUND 16

No. Owner Selection

181 Tommy Tighe Brian Calhoun, RB, Detroit

182 Daniel E. Dobish Mike Williams, WR, Detroit

183 Peter Madden Cedric Cobbs, RB, Denver

184 Greg Bromberg Minnesota DST

185 Eric Mack Ashley Lelie, WR, Denver

186 Sergio Gonzalez Charles Rogers, WR, Detroit

187 Brian De Los Santos Washington DST

188 Michael Fabiano Jermaine Wiggins, TE, Minnesota

189 Clark Judge Philadelphia DST

190 Dave Richard John Kasay, PK, Carolina

191 Jason Horowitz Mewelde Moore, RB, Minnesota

192 Pete Prisco Cedric Houston, RB, N.Y. Jets

 

[WhoDat]

I stopped reading after I saw Dunn and Brady at 13 and 16, respectively.

 

[joffer]

no Marcel Shipp in the 2nd round?? :(

 

[Padraig]

I havent read the whole thing yet,but 2 things jump out right away.

This is a PPR league,so Rudi went too early and Westbrook too late,IMO.

 

[dudaman]

I stopped reading after I saw Dunn and Brady at 13 and 16, respectively.

Tommy Tighe =

 

[dudaman]

Is this a dynasty draft? If not, is Reggie Bush going in the second round in your drafts as well?

 

[ChampBailey24]

It's not that accurate but it's still a decent mock draft. I mean, how many ridiculous mock drafts have we seen (NFL) ? This one had some flaws but isn't that ridiculous.

 

[tytyty]

James # 5 huh? I wonder if there is an article or analysis that shows top 10 RB when they get traded to a less then optimal rushing attack.

Boys?

It would be interesting to see historically how a supposed really good back does on a bad rushing team.

 

[mbuehner]

Whats the scoring/rules?

That being said, these are questionable (at best) for the first 2 rounds:

5 Michael Fabiano Edgerrin James, RB, Arizona

Edge before Tiki- risky. Unless you assume Tiki is going to get hurt I dont see how Edge can possibly outperform him in AZ as bad as their D is and how much they pass.

7 Sergio Gonzalez Carnell Williams, RB, Tampa Bay

Too early, but not indefensible. Rudi and Lamont have better track records at this point.

13 Tommy Tighe Warrick Dunn, RB, Atlanta

Come on man. McGahee and Dunn? Sounds like a law firm, not a backfield.

16 Greg Bromberg Tom Brady, QB, New England

Brady can't go 1 pick after Manning in a fantasy league. Ever.

24 Pete Prisco Reggie Bush, RB, New Orleans

Too Early. You're going to match up Larry Johnson with Bush, Freddy Taylor, and Travis Henry? High risk, high reward, but if he really wanted Bush he should have gone RB/RB/RB and taken Kevin Jones or Willy Parker. If Bush ends up worth starting, one of those guys will have trade value.

 

[einstein2u]

witten in the 4th?????

 

[morbid]

Mock Draft Guidelines and Scoring:

League guidelines: Owners are required to start one quarterback, two running backs, three wide receivers, one flex (RB/WR/TE), one tight end, one kicker and one hybrid defense (DST). Rosters are limited to 16 players with no restrictions on positions (an owner could carry six RB reserves if he wanted to).

Offensive scoring: All touchdowns: 6 points; Two-point conversions: 2 points; 1 point for each 10 yards rushing and receiving; 1 point for each 25 yards passing; Receptions: 1 point; Field Goals: 3 points (5 points for a 50-plus-yard field goal); Extra Points: 1 point; Fumbles lost: minus-2 points; Passing interceptions: minus-2 points.

DST scoring: Touchdowns: 6 points; Interceptions: 2 points; Sacks: 1 point; Safeties: 2 points; Shutout: 5 points; 2-10 points allowed: 3 points.

 

[Deuce'sWild]

Wow, I'd love to get S. Jackson as the #10 pick overall. Let me in this league.

McGahee went way to high, as did Brady, Dunn, and Bush.

These "experts" didn't impress me much.

 

[Captain Quinoa]

I stopped reading after I saw Dunn and Brady at 13 and 16, respectively.

Tommy Tighe =

Weird thing is, the guy didn't draft all that badly after his first 2 pics

 

[srnohav]

if all TD's are worth 6 points, then QB's would be drafted higher than most other drafts.

 

[Gargoylez]

TOP 3 wr GOES IN THE THIRD ROUND?

LMAO!

I hate looking at these kind of mocks, very unrealistic with the bone heads picking players.

