Dynasty Value Discussion Thread (4 Viewers)

[scothawk]

Just got offered achane for my MHJ in my keeper league. Notable players on my team already by position
Rb
Gibbs
JT

WR
AJB
JJ
chase
Garrett wilson
Odunze

Not ppr
Start 1/1/2/1 plus a couple flex.

Pondering it hard at the moment

qUITE THE ROSTER. mAYBE YO

Just got offered achane for my MHJ in my keeper league. Notable players on my team already by position
Rb
Gibbs
JT

WR
AJB
JJ
chase
Garrett wilson
Odunze

Not ppr
Start 1/1/2/1 plus a couple flex.

Pondering it hard at the moment

Quite the roster. Maybe you should ask the other 3 players in your league.

 

[InDitkaWeTrust]

Checking in on price of Tyreek Hill (Standard Scoring)

For my playoff push I was offered Tyreek Hill for JSN and 2 1st Round Rookie Picks (2026 and 2027)

I think that is too much to give. Would probably give JSN and 1st Rounder.

Thoughts as to Tyreek Hill's value.

That's a HUGE overpay. I'm not sure at this point if I'd give up JSN for Tyreek straight up.

 

[Birdie048]

Checking in on price of Tyreek Hill (Standard Scoring)

For my playoff push I was offered Tyreek Hill for JSN and 2 1st Round Rookie Picks (2026 and 2027)

I think that is too much to give. Would probably give JSN and 1st Rounder.

Thoughts as to Tyreek Hill's value.

That's a HUGE overpay. I'm not sure at this point if I'd give up JSN for Tyreek straight up.

AGREED! JSN is rising and this is a major overpay. Personally, I would NOT give JSN + a single 1st for Tyreek
Lockett is fading, Metcalf is hurt but will remain in SEA. JSN is part of the bright future.

 

[BearsFan4Life]

Checking in on price of Tyreek Hill (Standard Scoring)

For my playoff push I was offered Tyreek Hill for JSN and 2 1st Round Rookie Picks (2026 and 2027)

I think that is too much to give. Would probably give JSN and 1st Rounder.

Thoughts as to Tyreek Hill's value.

That's a HUGE overpay. I'm not sure at this point if I'd give up JSN for Tyreek straight up.

AGREED! JSN is rising and this is a major overpay. Personally, I would NOT give JSN + a single 1st for Tyreek
Lockett is fading, Metcalf is hurt but will remain in SEA. JSN is part of the bright future.

Thanks for your input. Hill is a luxury not a need as I have ARSB, Collins, Aiyuk, Dell, and JSN as my main WR (start 1 or 2 max) More trying to keep him away from another contender or 2 is all.

 

[Birdie048]

Thanks for your input. Hill is a luxury not a need as I have ARSB, Collins, Aiyuk, Dell, and JSN as my main WR (start 1 or 2 max) More trying to keep him away from another contender or 2 is all.

While that has MERIT, it would have to be an "economical" move ... that is almost a future crippling deal.

While keeping 30 yo Tyreek away from other "contenders" is a move, let them overpay.

Good FBG Premium Read

 

[finfansteve]

Just got offered achane for my MHJ in my keeper league. Notable players on my team already by position
Rb
Gibbs
JT

WR
AJB
JJ
chase
Garrett wilson
Odunze

Not ppr
Start 1/1/2/1 plus a couple flex.

Pondering it hard at the moment

qUITE THE ROSTER. mAYBE YO

Just got offered achane for my MHJ in my keeper league. Notable players on my team already by position
Rb
Gibbs
JT

WR
AJB
JJ
chase
Garrett wilson
Odunze

Not ppr
Start 1/1/2/1 plus a couple flex.

Pondering it hard at the moment

Quite the roster. Maybe you should ask the other 3 players in your league.

Ten team league which has been around since 1986. 6/10 original owners

 

[JamboTaylor]

Quick question

My RB’s are Aaron Jones (1 year) and Rachaad White (3 years)

Would you trade Devonta Smith (2 years) for Chuba Hubbard (4 years)?

My other WR’s are Zay Flowers (4 years), Jayden Reed (4 years), Tank Dell (4 years), Drake London (3 years), Cedric Tillman (4 years).

 

[joey]

Quick question

My RB’s are Aaron Jones (1 year) and Rachaad White (3 years)

Would you trade Devonta Smith (2 years) for Chuba Hubbard (4 years)?

My other WR’s are Zay Flowers (4 years), Jayden Reed (4 years), Tank Dell (4 years), Drake London (3 years), Cedric Tillman (4 years).

No way. I’ve ridden Chuba for the beginning of the season in one league and count myself lucky he’s done so well, but Brooks is in the mix this week and assumed to be the obvious future at RB in CAR. So you’re selling a solid WR for a soon-to-be backup RB imo.

 

[joey]

Quick question

My RB’s are Aaron Jones (1 year) and Rachaad White (3 years)

Would you trade Devonta Smith (2 years) for Chuba Hubbard (4 years)?

My other WR’s are Zay Flowers (4 years), Jayden Reed (4 years), Tank Dell (4 years), Drake London (3 years), Cedric Tillman (4 years).

No way. I’ve ridden Chuba for the beginning of the season in one league and count myself lucky he’s done so well, but Brooks is in the mix this week and assumed to be the obvious future at RB in CAR. So you’re selling a solid WR for a soon-to-be backup RB imo.

And with that, the Panthers sign Chuba to a 4 yr deal. What the hell do I know?!

 

[gruecd]

Looking to trade Calvin Ridley's expiring contract. Buyer will have his services for the rest of this season and will have the right to match in next year's auction. Barring injuries, I don't have room for him in my lineup this season, and I have no intention of re-signing him after this season due to cap/roster constraints. I prefer not to lose him for nothing.

Is a 3rd-round pick in the rookie draft fair value?

 

[Birdie048]

Looking to trade Calvin Ridley's expiring contract. Buyer will have his services for the rest of this season and will have the right to match in next year's auction. Barring injuries, I don't have room for him in my lineup this season, and I have no intention of re-signing him after this season due to cap/roster constraints. I prefer not to lose him for nothing.

Is a 3rd-round pick in the rookie draft fair value?

He is currently valued around a Late 2025 2nd/early 3rd
But with your limited options and contract restrictions, early to mid 3rd is likely his value.
I am a Ridley owner and would move him for a late 2nd, but maybe not a 3rd (no contract issues, but Depth is key to success in my league)
He is my WR4 in PPR start 2-5 WR

 

[gruecd]

Looking to trade Calvin Ridley's expiring contract. Buyer will have his services for the rest of this season and will have the right to match in next year's auction. Barring injuries, I don't have room for him in my lineup this season, and I have no intention of re-signing him after this season due to cap/roster constraints. I prefer not to lose him for nothing.

Is a 3rd-round pick in the rookie draft fair value?

He is currently valued around a Late 2025 2nd/early 3rd
But with your limited options and contract restrictions, early to mid 3rd is likely his value.
I am a Ridley owner and would move him for a late 2nd, but maybe not a 3rd (no contract issues, but Depth is key to success in my league)
He is my WR4 in PPR start 2-5 WR

Yeah, he's my W4-5 behind Chase, Garrett Wilson, MHJ, and maybe Shakir. Also PPR, but start 2-4 WR. But I also have Bowers, Engram, and Otton, which makes the ol' lineup a little crowded.

 

[JamboTaylor]

Zay Flowers value check?

Been offered Worthy + 2nd

 

[King of the Jungle]

Zay Flowers value check?

Been offered Worthy + 2nd

The hope is that Worthy starts producing like Flowers, so I would keep Flowers for that.