This is a sample guest message. Register a free account today to become a member! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!
huh? Deuce has another ACL and will be 30 next year? These things take time to recover from... Deuce isn't worth anything. Period. There is nothing to debate... this is a young man's league and I would much rather invest the roster spot in a player with long term upside. Sorry, just being factual.
Well it took him 9 months last time. He got hurt week 4 and had a solid year last season..Remember? That was less than a season from his first one. I know he will be 2 years older BUT its not out of the question like you make it sound. In a dynasty he has value..He COULD be a solid #2 next season...It COULD happen
I'll debate it.
Deuce, unlike most of these young guys, has shown a history of success in this league and has also shown the ability and work ethic to recover from a seemingly catastrophic ACL injury.
If Edge of Favre came up with a season ending and possibly career ending injury then maybe your perspective would be different.No, there is nothing to debate.I'll debate it.Deuce, unlike most of these young guys, has shown a history of success in this league and has also shown the ability and work ethic to recover from a seemingly catastrophic ACL injury.
His skill as a runner, receiver and pass blocker is a commodity that many NFL team would love to have. Those that lack an established RB would love to take a shot at him next year and I can see him running in GB or in Houston next year or perhaps in a committee with someone else.
I would be happy, in a dynasty league, to take my chances with him on the end of my bench or on my IR list over most of the "young-never-will-bes" on the waiver wire right now
Actually, it does look like there is something to debate here.
Oh and by the way, if this is only "a young man's league" would you give me Edge James for Selvin Young or perhaps Alex Smith for Brett Farve?
Unless you're talking alone here you're having a debate.If Edge of Favre came up with a season ending and possibly career ending injury then maybe your perspective would be different.No, there is nothing to debate.I'll debate it.
His skill as a runner, receiver and pass blocker is a commodity that many NFL team would love to have. Those that lack an established RB would love to take a shot at him next year and I can see him running in GB or in Houston next year or perhaps in a committee with someone else.
I would be happy, in a dynasty league, to take my chances with him on the end of my bench or on my IR list over most of the "young-never-will-bes" on the waiver wire right now
Actually, it does look like there is something to debate here.
Oh and by the way, if this is only "a young man's league" would you give me Edge James for Selvin Young or perhaps Alex Smith for Brett Farve?
Are you tlaking alone? No, so there's a debate going on here.
If you think it's wise to hold an aging RB on your roster while he recovers from another ACL... that is your problem. But, I won't debate it.
Its opportunity cost. C'mon guys be creative... you can't find anything better to do with that roster spot?
Yes, those are facts. Deuce will be 30. Deuce tore his ACL (again). ACL's can take some time to recover from.Not sure what you're laughing about... Oh, that's right... you're the guy with Barry Sanders still stashed away in a dynasty.
Well... you're quoting me at the same time you're modifying my quote... so I guess you're debating with yourself masterfully. I believe that's master-bating.Unless you're talking alone here you're having a debate.If Edge of Favre came up with a season ending and possibly career ending injury then maybe your perspective would be different.No, there is nothing to debate.I'll debate it.
His skill as a runner, receiver and pass blocker is a commodity that many NFL team would love to have. Those that lack an established RB would love to take a shot at him next year and I can see him running in GB or in Houston next year or perhaps in a committee with someone else.
I would be happy, in a dynasty league, to take my chances with him on the end of my bench or on my IR list over most of the "young-never-will-bes" on the waiver wire right now
Actually, it does look like there is something to debate here.
Oh and by the way, if this is only "a young man's league" would you give me Edge James for Selvin Young or perhaps Alex Smith for Brett Farve?
Are you tlaking alone? No, so there's a debate going on here.
If you think it's wise to hold an aging RB on your roster while he recovers from another ACL... that is your problem. But, I won't debate it.
Its opportunity cost. C'mon guys be creative... you can't find anything better to do with that roster spot?
Oh no, you outYes, those are facts. Deuce will be 30. Deuce tore his ACL (again). ACL's can take some time to recover from.Not sure what you're laughing about... Oh, that's right... you're the guy with Barry Sanders still stashed away in a dynasty.
me.
These are not facts, sorry. An IN before you make a point with more
than me.
Perhaps you don't understand what "debate" means, for we are currently having a discussion presenting opposing viewpoints therefore, you are currently having a debate.If Edge of Favre came up with a season ending and possibly career ending injury then maybe your perspective would be different.No, there is nothing to debate.I'll debate it.