 

[Padraig]

witten in the 4th?????

And ahead of Gonzalez. Some of these guys were awful.

Ive never heard of Horowitz,but he had the worst draft.

Took Brees and Favre in the 6th and 8th, with better QBs still on the board each time.

He couldve had better value and helped his team by taking T.J. Houshmandzadeh

instead of Brees and getting Trent Green 3 rounds later.

Took Walker ahead of D. Jackson,Driver and Plaxico.

He burned 3 straight picks,10th,11th and 12th round,on a K and 2 Defenses.

Picking 2 QBs,2 Def and a K before you have any RB or WR depth is insane and not really "expert" drafting.

 

[Cookiemonster]

Pete Prisco Despite all his B.S., not bad.

25 Carson Palmer, 120 Byron Leftwich

1 Larry Johnson, 24 Reggie Bush, 49 Fred Taylor, 145 Travis Henry, 192 Cedric Houston

48 Roy Williams, 72 Joey Galloway, 73 T.J. Houshmandzadeh, 97 Mark Clayton, 144 Michael Clayton

96 Vernon Davis, 121 Ben Troupe

169 Denver

168 Lawrence Tynes

Jason Horowitz Bad value @ QB, ? RBs, ? WRs. Don't like it myself.

71 Drew Brees, 95 Brett Favre

2 LaDainian Tomlinson, 23 DeShaun Foster, 50 Chris Brown, 191 Mewelde Moore

26 Larry Fitzgerald, 47 Javon Walker, 98 Marcus Robinson, 146 Brandon Stokley, 170 Robert Ferguson

74 Alge Crumpler, 167 Marcedes Lewis

122 Pittsburgh, 143 Tampa Bay

119 Shayne Graham

Dave Richard I like the old QBs, like the RB depth (all should get playing time if not starting), WRs could really pan out but a wasted pick on Cooley IMO with the 3 quality WRs Washington has. Swap TE pick for a QB and get an = TE @ 120+. Overall, good.

123 Steve McNair, 142 Mark Brunell

3 Shaun Alexander, 27 Jamal Lewis, 51 Joseph Addai, 70 Ahman Green, 94 Frank Gore, 166 Marion Barber

22 Torry Holt, 46 Chris Chambers, 99 Eddie Kennison, 147 Ernest Wilford, 171 Roddy White

75 Chris Cooley

118 Carolina

190 John Kasay

Clark Judge After Portis and Smith, the best pick was Philly @ 189. 'Nuff said. And this guy gets paid for what he writes?

52 Donovan McNabb, 148 Jon Kitna

4 Clinton Portis, 28 Tatum Bell, 45 Chester Taylor, 117 Mike Anderson, 165 Marshall Faulk

21 Steve Smith, 76 Muhsin Muhammad, 93 Donte Stallworth, 100 Lee Evans, 172 Antonio Bryant

69 Todd Heap

141 Cincinnati, 189 Philadelphia

124 Neil Rackers

Michael Fabiano Depth @ RB is a little unnerving, but PPR will be a very good team if Edge and Westy stay healthy.

101 Trent Green, 116 Aaron Brooks

5 Edgerrin James, 20 Brian Westbrook, 68 Thomas Jones, 92 LenDale White, 164 Ryan Moats

29 Randy Moss, 44 Hines Ward, 53 Darrell Jackson, 125 Keenan McCardell, 140 Drew Bennett

77 Randy McMichael, 188 Jermaine Wiggins

173 N.Y. Giants

149 Mike Vanderjagt

Brian De Los Santos C'Pep @ 43??? Should have gotten another back there, but oterwise decent.

43 Daunte Culpepper, 91 Jake Delhomme

6 Tiki Barber, 19 Julius Jones, 54 Deuce McAllister, 126 T.J. Duckett, 163 Greg Jones

30 Marvin Harrison, 67 Joe Horn, 102 Rod Smith, 150 Antwaan Randle El, 174 Santonio Holmes

78 Heath Miller, 115 Kellen Winslow

187 Washington

139 Jason Elam

Sergio Gonzalez 2 Ds, 3 QBs and only 3 RBs? That won't make it through the season in a start 2 back league. My pick to finish last.

66 Marc Bulger, 114 Michael Vick, 175 David Carr

7 Carnell Williams, 31 Corey Dillon, 103 Ron Dayne

18 Chad Johnson, 42 Reggie Wayne, 55 Andre Johnson, 127 Koren Robinson, 151 Kevin Curtis, 186 Charles Rogers

79 L.J. Smith

90 Chicago, 162 Atlanta

138 Jay Feely

Eric Mack We all agree there was better value in a PPR @ #8, but good otherwise. Enough depth to make a trade for a 2nd QB.

