I may occasionally, and i mean occasionally bring a ranking up that i dont neccassarily agree with for discussion, but this is the first time i am bringing one up for what i think to be undeniably wrong.I know you make alot of gutsy calls, as a matter of fact part of the reason i originally payed for the services here at FBG is because of Shane Matthews and his #4(i think 4, but high whatever it was) ranking in week one a few years back. As it turned out, he went on to throw 3 TD passes that game, and i was sold. I dont know exactly how you rank your players, but i assume it comes directly from your projections. So maybe while you were inputting the numbers it happened that Mccown came out to be ranked higher than Peyton. What i would like to know, if Peyton and Mccown were your only two options at QB this week in a real league, would you start Mccown over Peyton Manning?Disclaimer, i have Peyton Manning and Josh Mccown in the same league, so this post could be considered a who do i start. Trust me though, if i got 1000 replies saying i should start Mccown and none saying i should go with Manning, it would not make me even consider benching Manning for Mccown. Also, i know it is possible that Mccown finishes higher than Manning, and that i may be setting myself up here to look really stupid, but i was just wondering does David put in his numbers and leave them as is, or does he go through the cheatsheets after and ask himself "would i really start player A over player B?"
Last edited by a moderator: