What's new
Fantasy Football - Footballguys Forums

Welcome to Our Forums. Once you've registered and logged in, you're primed to talk football, among other topics, with the sharpest and most experienced fantasy players on the internet.

[DYNASTY] Rookie Draft Rankings (1 Viewer)

Bojang0301

Omar4Heisman
This is my personal preference so don't rip me too hard. I am looking for guys I am overlooking and who you all think is too high or too low. Any ideas are welcome.

QB’s

1) Vince Young

2) Jay Cutler

3) Matt Leinhart

4) Brodie Croyle

5) Omar Jacobs

6) Bruce Gradkowski

7) Reggie McNeal

8) Charlie Whitehurst

9) Ingle Martin

10) Justin Holland

11) Darrell Hackney

12) Marcus Vick

RB’s

1) Reggie Bush

2) DeAngelo Williams

3) Lendale White

4) Laurence Maroney

5) Jerious Norwood

6) Joseph Addai

7) Maurice Drew

8) Brian Calhoun

9) Jerome Harrison

10) Dontrell Moore

11) Mike Bell

12) Gerald Riggs

13) Cedric Humes

14) Leon Washington

15) Quinton Ganther

WR’s

1) Santonio Holmes

2) Chad Jackson

3) Sinorice Moss

4) Maurice Stovall

5) Martin Nance

6) Derek Hagan

7) Greg Jennings

8) Brandon Marshall

9) Jonathan Orr

10) Demetrius Williams

11) Brandon Williams

12) Greg Lee

13) Devin Aromashodu

14) Mike Hass

15) Troy Bergeron

TE’s

1) Vernon Davis

2) Leonard Pope

3) Dominique Byrd

4) Mercedes Lewis

5) Anthony Fasano

6) Joe Klopfenstein

7) Tony Scheffler

8) Tim Day

9) TJ Williams

10) David Thomas

DE’s

1) Mario Williams

2) Manny Lawson

3) Kamerion Wimbly

4) Mathias Kiwanuka

5) Tamba Hali

6) Mark Anderson

7) Stanley McClover

8) Elvis Dumervil

9) Ray Edwards

10) Mike Kudla

DT’s

1) Broderick Bunkley

2) Haloti Ngata

3) Gabe Watson

4) Rodrique Wright

5) Claude Wroten

LB’s

1) AJ Hawk

2) Ernie Sims

3) Bobby Carpenter

4) Chad Greenway

5) DeMeco Ryans

6) Thomas Howard

7) D’Qwell Jackson

8) Abdul Hodge

9) Jon Alston

10) Roger McIntosh

DB’s

1) Michael Huff

2) Donte Whitner

3) Jason Allen

4) Jimmy Williams

5) Tye Hill

6) Ko Simpson

7) Daniel Bullocks

8) Antonio Cromartie

9) Darnell Bing

10) Jonathan Joseph

 
Last edited by a moderator:

Imedos

Footballguy
your rankings are very similar to mine.

I don't know whether that's good or bad. :unsure:

Just move around a few wrs due to preference, bump up Mercedes a notch, and bump down any lb that projects favorably to SOLB.

 

Raiders

Footballguy
This is my personal preference so don't rip me too hard. I am looking for guys I am overlooking and who you all think is too high or too low. Any ideas are welcome.

QB’s

1) Vince Young

2) Jay Cutler

3) Matt Leinhart

4) Brodie Croyle

5) Omar Jacobs

6) Bruce Gradkowski

7) Reggie McNeal

8) Charlie Whitehurst

9) Ingle Martin

10) Justin Holland

11) Darrell Hackney

12) Marcus Vick

RB’s

1) Reggie Bush

2) DeAngelo Williams

3) Lendale White

4) Laurence Maroney

5) Jerious Norwood

6) Joseph Addai

7) Maurice Drew

8) Brian Calhoun

9) Jerome Harrison

10) Dontrell Moore

11) Mike Bell

12) Gerald Riggs

13) Cedric Humes

14) Leon Washington

15) Quinton Ganther

WR’s

1) Santonio Holmes

2) Chad Jackson

3) Sinorice Moss

4) Maurice Stovall

5) Martin Nance

6) Derek Hagan

7) Greg Jennings

8) Brandon Marshall

9) Jonathan Orr

10) Demetrius Williams

11) Brandon Williams

12) Greg Lee

13) Devin Aromashodu

14) Mike Hass

15) Troy Bergeron

TE’s

1) Vernon Davis

2) Leonard Pope

3) Dominique Byrd

4) Mercedes Lewis

5) Anthony Fasano

6) Joe Klopfenstein

7) Tony Scheffler

8) Tim Day

9) TJ Williams

10) David Thomas

DE’s

1) Mario Williams

2) Manny Lawson

3) Kamerion Wimbly

4) Mathias Kiwanuka

5) Tamba Hali

6) Mark Anderson

7) Stanley McClover

8) Elvis Dumervil

9) Ray Edwards

10) Mike Kudla

DT’s

1) Broderick Bunkley

2) Haloti Ngata

3) Gabe Watson

4) Rodrique Wright

5) Claude Wroten

LB’s

1) AJ Hawk

2) Ernie Sims

3) Bobby Carpenter

4) Chad Greenway

5) DeMeco Ryans

6) Thomas Howard

7) D’Qwell Jackson

8) Abdul Hodge

9) Jon Alston

10) Roger McIntosh

DB’s

1) Michael Huff

2) Donte Whitner

3) Jason Allen

4) Jimmy Williams

5) Tye Hill

6) Ko Simpson

7) Daniel Bullocks

8) Antonio Cromartie

9) Darnell Bing

10) Jonathan Joseph
Sorry but I have to say I dissagree. L White should not be the 3rd Rb on the board!!! Addai should be ahead of Norwood, Leinhart should be ahead of Cutler, and C Jackson MUST be the no.1 WR.
 