His skill as a runner, receiver and pass blocker is a commodity that many NFL team would love to have. Those that lack an established RB would love to take a shot at him next year and I can see him running in GB or in Houston next year or perhaps in a committee with someone else.
I would be happy, in a dynasty league, to take my chances with him on the end of my bench or on my IR list over most of the "young-never-will-bes" on the waiver wire right now
Actually, it does look like there is something to debate here.
Oh and by the way, if this is only "a young man's league" would you give me Edge James for Selvin Young or perhaps Alex Smith for Brett Farve?
If you think it's wise to hold an aging RB on your roster while he recovers from another ACL... that is your problem. But, I won't debate it.
Its opportunity cost. C'mon guys be creative... you can't find anything better to do with that roster spot?
To digress back to the point of debate, I will take a shot a running back with Duece McAlllister over the likes of Selvin Young, Michael Robinson, Chris Henry or Kenton Kieth any day of the week.
Be my guest. Hold Deuce on your roster for 1+ years while he recovers (and gets another year older). Kiss anything positive you could do with that roster spot goodbye. Have a nice night.Do you get the point? The cost of holding Deuce is the roster spot? The NFL is loaded with young talent. Do something with it!Oh no, you outYes, those are facts. Deuce will be 30. Deuce tore his ACL (again). ACL's can take some time to recover from.Not sure what you're laughing about... Oh, that's right... you're the guy with Barry Sanders still stashed away in a dynasty.
These are not facts, sorry. An IN before you make a point with more
He's on my IR not taking the place of one other person.Be my guest. Hold Deuce on your roster for 1+ years while he recovers (and gets another year older). Kiss anything positive you could do with that roster spot goodbye. Have a nice night.Do you get the point? The cost of holding Deuce is the roster spot? The NFL is loaded with young talent. Do something with it!Oh no, you outYes, those are facts. Deuce will be 30. Deuce tore his ACL (again). ACL's can take some time to recover from.Not sure what you're laughing about... Oh, that's right... you're the guy with Barry Sanders still stashed away in a dynasty.
These are not facts, sorry. An IN before you make a point with more
I could care less who you don't like. Who do you like?I think all those guys outscore Deuce this season. Just my humble opinion.Perhaps you don't understand what "debate" means, for we are currently having a discussion presenting opposing viewpoints therefore, you are currently having a debate.If Edge of Favre came up with a season ending and possibly career ending injury then maybe your perspective would be different.No, there is nothing to debate.I'll debate it.
His skill as a runner, receiver and pass blocker is a commodity that many NFL team would love to have. Those that lack an established RB would love to take a shot at him next year and I can see him running in GB or in Houston next year or perhaps in a committee with someone else.
I would be happy, in a dynasty league, to take my chances with him on the end of my bench or on my IR list over most of the "young-never-will-bes" on the waiver wire right now
Actually, it does look like there is something to debate here.
Oh and by the way, if this is only "a young man's league" would you give me Edge James for Selvin Young or perhaps Alex Smith for Brett Farve?
If you think it's wise to hold an aging RB on your roster while he recovers from another ACL... that is your problem. But, I won't debate it.
Its opportunity cost. C'mon guys be creative... you can't find anything better to do with that roster spot?
I hate to be so confrontational and so blunt but you don't seem to favor discussion or opposing points of view, so if you don't care what others think, why the Hell are you posting on an internet message board instead of looking yourself in the mirror telling yourself how smart you are?Furthermore, it is not germane to the discussion who scores more points this year, the topic here, in accordance with the OP, is dynasty rankings, and answering the original question, I think McAllister's dynasty rankings are still on the radar.I could care less who you don't like. Who do you like?I think all those guys outscore Deuce this season. Just my humble opinion.Perhaps you don't understand what "debate" means, for we are currently having a discussion presenting opposing viewpoints therefore, you are currently having a debate.If Edge of Favre came up with a season ending and possibly career ending injury then maybe your perspective would be different.No, there is nothing to debate.I'll debate it.
His skill as a runner, receiver and pass blocker is a commodity that many NFL team would love to have. Those that lack an established RB would love to take a shot at him next year and I can see him running in GB or in Houston next year or perhaps in a committee with someone else.
I would be happy, in a dynasty league, to take my chances with him on the end of my bench or on my IR list over most of the "young-never-will-bes" on the waiver wire right now
Actually, it does look like there is something to debate here.
