CBS SportsLine.com Keeper League (1 Viewer)

[jdoggydogg]

Wow. Just stunning how bad this is. These guys should be ashamed.

LINK

Worst picks:

- Edgerrin James gets picked ahead of Ladanian and a host of young talent.

- In round 16, Drew Bledsoe gets picked ahead of Vince Young.

- Chester Taylor picked before Carnell Williams.

- Willie Parker at number 9 ?!

This is so bad, it's sure to elicit some laughs:

Round 1

No. Owner Selection

1. Matt Pitzer Reggie Bush, RB, New Orleans

2. James Quintong Clinton Portis, RB, Washington*

3. Dave Richard Randy Moss, WR, Oakland

4. William Del Pilar Edgerrin James, RB, Arizona*

5. Rick Wolf Julius Jones, RB, Dallas

6. Jeff Erickson Willis McGahee, RB, Buffalo*

7. Greg Ambrosius LaDainian Tomlinson, RB, San Diego*

8. John Hansen Kevin Jones, RB, Detroit*

9. Mike Harmon Willie Parker, RB, Pittsburgh

10. Michael Fabiano Domanick Davis, RB, Houston*

11. Adam Caplan Rudi Johnson, RB, Cincinnati*

12. Sam Caplan Shaun Alexander, RB, Seattle*

Round 2

No. Owner Selection

13. Sam Caplan Tiki Barber, RB, N.Y. Giants*

14. Adam Caplan Peyton Manning, QB, Indianapolis

15. Michael Fabiano LaMont Jordan, RB, Oakland*

16. Mike Harmon Chester Taylor, RB, Baltimore

17. John Hansen Carnell Williams, RB, Tampa Bay*

18. Greg Ambrosius Brian Westbrook, RB, Philadelphia*

19. Jeff Erickson Reuben Droughns, RB, Cleveland

20. Rick Wolf Jamal Lewis, RB, Baltimore

21. William Del Pilar Steven Jackson, RB, St. Louis*

22. Dave Richard DeShaun Foster, RB, Carolina

23. James Quintong Corey Dillon, RB, New England

24. Matt Pitzer Laurence Maroney, RB, New England

Round 3

25. Matt Pitzer Joseph Addai, RB, Indianapolis

26. James Quintong Marvin Harrison, QB, Indianapolis*

27. Dave Richard Cedric Benson, RB, Chicago*

28. William Del Pilar Darrell Jackson, WR, Seattle

29. Rick Wolf Chad Johnson, WR, Cincinnati*

30. Jeff Erickson Tatum Bell, RB, Denver*

31. Greg Ambrosius Tony Gonzalez, TE, Kansas City*

32. John Hansen Terrell Owens, WR, Dallas*

33. Mike Harmon Hines Ward, WR, Pittsburgh*

34. Michael Fabiano Ronnie Brown, RB, Miami*

35. Adam Caplan Chris Chambers, WR, Miami

36. Sam Caplan Torry Holt, WR, St. Louis*

Round 4

No. Owner Selection

37. Sam Caplan Andre Johnson, WR, Houston

38. Adam Caplan Larry Johnson, RB, Kansas City*

39. Michael Fabiano Reggie Wayne, WR, Indianapolis*

40. Mike Harmon Antonio Gates, TE, San Diego*

41. John Hansen Deuce McAllister, RB, New Orleans

42. Greg Ambrosius Javon Walker, WR, Denver

43. Jeff Erickson DeAngelo Williams, RB, Carolina

44. Rick Wolf Derrick Mason, WR, Baltimore

45. William Del Pilar Donovan McNabb, QB, Philadelphia

46. Dave Richard Warrick Dunn, RB, Atlanta*

47. James Quintong Curtis Martin, RB, N.Y. Jets

48. Matt Pitzer Joe Horn, WR, New Orleans*

Round 5

49. Matt Pitzer Deion Branch, WR, New England

50. James Quintong Laveranues Coles, WR, N.Y. Jets

51. Dave Richard Ahman Green, RB, Green Bay

52. William Del Pilar LenDale White, RB, Tennessee

53. Rick Wolf Marc Bulger, QB, St. Louis

54. Jeff Erickson Roy Williams, WR, Detroit*

55. Greg Ambrosius Lee Evans, WR, Buffalo

56. John Hansen Anquan Boldin, WR, Arizona*

57. Mike Harmon Fred Taylor, RB, Jacksonville