Bojang0301

Omar4Heisman
This is my personal preference so don't rip me too hard. I am looking for guys I am overlooking and who you all think is too high or too low. Any ideas are welcome.

QB’s

1) Vince Young

2) Jay Cutler

3) Matt Leinhart

4) Brodie Croyle

5) Omar Jacobs

6) Bruce Gradkowski

7) Reggie McNeal

8) Charlie Whitehurst

9) Ingle Martin

10) Justin Holland

11) Darrell Hackney

12) Marcus Vick

RB’s

1) Reggie Bush

2) DeAngelo Williams

3) Lendale White

4) Laurence Maroney

5) Jerious Norwood

6) Joseph Addai

7) Maurice Drew

8) Brian Calhoun

9) Jerome Harrison

10) Dontrell Moore

11) Mike Bell

12) Gerald Riggs

13) Cedric Humes

14) Leon Washington

15) Quinton Ganther

WR’s

1) Santonio Holmes

2) Chad Jackson

3) Sinorice Moss

4) Maurice Stovall

5) Martin Nance

6) Derek Hagan

7) Greg Jennings

8) Brandon Marshall

9) Jonathan Orr

10) Demetrius Williams

11) Brandon Williams

12) Greg Lee

13) Devin Aromashodu

14) Mike Hass

15) Troy Bergeron

TE’s

1) Vernon Davis

2) Leonard Pope

3) Dominique Byrd

4) Mercedes Lewis

5) Anthony Fasano

6) Joe Klopfenstein

7) Tony Scheffler

8) Tim Day

9) TJ Williams

10) David Thomas

DE’s

1) Mario Williams

2) Manny Lawson

3) Kamerion Wimbly

4) Mathias Kiwanuka

5) Tamba Hali

6) Mark Anderson

7) Stanley McClover

8) Elvis Dumervil

9) Ray Edwards

10) Mike Kudla

DT’s

1) Broderick Bunkley

2) Haloti Ngata

3) Gabe Watson

4) Rodrique Wright

5) Claude Wroten

LB’s

1) AJ Hawk

2) Ernie Sims

3) Bobby Carpenter

4) Chad Greenway

5) DeMeco Ryans

6) Thomas Howard

7) D’Qwell Jackson

8) Abdul Hodge

9) Jon Alston

10) Roger McIntosh

DB’s

1) Michael Huff

2) Donte Whitner

3) Jason Allen

4) Jimmy Williams

5) Tye Hill

6) Ko Simpson

7) Daniel Bullocks

8) Antonio Cromartie

9) Darnell Bing

10) Jonathan Joseph
Sorry but I have to say I dissagree. L White should not be the 3rd Rb on the board!!! Addai should be ahead of Norwood, Leinhart should be ahead of Cutler, and C Jackson MUST be the no.1 WR.
I won't argue my top four rankings of RB's, top 3 QB's or top 3 WR's (It's been done to death and I am set right now until I see the situation they are in, so why argue?). Addai is a workout warrior who did underachieved on a great team in college. Norwood is a workout warrior who overachieved on a bad team in the SEC in college. I haven't seen too much of either but I will take the second scenario any day of the week.Norwood

YEAR ATT YDS AVG LNG TD REC YDS AVG LNG TD FUM LST

2002 66 394 6.0 51 0 5 47 9.4 31 0 0 0

2003 121 642 5.3 58 2 8 6 0.8 6 0 0 0

2004 195 1050 5.4 50 7 11 37 3.4 10 0 0 0

2005 191 1136 5.9 76 6 19 96 5.1 19 2 0 0

Addai

2002 80 438 5.5 63 4 6 81 13.5 42 0 0 0

2003 114 520 4.6 21 2 14 86 6.1 25 1 0 0

2004 101 680 6.7 53 3 26 294 11.3 38 4 0 0

2005 187 911 4.9 30 9 20 180 9.0 43 1 0 0

 

Tick

Footballguy
Why so low on Calhoun?

Coyle's ratings:

Calhoun 86

Norwood 75

On a scale that pretty much only goes from 60 to about 93, that's a huge gap from a respected prospect rater.

 

Bojang0301

Omar4Heisman
Why so low on Calhoun?

Coyle's ratings:

Calhoun 86

Norwood 75

On a scale that pretty much only goes from 60 to about 93, that's a huge gap from a respected prospect rater.
It isn't so much that I am down on Calhoun, just that I really like Norwood. I feel like the 4 I have after the big 4 are another tier. A case can be made for any of those guys and I probably wouldn't argue too much. All are 4.4 guys with good vision and strength for what their size is. I am thinking about moving Calhoun over Drew. While I think Drew has nice weight for his size he may be too small.
 

ConstruxBoy

Kate's Daddy
Why so low on Calhoun?

Coyle's ratings:

Calhoun 86

Norwood 75

On a scale that pretty much only goes from 60 to about 93, that's a huge gap from a respected prospect rater.
I was surprised by that when I got my Coyle. I respect his rankings, but I personally like Norwood better than Calhoun. I think Norwood is explosive, while Calhoun is merely quick. I also think that Calhoun looked good on a very good team with a great OLine and specialized blocking scheme, while Norwood looked good on Mississippi State. :D
 

beto

Footballguy
WR’s

10) Demetrius Williams
:mellow: Up, up, and away.
I will have to agree with that, at least above Orr. I really like Jennings and Marshall but I think I did put Williams too low.
I don't have Williams very high. The only reason I am watching him at all is because some of you think he's decent. I will be waiting for his name on draft day.
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Top