65 Eli Manning

8 Rudi Johnson, 17 Domanick Davis, 32 Kevin Jones, 80 Dominic Rhodes, 104 Priest Holmes, 137 Chris Perry

41 Santana Moss, 56 Plaxico Burress, 89 Reggie Brown, 113 Issac Bruce, 128 Matt Jones, 185 Ashley Lelie

152 Alex Smith

161 Jacksonville

176 Nate Kaeding

Greg Bromberg Yeah, Brady. With RB and WR so weak, #16 was even worse! Contender for last. Hey, at least he's got good TEs and Ks.

16 Tom Brady, 88 Ben Roethlisberger

9 LaMont Jordan, 40 Reuben Droughns, 64 Kevan Barlow, 81 Samkon Gado

33 Anquan Boldin, 112 Braylon Edwards, 153 Troy Williamson, 160 Amani Toomer

57 Jeremy Shockey, 129 Jerramy Stevens

105 Indianapolis, 184 Minnesota

136 Ryan Longwell, 177 Sebastian Janikowski

Peter Madden Overkill @ RB. Make a trade to solidify the WRs and he's got a pretty good roster.

15 Peyton Manning, 130 Philip Rivers

10 Steven Jackson, 34 Cedric Benson, 63 Curtis Martin, 87 Laurence Maroney, 159 Derrick Blaylock, 178 Maurice Drew, 183 Cedric Cobbs

58 Deion Branch, 82 Jerry Porter, 106 David Givens, 154 Joe Jurevicius

39 Tony Gonzalez

135 Dolphins

111 Adam Vinatieri

Daniel E. Dobish Love the roster... but WTF is Witten the #38 pick for? Substitute w/ Droughns and I would have been pleased.

83 Drew Bledsoe, 107 Kurt Warner

11 Ronnie Brown, 35 Willie Parker, 86 DeAngelo Williams, 179 Michael Pittman

14 Terrell Owens, 59 Nate Burleson, 61 Derrick Mason, 62 Eric Moulds, 110 Laveranues Coles, 134 Brandon Lloyd, 182 Mike Williams

38 Jason Witten, 131 Dallas Clark

158 Baltimore

155 Jeff Wilkins

Tommy Tighe Agree that there was better value than McGahee and Dunn, but really made up for it with Glenn and Key. Watson may way outperform #133 and provide a package for a better RB.

37 Matt Hasselbeck, 109 Jake Plummer

12 Willis McGahee, 13 Warrick Dunn, 85 Duce Staley, 132 Brandon Jacobs, 181 Brian Calhoun

60 Donald Driver, 61 Derrick Mason, 84 Terry Glenn, 108 Keyshawn Johnson, 180 Chad Jackson

36 Antonio Gates, 133 Ben Watson

156 Seattle

157 David Akers

 

[JimmyD]

I havent read the whole thing yet,but 2 things jump out right away.

This is a PPR league,so Rudi went too early and Westbrook too late,IMO.

I agree with you that in ppr leagues Rudi went a little high, but then he snagged Dom Davis in the 2nd, so it works itself out. (if you think DD will be healthy)

 

[joffer]

despite the fact that i don't like Edge, i like Fabiano's team overall

 

[nygiants56]

