[DYNASTY] Overall Player Rankings (1 Viewer)

[snorlax]

Runoff of this poll.

 

[wannabee]

I have had Wayne has top pick for a couple. Decision became Julius or Chester. Chose Julius. So, Wayne, Julius, Chester

 

[aposulli]

Definitly agree Wayne... Chestor over Julius... Both have competition concerns... If Vikings take a RB in the draft, then I'd say Jones.

 

[Keg]

Definitly agree Wayne... Chestor over Julius... Both have competition concerns... If Vikings take a RB in the draft, then I'd say Jones.

i just dont get why people think this way about Minn and the RB situationJulius has FAR more to worry about then Chester does

 

[-OZ-]

Definitly agree Wayne... Chestor over Julius... Both have competition concerns... If Vikings take a RB in the draft, then I'd say Jones.

i just dont get why people think this way about Minn and the RB situationJulius has FAR more to worry about then Chester does

For now, yes. If however, Minnesota takes DeAngelo Williams with 1.17, Chester drops a lot. I went Wayne, CT, JJ. I'm no longer convinced that JJ is the best RB on his team. (I think he is, but not certain)

 

[brewer]

If ballot stuffing indeed took place, Taylor doesn't even belong in this grouping.

Just my

 

[aposulli]

If ballot stuffing indeed took place, Taylor doesn't even belong in this grouping.

Just my

The Chestor Taylor lover(s) is MIA

 

[EBF]

Tom Brady

 

[Keg]

Definitly agree Wayne... Chestor over Julius... Both have competition concerns... If Vikings take a RB in the draft, then I'd say Jones.

i just dont get why people think this way about Minn and the RB situationJulius has FAR more to worry about then Chester does

For now, yes. If however, Minnesota takes DeAngelo Williams with 1.17, Chester drops a lot. I went Wayne, CT, JJ. I'm no longer convinced that JJ is the best RB on his team. (I think he is, but not certain)

i dont see that happening even if DeAngelo was there...Childress already addressed the RB spot when he got Chester...if DeAngelo fell to them you will either see them pass or deal the pick but i just dont see them taking a RB in Round 1 or even 2, 3 or 4 for that matter

 

[brewer]

Tom Brady

That's my point... Taylor is going to automatically be put in this runoff group ahead of a few guys who he has no business being ahead of yet in my opinion.Could he prove worthy, sure, I just think there are safer/surer dynasty picks.

 

[-OZ-]

Definitly agree Wayne... Chestor over Julius... Both have competition concerns... If Vikings take a RB in the draft, then I'd say Jones.

i just dont get why people think this way about Minn and the RB situationJulius has FAR more to worry about then Chester does

For now, yes. If however, Minnesota takes DeAngelo Williams with 1.17, Chester drops a lot. I went Wayne, CT, JJ. I'm no longer convinced that JJ is the best RB on his team. (I think he is, but not certain)

i dont see that happening even if DeAngelo was there...Childress already addressed the RB spot when he got Chester...if DeAngelo fell to them you will either see them pass or deal the pick but i just dont see them taking a RB in Round 1 or even 2, 3 or 4 for that matter

You are probably right. My point is simply that we don't know, and it really wouldn't surprise me.

 

[snorlax]

I certainly don't encourage ballot stuffing, and I might just let this go for a while and put Chester back in the next poll if he gets dominated. However, if he holds his own here, then he belongs either way. If you are reading this and you only want to screw around by messing up polls and things of that nature, I'm sure you could find a happier home somewhere like fftoday.

 

[snorlax]

Any suggestions for whom I should add in the next poll?

 

[aposulli]

Any suggestions for whom I should add in the next poll?

The only players that are worthy of a vote for the next poll IMO:QB

Brady, McNabb, E.Manning

RB

Lewis, Droughns, T.Jones, Parker, Foster

WR

D.Jack

TE

Gonzo, Heap, Shockey

Bulger still has lots of durability critics

The only other RBs I can think of have MAJOR knocks against them (Dunn- age, D.D.- Bush, Bell-doghouse, Dillon-age)

The other WRs are, I believe all in a tier below DJack. Those guys include Chambers, Moss, Ward, RoyWill, AJ, Burress, Walker

One thing I would not like to see is Maroney, Lendale White, Vernon Davis. I wasn't a big fan of the rookie voting when I saw Williams go so high. I could only support that ranking if he was in Denver or Indy (which doesnt seem likely to happen).

I'm not one of those guys who takes this whole thing overly-serious. I think it's been done right, and its good to have an idea of the consensous rankings, no matter how potentially flawed this system is.

Good work!