Oh and by the way, if this is only "a young man's league" would you give me Edge James for Selvin Young or perhaps Alex Smith for Brett Farve?
If you think it's wise to hold an aging RB on your roster while he recovers from another ACL... that is your problem. But, I won't debate it.
Its opportunity cost. C'mon guys be creative... you can't find anything better to do with that roster spot?
Sorry Norwood. Wide Right!You're missing the point entirely (blunt enough?), It is certainly relevant who scores more points THIS year, because (unless your team suxor) everyone is still trying to win NOW. Also, there are many up an coming players in the NFL. I could care less (as should you) who you dislike. They're not the point. Find someone you like.I hate to be so confrontational and so blunt but you don't seem to favor discussion or opposing points of view, so if you don't care what others think, why the Hell are you posting on an internet message board instead of looking yourself in the mirror telling yourself how smart you are?Furthermore, it is not germane to the discussion who scores more points this year, the topic here, in accordance with the OP, is dynasty rankings, and answering the original question, I think McAllister's dynasty rankings are still on the radar.I could care less who you don't like. Who do you like?I think all those guys outscore Deuce this season. Just my humble opinion.Perhaps you don't understand what "debate" means, for we are currently having a discussion presenting opposing viewpoints therefore, you are currently having a debate.If Edge of Favre came up with a season ending and possibly career ending injury then maybe your perspective would be different.No, there is nothing to debate.I'll debate it.
His skill as a runner, receiver and pass blocker is a commodity that many NFL team would love to have. Those that lack an established RB would love to take a shot at him next year and I can see him running in GB or in Houston next year or perhaps in a committee with someone else.
I would be happy, in a dynasty league, to take my chances with him on the end of my bench or on my IR list over most of the "young-never-will-bes" on the waiver wire right now
Actually, it does look like there is something to debate here.
Oh and by the way, if this is only "a young man's league" would you give me Edge James for Selvin Young or perhaps Alex Smith for Brett Farve?
If you think it's wise to hold an aging RB on your roster while he recovers from another ACL... that is your problem. But, I won't debate it.
Its opportunity cost. C'mon guys be creative... you can't find anything better to do with that roster spot?
And your opinion of Deuce long term is ?
Unfortunately, although we can just talk around the problem. Frankly, if you can grab him and put him on IR, there's no cost, so he's worth that.He's a guy with a track record of success, which has some value. For some of the names out there: I'd take Young or Keith ahead of Deuce, probably MRobinson as well - I like him. Young & Keith are the backups in great offenses.Deuce is probably at best a commitee back from here out. So you're looking at whether that has value.
I would have gone with "master-debating" here - a little more linguistically accurate and still makes the point. Let's put in a little effort here people.
None of them will ever make it off your bench. If they do, your dynasty team is trash.
Not every league has an IR spot. If you can stick him there, then fine... that is pretty obvious. The same situation applies if you have deep rosters. However, many leagues do have limited roster sizes and the cost of holding Deuce for an extended time for a questionable pay-off is that roster spot. And what is the value of that roster spot? The implication of people scoring points is that they're still playing and could be helpful to your team THIS year. Who said he was limited to picking up one of the above? These were guys identified as having little promise, which may/may not be true. Instead of taking the glass half empty perspective, why not be more optimistic and find someone you think has upside and/or a potential opportunity, like a Brian Calhoun. How about a guys who could be a UFA next season? Another option is to use the roster spot for a handcuff. There is more than one owner out there this week who wishes they handcuffed SJax or Rudi.im not sure where i have him ranked #RB wise...but...IR spot is lovely. 18-20+ man roster is worth one spot. Chris Henry, Kenton Keith, Selvin Young, MRobinson will ALL be worth less than Deuce when he comes back next season. Rostering Deuce for another year or two with the upside of a RB2 or RB3, easily doubles the value any of your named rbs now or ever. Spot fanasy starters vs a sure-fire real-life starter. Easy choice. Too bad your intuition points you in the wrong direction. Way to take the high road by saying all these guys will score more points than deuce this year.None of them will ever make it off your bench. If they do, your dynasty team is trash. Only person really worth having carries a big IF around his neck. And that is Kenton Kieth, waiting for Addai to be banged up allowing him to fill in for a week or two at best. You are the person to needs to show some creativity.
