ConstruxBoy
Kate's Daddy
Finally done.
Results:
QB
Link to the original thread: http://forums.footballguys.com/forum/index...;hl=construxboy
The board consensus ranking for the top 20 QBs was:
1 P Manning2 C Palmer3 T Brady4 M Hasselbeck5 D McNabb6 E Manning7 D Culpepper8 M Bulger9 J Delhomme10 J Plummer11 M Vick12 D Bledsoe13 A Brooks14 T Green15 B Favre16 K Warner17 C Simms18 S McNair19 J Kitna20 P RiversThe final top 40 rankings for QBs was:
The winner, with an amazingly low score of 165, was BoltBacker, with this ranking:
The board consensus was 224, so BoltBacker wins $10. 16 members beat the board consensus, so basically, everyone with a pulse. For fun, I included the last preseason ranking of 6 Staff members (David and Joe, Pasquino, Rudnicki, Tremblay, Wood and Yudkin). I also included the FBG Staff Average of all staff members as of September 10th. The FBG Average was a very good 202 points. 7 people beat this score among message board members. Congratulations to Maurile Tremblay, who had the staff low score of 197.
Stats:
Top 5 scorers:
1) BoltBacker - 165
2) The Man with No Name - 188
3) nshelat1 - 192
4) Chaos Commish - 196
5) Comfortably Numb - 197
Average Score - 215
Bottom 5 Scores:
232
232
234
236
254 - Guess who? That Kerry Collins at 9 pick was just a teeny bit off.
Thoughts:
Culpepper, Brooks and Simms all finished outside the top 40 and were on a lot of lists. Bledsoe, Green and Warner were also on lots of lists and finished just inside the top 40. Brees and Kitna were the big achievers.
Nailed it:
Players outside the top 5 who were ranked correctly
BoltBacker 6 M VickLott's Fingertip 6 M Vicknshelat1 6 M VickDirty Weasel 7 T BradyHusker Power 7 T BradyThe Man with No Name 7 T Bradyjurb26 9 E Manningtarheel1unc 9 E Manningabrecher 10 P RiversChaos Commish 10 P RiversChaos Commish 11 B Roethlisbergerabrecher 19 S McNairChaos Commish 19 S McNairFBG Average 19 S McNairModog814 19 S McNairSpecial congrats to Chaos Commish, who nailed the most ranks at 5 (PManning, Palmer, Rivers, Roethlisberger and McNair), but left off a ranking for #16 in a cut and paste incident gone horribly wrong. I had to give him a 20 for that rank, otherwise he could have challenged for 2nd place. RB
Link to the original thread: http://forums.footballguys.com/forum/index...;hl=construxboy
The board consensus ranking for the top 20 RBs was:
1 L Tomlinson2 L Johnson3 S Alexander4 R Johnson5 T Barber6 R Brown7 C Williams8 S Jackson9 C Portis10 E James11 L Jordan12 W McGahee13 W Parker14 K Jones15 W Dunn16 B Westbrook17 C Taylor18 J Lewis19 R Bush20 R DroughnsThe final top 40 ranking for RBs was:
The winner with a low difference score of 181 was Beto, with this ranking:
The Board Consensus score was 193, so Beto will be getting $10. A total of 6 board members beat the Board Consensus. For fun, I included the last preseason ranking of 6 Staff members (David and Joe, Pasquino, Rudnicki, Tremblay, Wood and Yudkin). I also included the FBG Staff Average of all staff members as of September 10th. The FBG Average was an outstanding 186 points. Only Beto beat this score among message board members. Congratulations to Jason Wood, who matched Beto's 181 score and David Yudkin, who scored 185. They, along with Beto, are the only people to beat the FBG Staff Average.
Stats:
Top 5 Scorers
1) Beto - 181
2) BoltBacker - 188
3) by the sea wannabe - 189
4) Lott's Fingertip - 190
5) djjosee - 191
Average Score - 205
Bottom 5 Scores
230
233
250
254
255
Thoughts:
Everyone had the maximum 20 points for players who busted this year, such as Shaun Alexander, Cadillac Williams, LaMont Jordan and Clinton Portis. Ronnie Brown and Willis McGahee also had some high point totals.