58. Michael Fabiano Daunte Culpepper, QB, Miami

59. Adam Caplan Steve Smith, WR, Carolina*

60. Sam Caplan Dominic Rhodes, RB, Indianapolis

Round 6

No. Owner Selection

61. Sam Caplan Jason Witten, TE, Dallas

62. Adam Caplan Frank Gore, RB, San Francisco

63. Michael Fabiano Jeremy Shockey, TE, N.Y. Giants*

64. Mike Harmon Terry Glenn, WR, Dallas

65. John Hansen Carson Palmer, QB, Cincinnati*

66. Greg Ambrosius Larry Fitzgerald, WR, Arizona*

67. Jeff Erickson Drew Bennett, WR, Tennessee

68. Rick Wolf Michael Clayton, WR, Tampa Bay

69. William Del Pilar Todd Heap, TE, Baltimore*

70. Dave Richard Trent Green, QB, Kansas City

71. James Quintong Michael Vick, QB, Atlanta*

72. Matt Pitzer Chris Brown, RB, Tennessee

Round 7

73. Matt Pitzer Plaxico Burress, WR, N.Y. Giants*

74. James Quintong Eddie Kennison, WR, Kansas City

75. Dave Richard Randy McMichael, TE, Miami

76. William Del Pilar Donald Driver, WR, Green Bay*

77. Rick Wolf Alge Crumpler, TE, Atlanta

78. Jeff Erickson Vernon Davis, TE, San Francisco

79. Greg Ambrosius Rod Smith, WR, Denver

80. John Hansen Koren Robinson, WR, Minnesota

81. Mike Harmon Drew Brees, QB, New Orleans

82. Michael Fabiano Braylon Edwards, WR, Cleveland

83. Adam Caplan Tom Brady, QB, New England*

84. Sam Caplan Nate Burleson, WR, Seattle

Round 8

No. Owner Selection

85. Sam Caplan Jerry Porter, WR, Oakland

86. Adam Caplan Heath Miller, TE, Pittsburgh

87. Michael Fabiano David Givens, WR, Tennessee

88. Mike Harmon Ernest Wilford, WR, Jacksonville

89. John Hansen Kellen Winslow, TE, Cleveland

90. Greg Ambrosius Matt Hasselbeck, QB, Seattle*

91. Jeff Erickson Muhsin Muhammad, WR, Chicago

92. Rick Wolf Donte Stallworth, WR, New Orleans*

93. William Del Pilar Keyshawn Johnson, WR, Carolina

94. Dave Richard Ron Dayne, RB, Denver

95. James Quintong Kevan Barlow, RB, San Francisco

96. Matt Pitzer Ben Troupe, TE, Tennessee

Round 9

97. Matt Pitzer T.J. Houshmandzadeh, WR, Cincinnati*

98. James Quintong Marion Barber, RB, Dallas

99. Dave Richard Mark Clayton, WR, Baltimore

100. William Del Pilar Jake Plummer, QB, Denver*

101. Rick Wolf Priest Holmes, RB, Kansas City

102. Jeff Erickson Jake Delhomme, QB, Carolina*

103. Greg Ambrosius Greg Jones, RB, Jacksonville

104. John Hansen Chris Perry, RB, Cincinnati

105. Mike Harmon Mark Brunell, QB, Washington

106. Michael Fabiano Brett Favre, QB, Green Bay

107. Adam Caplan Ben Watson, TE, New England

108. Sam Caplan Mike Anderson, RB, Baltimore

Round 10

No. Owner Selection

109. Sam Caplan Duce Staley, RB, Pittsburgh

110. Adam Caplan Santana Moss, WR, Washington*

111. Michael Fabiano Isaac Bruce, WR, St. Louis

112. Mike Harmon Bears DST

113. John Hansen Antonio Bryant, WR, San Francisco

114. Greg Ambrosius Philip Rivers, QB, San Diego

115. Jeff Erickson T.J. Duckett, RB, Atlanta

116. Rick Wolf Mewelde Moore, RB, Minnesota

117. William Del Pilar Panthers DST

118. Dave Richard Thomas Jones, RB, Chicago*

119. James Quintong Chris Simms, QB, Tampa Bay

120. Matt Pitzer Roddy White, WR, Atlanta

Round 11

No. Owner Selection

121. Matt Pitzer Ben Roethlisberger, QB, Pittsburgh

122. James Quintong Brandon Lloyd, WR, Washington

123. Dave Richard Eric Moulds, WR, Houston