Pete Prisco

25 Carson Palmer, 120 Byron Leftwich

1 Larry Johnson, 24 Reggie Bush, 49 Fred Taylor, 145 Travis Henry, 192 Cedric Houston

48 Roy Williams, 72 Joey Galloway, 73 T.J. Houshmandzadeh, 97 Mark Clayton, 144 Michael Clayton

96 Vernon Davis, 121 Ben Troupe

169 Denver

168 Lawrence Tynes

Jason Horowitz

71 Drew Brees, 95 Brett Favre

2 LaDainian Tomlinson, 23 DeShaun Foster, 50 Chris Brown, 191 Mewelde Moore

26 Larry Fitzgerald, 47 Javon Walker, 98 Marcus Robinson, 146 Brandon Stokley, 170 Robert Ferguson

74 Alge Crumpler, 167 Marcedes Lewis

122 Pittsburgh, 143 Tampa Bay

119 Shayne Graham

Dave Richard

123 Steve McNair, 142 Mark Brunell

3 Shaun Alexander, 27 Jamal Lewis, 51 Joseph Addai, 70 Ahman Green, 94 Frank Gore, 166 Marion Barber

22 Torry Holt, 46 Chris Chambers, 99 Eddie Kennison, 147 Ernest Wilford, 171 Roddy White

75 Chris Cooley

118 Carolina

190 John Kasay

Clark Judge

52 Donovan McNabb, 148 Jon Kitna

4 Clinton Portis, 28 Tatum Bell, 45 Chester Taylor, 117 Mike Anderson, 165 Marshall Faulk

21 Steve Smith, 76 Muhsin Muhammad, 93 Donte Stallworth, 100 Lee Evans, 172 Antonio Bryant

69 Todd Heap

141 Cincinnati, 189 Philadelphia

124 Neil Rackers

Michael Fabiano

101 Trent Green, 116 Aaron Brooks

5 Edgerrin James, 20 Brian Westbrook, 68 Thomas Jones, 92 LenDale White, 164 Ryan Moats

29 Randy Moss, 44 Hines Ward, 53 Darrell Jackson, 125 Keenan McCardell, 140 Drew Bennett

77 Randy McMichael, 188 Jermaine Wiggins

173 N.Y. Giants

149 Mike Vanderjagt

Brian De Los Santos

43 Daunte Culpepper, 91 Jake Delhomme

6 Tiki Barber, 19 Julius Jones, 54 Deuce McAllister, 126 T.J. Duckett, 163 Greg Jones

30 Marvin Harrison, 67 Joe Horn, 102 Rod Smith, 150 Antwaan Randle El, 174 Santonio Holmes

78 Heath Miller, 115 Kellen Winslow

187 Washington

139 Jason Elam

Sergio Gonzalez

66 Marc Bulger, 114 Michael Vick, 175 David Carr

7 Carnell Williams, 31 Corey Dillon, 103 Ron Dayne

18 Chad Johnson, 42 Reggie Wayne, 55 Andre Johnson, 127 Koren Robinson, 151 Kevin Curtis, 186 Charles Rogers

79 L.J. Smith

90 Chicago, 162 Atlanta

138 Jay Feely

Eric Mack

65 Eli Manning

8 Rudi Johnson, 17 Domanick Davis, 32 Kevin Jones, 80 Dominic Rhodes, 104 Priest Holmes, 137 Chris Perry

41 Santana Moss, 56 Plaxico Burress, 89 Reggie Brown, 113 Issac Bruce, 128 Matt Jones, 185 Ashley Lelie

152 Alex Smith

161 Jacksonville

176 Nate Kaeding

Greg Bromberg

16 Tom Brady, 88 Ben Roethlisberger

9 LaMont Jordan, 40 Reuben Droughns, 64 Kevan Barlow, 81 Samkon Gado

33 Anquan Boldin, 112 Braylon Edwards, 153 Troy Williamson, 160 Amani Toomer

57 Jeremy Shockey, 129 Jerramy Stevens

105 Indianapolis, 184 Minnesota

136 Ryan Longwell, 177 Sebastian Janikowski

Peter Madden

15 Peyton Manning, 130 Philip Rivers

10 Steven Jackson, 34 Cedric Benson, 63 Curtis Martin, 87 Laurence Maroney, 159 Derrick Blaylock, 178 Maurice Drew, 183 Cedric Cobbs

58 Deion Branch, 82 Jerry Porter, 106 David Givens, 154 Joe Jurevicius

39 Tony Gonzalez

135 Dolphins

111 Adam Vinatieri

Daniel E. Dobish

83 Drew Bledsoe, 107 Kurt Warner

11 Ronnie Brown, 35 Willie Parker, 86 DeAngelo Williams, 179 Michael Pittman

14 Terrell Owens, 59 Nate Burleson, 61 Derrick Mason, 62 Eric Moulds, 110 Laveranues Coles, 134 Brandon Lloyd, 182 Mike Williams

38 Jason Witten, 131 Dallas Clark

158 Baltimore

155 Jeff Wilkins

Tommy Tighe

37 Matt Hasselbeck, 109 Jake Plummer

12 Willis McGahee, 13 Warrick Dunn, 85 Duce Staley, 132 Brandon Jacobs, 181 Brian Calhoun

60 Donald Driver, 61 Derrick Mason, 84 Terry Glenn, 108 Keyshawn Johnson, 180 Chad Jackson

36 Antonio Gates, 133 Ben Watson

156 Seattle

157 David Akers

chad Johnson at 18 way too low..Pete Prisco did poorly with his WR's, but, Ben Troupe at 121 was a steal..