A lot of the older RBs were neglected in the rankings, with Duece McAllister, Ahman Green, Fred Taylor and Corey Dillon all finishing in the top 20 but not listed on most entries.
Nailed it:
Players outside the Top 5 who were ranked correctly
Rudnicki 13 C TaylorBeto 16 J LewisJoffer 16 J LewisThe Mechanic 16 J LewisDisco Stu 17 R BushH.K. 17 R BushPasquino 17 R BushTremblay 17 R Bushthecardiackid 20 E JamesA special congrats to tarheel1unc, the only entry to hit the top 3 in order (Tomlinson, Johnson, Jackson). Finally, I usually won't mention the worst entry but in this case since it's my good buddy H.K. and I'm still spending money trying to fix up this derelict house he sold me, I will use his poor showing to make a point about this contest.
Here is his entry:
1 C Taylor2 S Alexander3 C Portis4 L Johnson5 R Johnson6 R Brown7 L Tomlinson8 W Dunn9 E James10 D Rhodes11 C Williams12 F Gore13 T Jones14 J Jones15 S Jackson16 L Maroney17 R Bush18 L Jordan19 M Bell20 W LundyThis entry had the highest score, a 255. However, this high score and this contest in general does not actually measure fantasy football knowledge to a great degree. H.K. had the highest ranking of Chester Taylor (duh), but was one of 5 people to rank him as high as his 13 rank. Only 4 people ranked Cadillac Williams lower than he did, but Caddy's 39 rank still cost everyone 20 points. He tied with BassNBrew for the lowest ranking of LaMont Jordan, but Jordan's finish outside the top 40 still cost everyone 20 points. So the way this contest was run lead to some poor scores for him, but he was accurately higher on Taylor and lower on Caddy and Jordan than most people. This is more important when it comes to drafting a team in a fantasy football league. And I can confirm that because he beat BassNBrew, myself and 9 other people from this board to win our league for the 2nd straight year.
WR
Link to the original thread: http://forums.footballguys.com/forum/index...;hl=construxboy
The board consensus ranking for the top 20 WRs was:
1 T Holt2 C Johnson3 L Fitzgerald4 R Moss5 A Boldin6 C Chambers7 R Wayne8 S Smith9 M Harrison10 T Owens11 D Driver12 R Williams13 S Moss14 H Ward15 P Burress16 D Mason17 J Walker18 L Evans19 T Houshmandzadeh20 D JacksonThe final top 40 rankings for WRs are:
The winner with a low score of 151 was Lott's Fingertip with this ranking:
The Board Consensus score was 184, so Lott's Fingertip will be getting $10. A total of 10 board members beat the Board Consensus. For fun, I included the last preseason ranking of 6 Staff members (David and Joe, Pasquino, Rudnicki, Tremblay, Wood and Yudkin). I also included the FBG Staff Average of all staff members as of September 10th. The FBG Average was a very good 177 points. 8 message board members beat this score. Congratulations to Jason Wood, who was 3rd overall with a 161 score and David and Joe, who scored 167, good for 4th place overall.
Stats:
Top 5 Scorers
1) Lott's Fingertip - 151
2) Pictus Cat - 156
3) Joffer - 169
4) Comfortably Numb - 171
5) jurb26 - 173
Average Score - 186
Bottom 5 Scores
203
204
213
228
238
Thoughts:
Everyone had the maximum 20 points for players who busted this year, such as Randy Moss, Chris Chambers, Derrick Mason and Joe Horn. Larry Fitzgerald also had some high point totals.
The WR position seems to be the easiest to rank so far.
