Monorail=convenience. Especially with little kids. My wife would like to stay there the next time. I'm pushing for Animal Kingdom Villas. We have only done the cheap hotels (pop century, sports) and Carribean Beach. I would only stay at Carribean Beach if it was dirt cheap. I hated my expeirience there.
Wilderness Lodge was the best of both worlds IMO. They had a boat that would take you right to Magic Kingdom and another that would take you to the Contemporary to ride on the monorail. It was like a 5 minute boat ride over to Contemporary and like 15 over to Magic Kingdom.
Just got back on Saturday (Me, wifie, and 2 kids-5 and 1 yrs old) and I can't recommend the Contemporary enough—Actually we stayed at the Bay Lake Tower which is right next to the Contemp and as close as you can be to the MK. We had a theme park view, 12th floor, that we could see from Space Mtn to Castle and through to Splash Mtn. Most of the nights we watched the fireworks from our balcony to avoid the crazy crowds, plus they pipe in the music through a special channel on the room TV.It was a 5 minute walk from the door of our resort to the entrance of MK, with only crossing 1 street and the rest a private, paving stone walkway that was pretty well lit at night.There were no food places in the hotel, but the 5th floor had a covered walkway to the main level of the Contemp. where Chef Mickey's is as well as a pretty good quick serve and some shops. 1 lv up from that was the monorail. We thought we would use it more, but the route to the MK was around the lake and stopping at the other 2 MK resorts, so we just walked.Pool was great, deep enough to get wet, but shallow enough for the kids, with a good, twisting water slide that I couldn't pry my daughter off of. The also had a nice kiddie area with that fountain-type water spouts for the 1 yr old to run around on. Attached to that was a small beach area, hot tub and a nightly fire pit lit. Between them was a place to rent boats, para-sail and water ski/wake board.I recommend getting a smartphone app that yells you the wait times all over the park. Came in huge when we were moving from attraction to attraction bc we could just look at that and not have to go to each attraction first just to see the fastpass or wait times.