124. William Del Pilar Brandon Jacobs, RB, N.Y. Giants

125. Rick Wolf Aaron Brooks, QB, Oakland

126. Jeff Erickson Billy Volek, QB, Tennessee

127. Greg Ambrosius Amani Toomer, WR, N.Y. Giants

128. John Hansen David Carr, QB, Houston

129. Mike Harmon Ciatrick Fason, RB, Minnesota

130. Michael Fabiano Travis Henry, RB, Tennessee

131. Adam Caplan Steve McNair, QB, Baltimore

132. Sam Caplan Colts DST

Round 12

No. Owner Selection

133. Sam Caplan Ryan Moats, RB, Philadelphia

134. Adam Caplan Keenan McCardell, WR, San Diego

135. Michael Fabiano Michael Jenkins, WR, Atlanta

136. Mike Harmon Troy Williamson, WR, Minnesota

137. John Hansen Chad Jackson, WR, New England

138. Greg Ambrosius Najeh Davenport, RB, Green Bay

139. Jeff Erickson Kevin Curtis, WR, St. Louis*

140. Rick Wolf Adam Vinatieri, K, Indianapolis

141. William Del Pilar Matt Leinart, K, Arizona

142. Dave Richard Steelers DST

143. James Quintong Buccaneers DST

144. Matt Pitzer Byron Leftwich, QB, Jacksonville*

Round 13

145. Matt Pitzer Jon Kitna, QB, Detroit

146. James Quintong Reggie Brown, WR, Philadelphia*

147. Dave Richard Vincent Jackson, WR, San Diego

148. William Del Pilar Reche Caldwell, WR, New England

149. Rick Wolf Falcons DST

150. Jeff Erickson Michael Turner, RB, San Diego

151. Greg Ambrosius Marcedes Lewis, TE, Jacksonville

152. John Hansen Mike Vanderjagt, K, Dallas

153. Mike Harmon Dallas Clark, TE, Indianapolis

154. Michael Fabiano Ashley Lelie, WR, Denver

155. Adam Caplan Michael Pittman, RB, Tampa Bay

156. Sam Caplan Jason Elam, K, Denver

Round 14

No. Owner Selection

157. Sam Caplan Charlie Frye, QB, Cleveland

158. Adam Caplan Samie Parker, WR, Kansas City

159. Michael Fabiano Vernand Morency, RB, Houston

160. Mike Harmon Joey Galloway, WR, Tampa Bay*

161. John Hansen Bengals DST

162. Greg Ambrosius David Akers, K, Philadelphia

163. Jeff Erickson Giants DST

164. Rick Wolf Matt Jones, WR, Jacksonville*

165. William Del Pilar Broncos DST

166. Dave Richard Shayne Graham, K, Cincinnati

167. James Quintong Jay Feely, K, N.Y. Giants

168. Matt Pitzer Seahawks DST

Round 15

No. Owner Selection

169. Matt Pitzer Matt Stover, K, Baltimore

170. James Quintong L.J. Smith, TE, Philadelphia*

171. Dave Richard Joe Jurevicius, WR, Cleveland*

172. William Del Pilar Lawrence Tynes, K, Kansas City

173. Rick Wolf Michael Bennett, RB, New Orleans*

174. Jeff Erickson Jeff Wilkins, K, St. Louis

175. Greg Ambrosius Ravens DST

176. John Hansen Lee Suggs, RB, Cleveland

177. Mike Harmon Kurt Warner, QB, Arizona*

178. Michael Fabiano Nate Kaeding, K, San Diego

179. Adam Caplan Eagles DST

180. Sam Caplan Eli Manning, QB, N.Y. Giants*

Round 16

No. Owner Selection

181. Sam Caplan Chris Cooley, TE, Washington*

182. Adam Caplan Josh Brown, K, Seattle

183. Michael Fabiano Jaguars DST

184. Mike Harmon Neil Rackers, K, Arizona*

185. John Hansen Jerious Norwood, RB, Atlanta

186. Greg Ambrosius Cedric Houston, RB, N.Y. Jets

187. Jeff Erickson Mike Williams, WR, Detroit

188. Rick Wolf Samkon Gado, RB, Green Bay*

189. William Del Pilar Charles Rogers, WR, Detroit

190. Dave Richard Drew Bledsoe, QB, Dallas*

191. James Quintong Vince Young, QB, Tennessee