Nailed it:
Players outside the Top 5 who were ranked correctly
Yudkin 6 D DriverBoard Consensus 8 S SmithBoltBacker 8 S SmithHusker Power 10 R Williamsjerseyh8r 10 R Williamsjurb26 10 R WilliamsPictus Cat 12 P BurressWood 12 P BurressPictus Cat 13 D Jacksontarheel1unc 13 D Jacksontarheel1unc 16 L ColesFBG Average 18 A Johnsonjerseyh8r 18 A JohnsonRudnicki 18 A JohnsonChaos Commish 20 T GlennTE
Link to the original thread: http://forums.footballguys.com/forum/index...;hl=construxboy
The board consensus ranking for the top 20 TEs was:
1 A Gates2 J Shockey3 T Heap4 T Gonzalez5 B Watson6 A Crumpler7 R McMichael8 C Cooley9 L Smith10 J Witten11 B Troupe12 K Winslow13 H Miller14 Da Clark15 J Wiggins16 V Davis17 A Smith18 T Scheffler19 J Stevens20 C AndersonThe final top 40 ranking for TEs are:
The winner with a low score of 87(!) was Disco Stu with this ranking:
The Board Consensus score was 83, so Lott's Fingertip will only be getting $5. This is the first position in which no board member beat the consensus. For fun, I included the last preseason ranking of 6 Staff members (David and Joe, Pasquino, Rudnicki, Tremblay, Wood and Yudkin). I also included the FBG Staff Average of all staff members as of September 10th. The FBG Average was a decent 119 points. 8 message board members beat this score. Congratulations to David and Joe, who were 2nd overall with a 86 score and Maurile Tremblay, who scored 98, good for 5th place overall.
Stats:
Top 5 Scorers
1) Disco Stu - 87
2) abrecher - 88
3) cws3030 - 100
4) Chaos Commish - 105
5) jersey h8ter - 113
Average Score - 122
Bottom 5 Scores
137
140
143
161
192 - H.K. is either really bad at this or tanking on purpose.
Thoughts:
Everyone had the maximum 20 points for Ben Troupe who busted this year. The difference between the scores usually came down to who ranked other players that busted this year, like Bubba Franks, Mercedes Lewis or Leonard Pope.
The TE position was even easier than the WR position to rank because there were so few big name busts or unexpected stars.
Special note for Chaos Commish, who managed to come in 4th even though his 17th ranked TE was someone called Chris Bird. I think he meant Chris Baker, who actually finished 18th, but I had to give him the full 20 points.
Nailed it:
Players outside the Top 5 who were ranked correctly
Pasquino 7 J Shockeyabrecher 9 L SmithBoard Consensus 9 L SmithAussie Cowboy 10 B WatsonJoeDoe 10 B WatsonYudkin 11 R McMichael5Rings 12 J WittenBoltBacker 12 J WittenChaos Commish 12 J WittenBeto 13 H MillerBoard Consensus 13 H MillerTremblay 13 H MillerBoltBacker 15 Da ClarkDisco Stu 15 Da Clarkjurb26 15 Da ClarkRudnicki 15 Da ClarkTitans Fan 15 Da Clarkcws3030 20 T SchefflerJoeDoe 20 T SchefflerPK
Link to the original thread: http://forums.footballguys.com/forum/index...;hl=construxboy
The board consensus ranking for the top 20 PKs was:
1 J Elam2 D Akers3 J Kasay4 S Graham5 N Rackers6 J Brown7 J Feely8 M Stover9 A Vinatieri10 J Reed11 L Tynes12 J Scobee13 N Kaeding14 M Koenen15 O Mare16 J Wilkins17 R Longwell18 J Hanson19 S Janikowski20 M VanderjagtThe final top 36 ranking for PKs are:
The winner with a low score of 148 was ComfortablyNumb with this ranking:
The Board Consensus score was a pathetic 194, so ComfortablyNumb will be getting $10. For fun, I included the last preseason ranking of 6 Staff members (David and Joe, Pasquino, Rudnicki, Tremblay, Wood and Mike Herman). I also included the FBG Staff Average of all staff members as of September 10th. The FBG Average was a poor 190 points. 8 message board members beat this score. Congratulations to David and Joe, who were the best FBG at 5th overall with a 171 score.
Stats:
Top 5 Scorers
1) ComfortablyNumb - 148
2) BoltBacker - 163
3) Lott's Fingertip - 166
4) Aussie Cowboy - 170
5) BassNBrew - 172
Average Score - 184
Bottom 5 Scores
193
194
199
219
238 - H.K. for reasons that will be explained later.
Thoughts:
Most people had the maximum 20 points for Michael Koenen who busted this year. Other poor finishers were David Akers, John Kasay, Mike Vanderjagt and SeaBass.
