Wilbur Wood said:
I commish both baseball and football leagues on CBS.
I played in 3 CBS leagues this year, none of which had any material problems other than there were a few Sundays during which Live Scoring was "frozen" up. I'll gladly take the 50% off for 2007.
I am also familiar with MFL (Myfantasyleague) as I have played in it for the past 3 years as well.
My $0.02 on CBS vs. MFL
#1 I prefer CBS to MFL. I chuckle at the arrogant fantasy geeks who opine on the superiority of MFL to CBS and suggest that "hands down" its a superior investment. It is all a matter of personal preferance.
MFL is a site for designed by hard core fantasy geeks for hard core fantasy geeks. Its interfaces and site design appear to have been designed by part-time college students who have simply bolted on applications over time whereever they could conveniently fit them. For those fantasy players who don't spend countless hours on line navigating the host site, MFL is a pain in the ###. CBS has infinately better site design, data retention capability and direct acces to historical NFL and fantasy league information.
The other day I tried to pull up the actual draft data for this current season for a new fantasy league that I play in on MFL and could not find it anywhere. While on CBS I can go back and within 5 seconds pull up the drafts for the past 4 years in my CBS league. I have easy access to the standings for the past 4 years in CBS, individual NFL by season player stats, historical league fantasy player point totals and can easily click on the current year's standings by week or go back to Live Scoring results by week as well.
Yes, I am aware of a few custom options that MFL has and they have a better array of waiver wire options. I don't really look at Live Scoring in the middle of Sunday afternoon anyway.
So for me, its not even close. Its like a BMW vs a Honda Civic. Yeah the BMW costs more, may frustrate you by going into the shop a little more than it should vs a reliable Civic, but there's no comparison as to what is a higher end product.
IMHO, CBS >> MFL
I couldnt disagree more on the MFL vs CBS. We used CBS for over 5 years and switched this passed season and couldnt be happier. All of our owners were worried about the switch and it took them a week to get use to the different interface however after a couple of weeks every single owner thanked the fantasy gods for MFL. I cant imagine anyone having a hard time navigating MFL. There are 6-8 buttons at the top all with drop downs. Its not very difficult at all, however I guess there are people out there that still havent gotten that mouse over and click thing down yet. The options on MFL far out way CBS in almost every single way, and the look and feel is just amazing.
Look at some of these MFL sites and tell me they arent better then the twice the price CBS site. But maybe some people will miss the McDonald, Budweiser, and so on. I mean who cares about paying $120 and still getting commercials.
site 1
site 2
site 3
Then you use the history page add on it gets even better. It breaks everything down from single game, career, milestones, players, team pages it goes on and on. The history page has so many options that it makes CBS's laughable. Want to know the first team to score 5,000 pts in a career ? It goes on and on.
Oh and the best part ? The live scoring didnt go down once this season, there is also a version that you can down load that has an audio voice that will tell you player X scored on play Z and it can all be set up to your specs.