192. Matt Pitzer Jerramy Stevens, TE, Seattle*

 

[jdoggydogg]

did you read the rules of the league? (*) means keeper? I don't think much of cbs's analysts but why rip them. You are the one not paying attention

I read the rules, and this draft is a joke. The fact that you are defending these "experts" leads me to believe you think more of them than you are admitting.

 

[acaplan]

did you read the rules of the league?  (*) means keeper?  I don't think much of cbs's analysts but why rip them.  You are the one not paying attention

I read the rules, and this draft is a joke. The fact that you are defending these "experts" leads me to believe you think more of them than you are admitting.

hey i don't even care enough to read any of there drafts. even though i am a commish. i was looking forward to another bunch of rediculous amatuerish picks.however you rip them for drafting edge before LT2. ah um, that is NOT what happened. That was a KEEPER. after that i just ignored the rest of what you wrote because if you couldn't get that then why keep reading.

your seemingly purposeful misrepresenting of the facts leads me to believe that this is just another rip CBS. which is fine with me but no matter how much you rip'em i'm still not joining RTS or whoever you like better

FYI: League started last year, we were able to keep 5 players so players like LT, Carnell Williams etc. were retained.

 

[acaplan]

did you read the rules of the league?  (*) means keeper?  I don't think much of cbs's analysts but why rip them.  You are the one not paying attention

I read the rules, and this draft is a joke. The fact that you are defending these "experts" leads me to believe you think more of them than you are admitting.

hey i don't even care enough to read any of there drafts. even though i am a commish. i was looking forward to another bunch of rediculous amatuerish picks.however you rip them for drafting edge before LT2. ah um, that is NOT what happened. That was a KEEPER. after that i just ignored the rest of what you wrote because if you couldn't get that then why keep reading.

your seemingly purposeful misrepresenting of the facts leads me to believe that this is just another rip CBS. which is fine with me but no matter how much you rip'em i'm still not joining RTS or whoever you like better

FYI: League started last year, we were able to keep 5 players so players like LT, Carnell Williams etc. were retained. What happened was they included their draft position from last year in the writeup that you saw. The first round in this year's draft was actually only three players (the ones without the asterisk).

 

[jdoggydogg]

your seemingly purposeful misrepresenting of the facts leads me to believe that this is just another rip CBS. which is fine with me but no matter how much you rip'em i'm still not joining RTS or whoever you like better

I have no idea what that even means.

 

[jdoggydogg]

FYI: League started last year, we were able to keep 5 players so players like LT, Carnell Williams etc. were retained.

This is really Caplan? Cool. I dig your radio spots.

 

[jdoggydogg]

Well then, that explains the entire topic. you have no idea. i'm sorry is started reading it

So am I.