The PK position was very hard to rank this season with the out of nowhere guys like Gould and the older PKs who were high performers, like Hanson, Nedney and Carney.
Special note for Lott's Fingertip, who nailed 3 PKs: Vinatieri, Gostkowski and Lindell.
Nailed it:
Players outside the Top 5 who were ranked correctly
JoeDoe 10 J CarneyComfortablyNumb 12 A VinatieriLott's Fingertip 12 A VinatieriRudnicki 12 A VinatieriWood 12 A VinatieriBassNBrew 15 J FeelyHerman 15 J FeelyBoltBacker 16 L TynesComfortablyNumb 18 S GostkowskiDavid and Joe 18 S GostkowskiLott's Fingertip 18 S GostkowskiWood 18 S GostkowskiLott's Fingertip 19 R LindellDEFLink to the original thread: http://forums.footballguys.com/forum/index...;hl=Construxboy
The board consensus ranking for the top 20 DEFs was:
1 CAR2 CHI3 PIT4 BAL5 TB6 SEA7 WAS8 MIA9 JAC10 ATL11 IND12 DAL13 NYG14 CIN15 PHI16 MIN17 NE18 ARI19 DEN20 SDThe final top 32 ranking for DEFs are:
The winner with a low score of 150 was BoltBacker with this ranking:
The Board Consensus score was 186, so Boltbacker will be getting $10, for the second time. For fun, I included the last preseason ranking of 6 Staff members (David and Joe, Bloom, Rudnicki, Tremblay, Wood and Bramel). I also included the FBG Staff Average of all staff members as of September 10th. The FBG Average was 185 points, only 1 point better than the Board Consensus. 8 message board members beat this score. Congratulations to Bloom, who wasthe best FBG at 2nd overall with a 151 score.
Stats:
Top 5 Scorers
1) BoltBacker - 150
2) Husker Power - 164
3) jurb26 - 167
4) Lott's Fingertip - 169
5T) BassNBrew - 171
5T) H.K. - 171 - Yes, even H.K. couldn't purposefully mess up this position.
Average Score - 178
Bottom 5 Scores
186
186
191
207
214
Thoughts:
IND, TB and WAS just killed folks in this one, as they finished the year 30-32. Most people had at least 2 of them, if not all 3, in their top 10.
The DEF position was very hard to rank this season with those 3 defenses going belly up and some unheralded defenses like SD, GB and MIN doing so well.
Special note for Lott's Fingertip and BoltBacker, who both nailed 2 DEFs. Apparently the Bears at 2 were the easiest to rank with 7 different folks getting them.
Nailed it:
Players outside the Top 5 who were ranked correctly
Results:
QB
Link to the original thread: http://forums.footballguys.com/forum/index...;hl=construxboy
The board consensus ranking for the top 20 QBs was:
1 P Manning2 C Palmer3 T Brady4 M Hasselbeck5 D McNabb6 E Manning7 D Culpepper8 M Bulger9 J Delhomme10 J Plummer11 M Vick12 D Bledsoe13 A Brooks14 T Green15 B Favre16 K Warner17 C Simms18 S McNair19 J Kitna20 P RiversThe final top 40 rankings for QBs was:
Code:
1 P Manning2 D Brees3 C Palmer4 J Kitna5 M Bulger6 M Vick7 T Brady8 B Favre9 E Manning10 P Rivers11 B Roethlisberger12 R Grossman13 J Losman14 C Pennington15 V Young16 D McNabb17 T Romo18 A Smith19 S McNair20 J Delhomme21 M Hasselbeck22 D Carr23 C Frye24 M Leinart25 B Johnson26 J Plummer27 J Harrington28 D Garrard29 D Huard30 B Gradkowski31 M Brunell32 J Campbell33 J Garcia34 B Leftwich35 D Bledsoe36 T Green37 S Wallace38 J Cutler39 K Warner40 A Walter
Code:
1 P Manning2 C Palmer3 D McNabb4 D Culpepper5 T Brady6 M Vick7 M Bulger8 E Manning9 M Hasselbeck10 T Green11 J Delhomme12 B Favre13 J Plummer14 S McNair15 C Simms16 P Rivers17 D Brees18 B Leftwich19 C Frye20 A SmithStats:
Top 5 scorers:
1) BoltBacker - 165
2) The Man with No Name - 188
3) nshelat1 - 192
4) Chaos Commish - 196
5) Comfortably Numb - 197
Average Score - 215
Bottom 5 Scores:
232
232
234
236
254 - Guess who? That Kerry Collins at 9 pick was just a teeny bit off.