Dave Richard has a solid unit, qb's a injury risks, but he has tremendous depth at nearly every other position.

Clark Judge did fairly well, although he's very weak at RB outside of Portis, and weak at WR outside of Steve Smith.

Fabiano has a very suspect backfield with Westbrook, Jones, LenDale White...

but I did like the Edge selection at #5 overall..

Sergio Gonzalez has a lousy backfiled , imo..outside of Carnell,who else do you have there, Dillon & Dayne? sounds like a bad sitcom.

Madden has just 1 starting RB, unless you count C-mart , who's likely to be involved in RBBC this year..

am I reading this right, Dobish and Tighe BOTH have Derrick Mason?!

 

[mbuehner]

if all TD's are worth 6 points, then QB's would be drafted higher than most other drafts.

25 passing yards = 1 FP mellows it.Regardless its the VBD argument that makes me tsk the Brady pick. He could almost certainly have gotten him a full round later, or worst case drafted Hasselbeck instead. This is not the year to jump for any QB short of Manning or a healthy Palmer. Too many guys in the second tier with top 3 possibilities to choose from.

 

[Padraig]

I havent read the whole thing yet,but 2 things jump out right away.

This is a PPR league,so Rudi went too early and Westbrook too late,IMO.

I agree with you that in ppr leagues Rudi went a little high, but then he snagged Dom Davis in the 2nd, so it works itself out. (if you think DD will be healthy)

Good point. A healthy Davis in PPR is great value where he picked him.Fabiano did the same thing.He took Edge over Tiki but it worked for him when

Westbrook was there late 2nd round.

 

[tytyty]

Barring injuries (yeah right) Fabiano will take it!

 

[mbuehner]

He took Edge over Tiki but it worked for him when Westbrook was there late 2nd round.

I dont see how that worked for him when he could have had Tiki + Westbrook, which in a PPR league is cash money in the bank. Edge has question marks.

 

[jdoggydogg]

19 Brian De Los Santos Julius Jones, RB, Dallas 20 Michael Fabiano Brian Westbrook, RB, Philadelphia

Brian De Los Santos is De Los insane for taking Jones over Westbrook.

 

[GroveDiesel]

I don't get all the Brady hate. I'm a Bills fan and wouldn't shed a tear if he broke his leg. But in my league last season where 25yards=1 pt and passing TDs=6pts, Brady outscored Manning by 3 points. Brady did lose Givens and there's the Branch issue, but I think that Chad Jackson may be better than either of those guys and Brady has never relied on just one guy anyway. The rushing game should be better, although I guess you could take that as a negative too.

IMO, Manning lost more this offseason than Brady did with the loss of Edge. Manning probably has a higher upside, but Brady is a solid pick. I wouldn't take him that high (but then again, I wouldn't take Manning that high either), but Brady should almost definitely be the next QB taken after Manning in my mind.

 

[poopdawg]

I stopped reading after I saw Dunn and Brady at 13 and 16, respectively.

Were they passing the bowl in the draft room????

 

[Sinrman]

13 Tommy Tighe Warrick Dunn, RB, Atlanta

Come on man. McGahee and Dunn? Sounds like a law firm, not a backfield.

 

[NOSRAC247]

13 Tommy Tighe Warrick Dunn, RB, Atlanta

Dumbest pick of the draft!

 

[remote controller]

Fabiano did real well out of the 5 hole, but maybe could have improved even more by taking Tiki over edge at 1.05. I like his squad.

 

[Padraig]

He took Edge over Tiki but it worked for him when

Westbrook was there late 2nd round.

I dont see how that worked for him when he could have had Tiki + Westbrook, which in a PPR league is cash money in the bank. Edge has question marks.

Youre right.I didnt put that the right way.Tiki/Westbrook wouldve been much better,but once he picked Edge

I doubt he thought Westbrook would be there for him in the 2nd.

I just meant it worked out about as well as he couldve hoped.

Passing on Tiki was dumb,having Westbrook fall

to him was dumb luck.

Blowing a top 5 pick almost never works out that well.

Looking at the RBs who wouldve been there for him had Westbrook gone early 2nd,he couldve been in much worse shape.

No question he blew it passing on Tiki, but he recovered nicely and has one of the better teams.

 

[Chaos Commish]

I stopped reading after I saw Dunn and Brady at 13 and 16, respectively.

You missed out on some entertaining reading.

 

[Solidsteel Rats]

I would of took Manning at the 12th pick and Owens at the 13th pick.

My next pick at 36..there would of been 6-7 starting RB's still..would grab best 2 of them then!