Thoughts:
Culpepper, Brooks and Simms all finished outside the top 40 and were on a lot of lists. Bledsoe, Green and Warner were also on lots of lists and finished just inside the top 40. Brees and Kitna were the big achievers.
Nailed it:
Players outside the top 5 who were ranked correctly
BoltBacker 6 M VickLott's Fingertip 6 M Vicknshelat1 6 M VickDirty Weasel 7 T BradyHusker Power 7 T BradyThe Man with No Name 7 T Bradyjurb26 9 E Manningtarheel1unc 9 E Manningabrecher 10 P RiversChaos Commish 10 P RiversChaos Commish 11 B Roethlisbergerabrecher 19 S McNairChaos Commish 19 S McNairFBG Average 19 S McNairModog814 19 S McNairSpecial congrats to Chaos Commish, who nailed the most ranks at 5 (PManning, Palmer, Rivers, Roethlisberger and McNair), but left off a ranking for #16 in a cut and paste incident gone horribly wrong. I had to give him a 20 for that rank, otherwise he could have challenged for 2nd place. RB
Link to the original thread: http://forums.footballguys.com/forum/index...;hl=construxboy
The board consensus ranking for the top 20 RBs was:
1 L Tomlinson2 L Johnson3 S Alexander4 R Johnson5 T Barber6 R Brown7 C Williams8 S Jackson9 C Portis10 E James11 L Jordan12 W McGahee13 W Parker14 K Jones15 W Dunn16 B Westbrook17 C Taylor18 J Lewis19 R Bush20 R DroughnsThe final top 40 ranking for RBs was:
Code:
1 L Tomlinson2 L Johnson3 S Jackson4 F Gore5 W Parker6 B Westbrook7 T Barber8 M Jones-Drew9 R Johnson10 D McAllister11 L Betts12 J Addai13 C Taylor14 M Barber15 A Green16 J Lewis17 R Bush18 F Taylor19 C Dillon20 E James21 T Jones22 T Henry23 K Jones24 W Dunn25 R Brown26 W McGahee27 J Jones28 S Alexander29 L Maroney30 M Bell31 T Bell32 D Foster33 D Rhodes34 R Droughns35 L Washington36 C Portis37 B Jacobs38 C Benson39 C Williams40 R Dayne
Code:
1 L Tomlinson2 L Johnson3 S Alexander4 R Johnson5 T Barber6 C Williams7 E James8 W Parker9 C Portis10 W McGahee11 S Jackson12 L Jordan13 R Brown14 K Jones15 W Dunn16 J Lewis17 T Jones18 M Barber19 M Bell20 A GreenStats:
Top 5 Scorers
1) Beto - 181
2) BoltBacker - 188
3) by the sea wannabe - 189
4) Lott's Fingertip - 190
5) djjosee - 191
Average Score - 205
Bottom 5 Scores
230
233
250
254
255
Thoughts:
Everyone had the maximum 20 points for players who busted this year, such as Shaun Alexander, Cadillac Williams, LaMont Jordan and Clinton Portis. Ronnie Brown and Willis McGahee also had some high point totals.
A lot of the older RBs were neglected in the rankings, with Duece McAllister, Ahman Green, Fred Taylor and Corey Dillon all finishing in the top 20 but not listed on most entries.
Nailed it:
Players outside the Top 5 who were ranked correctly
Rudnicki 13 C TaylorBeto 16 J LewisJoffer 16 J LewisThe Mechanic 16 J LewisDisco Stu 17 R BushH.K. 17 R BushPasquino 17 R BushTremblay 17 R Bushthecardiackid 20 E JamesA special congrats to tarheel1unc, the only entry to hit the top 3 in order (Tomlinson, Johnson, Jackson). Finally, I usually won't mention the worst entry but in this case since it's my good buddy H.K. and I'm still spending money trying to fix up this derelict house he sold me, I will use his poor showing to make a point about this contest.
Here is his entry:
1 C Taylor2 S Alexander3 C Portis4 L Johnson5 R Johnson6 R Brown7 L Tomlinson8 W Dunn9 E James10 D Rhodes11 C Williams12 F Gore13 T Jones14 J Jones15 S Jackson16 L Maroney17 R Bush18 L Jordan19 M Bell20 W LundyThis entry had the highest score, a 255. However, this high score and this contest in general does not actually measure fantasy football knowledge to a great degree. H.K. had the highest ranking of Chester Taylor (duh), but was one of 5 people to rank him as high as his 13 rank. Only 4 people ranked Cadillac Williams lower than he did, but Caddy's 39 rank still cost everyone 20 points. He tied with BassNBrew for the lowest ranking of LaMont Jordan, but Jordan's finish outside the top 40 still cost everyone 20 points. So the way this contest was run lead to some poor scores for him, but he was accurately higher on Taylor and lower on Caddy and Jordan than most people. This is more important when it comes to drafting a team in a fantasy football league. And I can confirm that because he beat BassNBrew, myself and 9 other people from this board to win our league for the 2nd straight year.
WR
Link to the original thread: http://forums.footballguys.com/forum/index...;hl=construxboy
The board consensus ranking for the top 20 WRs was:
1 T Holt2 C Johnson3 L Fitzgerald4 R Moss5 A Boldin6 C Chambers7 R Wayne8 S Smith9 M Harrison10 T Owens11 D Driver12 R Williams13 S Moss14 H Ward15 P Burress16 D Mason17 J Walker18 L Evans19 T Houshmandzadeh20 D JacksonThe final top 40 rankings for WRs are:
Code:
1 M Harrison2 T Owens3 R Wayne4 C Johnson5 T Holt6 D Driver7 L Evans8 S Smith9 J Walker10 R Williams11 T Houshmandzadeh12 P Burress13 D Jackson14 M Colston15 J Galloway16 L Coles17 A Boldin18 A Johnson19 M Furrey20 T Glenn21 R Brown22 H Ward23 J Cotchery24 L Fitzgerald25 I Bruce26 B Edwards27 S Moss28 Ma Clayton29 E Kennison30 M Muhammad31 C Henry32 B Berrian33 M Booker34 D Henderson35 K Johnson36 D Stallworth37 C Chambers38 R Caldwell39 D Branch40 Bry Johnson
Code:
1 R Moss2 T Holt3 L Fitzgerald4 T Owens5 C Johnson6 C Chambers7 M Harrison8 R Williams9 R Wayne10 A Boldin11 P Burress12 J Walker13 D Driver14 S Smith15 L Evans16 T Houshmandzadeh17 A Johnson18 J Horn19 D Jackson20 S MossStats:
Top 5 Scorers
1) Lott's Fingertip - 151
2) Pictus Cat - 156
3) Joffer - 169
4) Comfortably Numb - 171
5) jurb26 - 173
Average Score - 186
Bottom 5 Scores
203
204
213
228
238
Thoughts:
Everyone had the maximum 20 points for players who busted this year, such as Randy Moss, Chris Chambers, Derrick Mason and Joe Horn. Larry Fitzgerald also had some high point totals.
The WR position seems to be the easiest to rank so far.
Nailed it:
Players outside the Top 5 who were ranked correctly
Yudkin 6 D DriverBoard Consensus 8 S SmithBoltBacker 8 S SmithHusker Power 10 R Williamsjerseyh8r 10 R Williamsjurb26 10 R WilliamsPictus Cat 12 P BurressWood 12 P BurressPictus Cat 13 D Jacksontarheel1unc 13 D Jacksontarheel1unc 16 L ColesFBG Average 18 A Johnsonjerseyh8r 18 A JohnsonRudnicki 18 A JohnsonChaos Commish 20 T GlennTE
Link to the original thread: http://forums.footballguys.com/forum/index...;hl=construxboy
The board consensus ranking for the top 20 TEs was:
1 A Gates2 J Shockey3 T Heap4 T Gonzalez5 B Watson6 A Crumpler7 R McMichael8 C Cooley9 L Smith10 J Witten11 B Troupe12 K Winslow13 H Miller14 Da Clark15 J Wiggins16 V Davis17 A Smith18 T Scheffler19 J Stevens20 C AndersonThe final top 40 ranking for TEs are:
Code:
1 A Gates2 A Crumpler3 T Gonzalez4 T Heap5 C Cooley6 K Winslow7 J Shockey8 Des Clark9 LJ Smith10 B Watson11 R McMichael12 J Witten13 H Miller14 O Daniels15 Dal Clark16 B Scaife17 D Campbell18 C Baker19 G Wrightster20 T Scheffler21 J Stevens22 V Davis23 J Wiggins24 A Smith25 E Johnson26 C Anderson27 R Royal28 B Utecht29 S Heiden30 D Wilcox31 D Graham32 M Schobel33 B Fletcher34 D Martin35 R Kelly36 K Wilson37 R Williams38 J Klopfenstein39 S Alexander40 B Manumaleuna
Code:
1 A Gates2 T Heap3 J Shockey4 B Watson5 A Crumpler6 T Gonzalez7 R McMichael8 L Smith9 C Cooley10 J Witten11 K Winslow12 H Miller13 B Troupe14 J Wiggins15 Da Clark16 C Anderson17 T Scheffler18 J Stevens19 A Smith20 V DavisStats:
Top 5 Scorers
1) Disco Stu - 87
2) abrecher - 88
3) cws3030 - 100
4) Chaos Commish - 105
5) jersey h8ter - 113
Average Score - 122
Bottom 5 Scores
137
140
143
161
192 - H.K. is either really bad at this or tanking on purpose.
Thoughts:
Everyone had the maximum 20 points for Ben Troupe who busted this year. The difference between the scores usually came down to who ranked other players that busted this year, like Bubba Franks, Mercedes Lewis or Leonard Pope.
The TE position was even easier than the WR position to rank because there were so few big name busts or unexpected stars.
Special note for Chaos Commish, who managed to come in 4th even though his 17th ranked TE was someone called Chris Bird. I think he meant Chris Baker, who actually finished 18th, but I had to give him the full 20 points.
Nailed it:
Players outside the Top 5 who were ranked correctly
Pasquino 7 J Shockeyabrecher 9 L SmithBoard Consensus 9 L SmithAussie Cowboy 10 B WatsonJoeDoe 10 B WatsonYudkin 11 R McMichael5Rings 12 J WittenBoltBacker 12 J WittenChaos Commish 12 J WittenBeto 13 H MillerBoard Consensus 13 H MillerTremblay 13 H MillerBoltBacker 15 Da ClarkDisco Stu 15 Da Clarkjurb26 15 Da ClarkRudnicki 15 Da ClarkTitans Fan 15 Da Clarkcws3030 20 T SchefflerJoeDoe 20 T SchefflerPK
Link to the original thread: http://forums.footballguys.com/forum/index...;hl=construxboy
The board consensus ranking for the top 20 PKs was:
1 J Elam2 D Akers3 J Kasay4 S Graham5 N Rackers6 J Brown7 J Feely8 M Stover9 A Vinatieri10 J Reed11 L Tynes12 J Scobee13 N Kaeding14 M Koenen15 O Mare16 J Wilkins17 R Longwell18 J Hanson19 S Janikowski20 M VanderjagtThe final top 36 ranking for PKs are:
Code:
1 R Gould2 N Kaeding3 J Wilkins4 M Stover5 J Scobee6 J Hanson7 J Nedney8 N Rackers9 J Elam10 J Carney11 S Graham12 A Vinatieri 13 J Brown14 D Rayner15 J Feely16 L Tynes17 M Nugent18 S Gostkowski19 R Lindell20 D Akers21 J Reed22 J Kasay23 O Mare24 R Bironas25 R Longwell26 P Dawson27 M Andersen28 K Brown29 M Bryant30 M Vanderjagt31 S Janikowski32 M Gramatica33 S Suisham34 J Hall35 N Novak36 M Koenen
Code:
1 M Stover2 J Reed3 J Feely4 J Kasay5 D Akers6 J Elam7 N Rackers8 J Scobee9 S Graham10 J Brown11 J Wilkins12 A Vinatieri13 N Kaeding14 J Hanson15 L Tynes16 M Bryant17 M Koenen18 S Gostkowski19 R Longwell20 O MareStats:
Top 5 Scorers
1) ComfortablyNumb - 148
2) BoltBacker - 163
3) Lott's Fingertip - 166
4) Aussie Cowboy - 170
5) BassNBrew - 172
Average Score - 184
Bottom 5 Scores
193
194
199
219
238 - H.K. for reasons that will be explained later.
Thoughts:
Most people had the maximum 20 points for Michael Koenen who busted this year. Other poor finishers were David Akers, John Kasay, Mike Vanderjagt and SeaBass.
The PK position was very hard to rank this season with the out of nowhere guys like Gould and the older PKs who were high performers, like Hanson, Nedney and Carney.
Special note for Lott's Fingertip, who nailed 3 PKs: Vinatieri, Gostkowski and Lindell.
Nailed it:
Players outside the Top 5 who were ranked correctly
JoeDoe 10 J CarneyComfortablyNumb 12 A VinatieriLott's Fingertip 12 A VinatieriRudnicki 12 A VinatieriWood 12 A VinatieriBassNBrew 15 J FeelyHerman 15 J FeelyBoltBacker 16 L TynesComfortablyNumb 18 S GostkowskiDavid and Joe 18 S GostkowskiLott's Fingertip 18 S GostkowskiWood 18 S GostkowskiLott's Fingertip 19 R LindellDEFLink to the original thread: http://forums.footballguys.com/forum/index...;hl=Construxboy
The board consensus ranking for the top 20 DEFs was:
1 CAR2 CHI3 PIT4 BAL5 TB6 SEA7 WAS8 MIA9 JAC10 ATL11 IND12 DAL13 NYG14 CIN15 PHI16 MIN17 NE18 ARI19 DEN20 SDThe final top 32 ranking for DEFs are:
Code:
1 BAL2 CHI3 SD4 GB5 MIN6 MIA7 NE8 PHI9 DAL10 PIT11 TEN12 ARI13 JAC14 DEN15 BUF16 SEA17 KC18 ATL19 CAR20 OAK21 NYG22 CIN23 STL24 CLE25 NYJ26 NO27 SF28 HOU29 DET30 IND31 TB32 WAS
Code:
1 CAR2 CHI3 BAL4 TB5 PHI6 JAC7 DAL8 ATL9 MIA10 PIT11 CIN12 NE13 WAS14 BUF15 NYG16 CLE17 DET18 SD19 DEN20 STLStats:
Top 5 Scorers
1) BoltBacker - 150
2) Husker Power - 164
3) jurb26 - 167
4) Lott's Fingertip - 169
5T) BassNBrew - 171
5T) H.K. - 171 - Yes, even H.K. couldn't purposefully mess up this position.
Average Score - 178
Bottom 5 Scores
186
186
191
207
214
Thoughts:
IND, TB and WAS just killed folks in this one, as they finished the year 30-32. Most people had at least 2 of them, if not all 3, in their top 10.
The DEF position was very hard to rank this season with those 3 defenses going belly up and some unheralded defenses like SD, GB and MIN doing so well.
Special note for Lott's Fingertip and BoltBacker, who both nailed 2 DEFs. Apparently the Bears at 2 were the easiest to rank with 7 different folks getting them.
Nailed it:
Players outside the Top 5 who were ranked correctly
Code:
Bramel 9 DALFBG Average 9 DALBoltBacker 10 PITH.K. 11 TENabrecher 13 JACLott's Fingertip 13 JACRudnicki 13 JAC
Last edited by a moderator:
Construx is loaded, don't let anyone tell you differently!
Construx is loaded, don't let anyone tell you differently!
Sad but true. Note this exchange in "Bull Durham": Crash Davis: I never told him to stay out of your bed. Annie Savoy: Yes you did. Crash Davis: I told him that a player on a streak has to respect the streak. Annie Savoy: Oh fine. Crash Davis: You know why? Because they don't - -they don't happen very often. Annie Savoy: Right. Crash Davis: If you believe you're playing well because you're getting laid, or because you're not getting laid, or because you wear women's underwear, then you ARE! And you should know that!
